Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

★★★☆☆
  • 55 Hutchinson Ave

    Columbus, OH 43235

    Map & Directions
  • 614-438-1000

3.1667 6
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse was?
Write a Review
.

This is the day after and my wife and I are still feeling unwell after eating there. The service was fine but it seems that the chief loves salt because the steaks, veg and potatos were covered with it. I can see now why it was mostly empty on a week night.

0
★☆☆☆☆

This is the day after and my wife and I are still feeling unwell after eating there. The service was fine but it seems that the chief loves salt because the steaks, veg and potatos were covered with it. I can see now why it was mostly empty on a week night.

Pros: quick service, no waiting during the week

Cons: Bad food and everything was covered with salt

.

Slow service, cold food, overdone steak, gave me the wrong dessert to go, didn't find out til I got home, seated 40 min after our reservation

0
★☆☆☆☆

Slow service, cold food, overdone steak, gave me the wrong dessert to go, didn't find out til I got home, seated 40 min after our reservation

.

In town on business- had dinner at the bar- lovely, warm, relaxing environment on a quiet Tuesday evening- Perfect dirty martini, friendly knowledgable bar tender- petite filet cooked to a PERFECT Medium- whole experience was highly enjoyable. I will defnitely return and highly recommend.

2
★★★★★

In town on business- had dinner at the bar- lovely, warm, relaxing environment on a quiet Tuesday evening- Perfect dirty martini, friendly knowledgable bar tender- petite filet cooked to a PERFECT Medium- whole experience was highly enjoyable. I will defnitely return and highly recommend.

Pros: Fantastic Food

Cons: pricey, but worth it if you don't mind paying for quality

.

I actually should have written months ago. I don't even live in Columbus, I was there for a business trip in January. The food was fine and the atmosphere was great. I remember chatting with the waitress (don't know her name, just know she was a petite dark-haired pretty girl with a pony tail). Before ordering, I chatted with her about the difference between the scallop and chicken dish. I finally ordered scallop, but my order came as chicken. I didn't think that's a big deal as I was hungry and just wanted to finish dinner soon and get back to the hotel, and that made sense since we chatted about scallop and chicken beforehand anyway. But then she realized that she brought me the wrong order, and came to my table to apologize. She told me to pick a dessert that I like and it's going to be on her to make up for the mistake. When I was done with my dessert and going to pay for my meal, she told me, "You're all set!" so she didn't even charge me for the main dish and she insisted. Oh my! I've never experienced such treatment even in Seattle where I come from. Best of compliment to this restaurant and the way they treat their customers.

1
★★★☆☆

I actually should have written months ago. I don't even live in Columbus, I was there for a business trip in January. The food was fine and the atmosphere was great. I remember chatting with the waitress (don't know her name, just know she was a petite dark-haired pretty girl with a pony tail). Before ordering, I chatted with her about the difference between the scallop and chicken dish. I finally ordered scallop, but my order came as chicken. I didn't think that's a big deal as I was hungry and just wanted to finish dinner soon and get back to the hotel, and that made sense since we chatted about scallop and chicken beforehand anyway. But then she realized that she brought me the wrong order, and came to my table to apologize. She told me to pick a dessert that I like and it's going to be on her to make up for the mistake. When I was done with my dessert and going to pay for my meal, she told me, "You're all set!" so she didn't even charge me for the main dish and she insisted. Oh my! I've never experienced such treatment even in Seattle where I come from. Best of compliment to this restaurant and the way they treat their customers.

.

Food was done well. The side portions are huge and are an acent themsleves. If you get a side it serves two to three easily. Atmosphere was romantic, but a bit on the cold side. Wear long sleves.

2
★★★★★

Food was done well. The side portions are huge and are an acent themsleves. If you get a side it serves two to three easily. Atmosphere was romantic, but a bit on the cold side. Wear long sleves.

.

Hyde park has an excellent steak. Their steak menus revolve around celebrity named entrees. They deliberately cook their steaks a little rare, so if you normally get medium rare, consider medium. Side dishes come separately from the entree.

PROS: Great steaks
CONS: pricey

4
★★★★☆

Hyde park has an excellent steak. Their steak menus revolve around celebrity named entrees. They deliberately cook their steaks a little rare, so if you normally get medium rare, consider medium. Side dishes come separately from the entree.

PROS: Great steaks
CONS: pricey

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Editorial from

The Worthington outpost of this restaurant family serves meaty cuts, seafood and specialty items in a warm setting. Relax in the bar and order cocktails plus a starter---perhaps oysters on the half shell or crab cakes---before heading in…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review