Milk & Cookies Bakery

★★★★★
  • 19 Commerce St 2

    New York, NY 10014

    Cross street: nr. Seventh Ave.

    Map & Directions
  • 212-243-1640

About Milk & Cookies Bakery

Categories
Hours
Daily, 11am-10pm

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Cafe Wha?

115 Macdougal St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Antique Cafe

55 West 26th Street New York, NY

5 34
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Milk & Cookies Bakery was?
Write a Review
.

My guy and I stopped by today after enjoying a play around the corner, at Cherry Lane. We thought the name was so cute that it had to be just as tasty. We were wrong. \r
We were not greeted, but just stared at, when we walked up to the

3
★★★★★

My guy and I stopped by today after enjoying a play around the corner, at Cherry Lane. We thought the name was so cute that it had to be just as tasty. We were wrong. \r
We were not greeted, but just stared at, when we walked up to the

.

I too spoke to a fresh manager. I am not sure they even know how their phone system works. Skip the frustration and go to one of the better options in the city!

3
★★★★★

I too spoke to a fresh manager. I am not sure they even know how their phone system works. Skip the frustration and go to one of the better options in the city!

.

The person taking my order, turns out to be the manager, sounded aggrieved to have to spend his time on the phone with me. I called two days later, the day that my client should have received the order, and nobody could find it. I was told

3
★★★★★

The person taking my order, turns out to be the manager, sounded aggrieved to have to spend his time on the phone with me. I called two days later, the day that my client should have received the order, and nobody could find it. I was told

Pros: I'm sure the cookies and presentation will be fine.

Cons: The manager and order process were each extremely difficult!

.

The cookies are delicious. It's the service that needs help. A couple of times I have walked in but was ignored for several minutes. One time I was told it was very busy and they'd be with me in a minute but there was no one else in the

3
★★★★★

The cookies are delicious. It's the service that needs help. A couple of times I have walked in but was ignored for several minutes. One time I was told it was very busy and they'd be with me in a minute but there was no one else in the

Pros: Delicious cookies

Cons: Bad service

.

I live a couple blocks from Milk and Cookies, and I must say, they do a very good chocolate chip cookie when they haven't been sitting out all day. Service can be a bit slack.. they once actually ran out of milk, so not only were they

3
★★★★★

I live a couple blocks from Milk and Cookies, and I must say, they do a very good chocolate chip cookie when they haven't been sitting out all day. Service can be a bit slack.. they once actually ran out of milk, so not only were they

Pros: good, home made cookies, bars and ice cream sandwiches

Cons: unbelievably inept service

.

I went to M&C on St Patty's day for the first time. The dark chocolate toffee cookie I ordered was hard and I can count how many chocolate chips is in that cookie (5 chips?). I was disappointed. Maybe because it was 11pm at night, the

3
★★★★★

I went to M&C on St Patty's day for the first time. The dark chocolate toffee cookie I ordered was hard and I can count how many chocolate chips is in that cookie (5 chips?). I was disappointed. Maybe because it was 11pm at night, the

Pros: Chocolate chip cookies, Double chocolate cookies, Long hours!!!

Cons: Dark chocolate chip cookies with toffee

.

new owners have destroyed this gem. the previous interior was adorable. it looks like a cheesy and cheap deli now. while the recipes were passed along from the previous owners, i think they neglected to give all the details as the

3
★★★★★

new owners have destroyed this gem. the previous interior was adorable. it looks like a cheesy and cheap deli now. while the recipes were passed along from the previous owners, i think they neglected to give all the details as the

Pros: cookies are just okay now

Cons: just not the same west village gem. there have to be other places.

.

I just finished reading some of the reviews for the adorably delicious Milk & Cookies. I have to say - I'm totally confused! Milk & Cookies has completely perked up the block. The owner clearly has a love of cookies and of serving them

3
★★★★★

I just finished reading some of the reviews for the adorably delicious Milk & Cookies. I have to say - I'm totally confused! Milk & Cookies has completely perked up the block. The owner clearly has a love of cookies and of serving them

Pros: UM FRESH BAKED COOKIES

Cons: not being able to get there as often as I'd like!

.

Hey this place is great. \r
\r
I had 3 cookies. (should have stopped at 2 but couldn't help myself). I highly recommend the chocolate chip, but apparently you can custom order cookies too. \r
\r
I loved that my friends and I could hang out

3
★★★★★

Hey this place is great. \r
\r
I had 3 cookies. (should have stopped at 2 but couldn't help myself). I highly recommend the chocolate chip, but apparently you can custom order cookies too. \r
\r
I loved that my friends and I could hang out

Pros: delicious cookies, inviting cafe

Cons: a lot of patrons

.

Having gone back to Milk and Cookies Bakery, I just love their new decor, its so clean and open. Who knew the place was THIS big? :-) Old, dusty curtains- be gone!\r
The cookies are better than ever and the overall quality of products is

3
★★★★★

Having gone back to Milk and Cookies Bakery, I just love their new decor, its so clean and open. Who knew the place was THIS big? :-) Old, dusty curtains- be gone!\r
The cookies are better than ever and the overall quality of products is

.

I am disgusted with the "transformation" of this quaint little bakery in our neighborhood. The new owner is rude to her employees--INFRONT of customers and while standing there, didn't even acknowledge us--the customers. The poor girls

3
★★★★★

I am disgusted with the "transformation" of this quaint little bakery in our neighborhood. The new owner is rude to her employees--INFRONT of customers and while standing there, didn't even acknowledge us--the customers. The poor girls

Pros: The neighborhood

Cons: The new owner

.

I WAS a regular customer at this quaint little cookie shop...I thoroughly enjoyed the cookies, the staff, and the owners, Marc and Jen. Since selling the bakery to a godzilla-like woman last month, things have all gone to hell there. I

3
★★★★★

I WAS a regular customer at this quaint little cookie shop...I thoroughly enjoyed the cookies, the staff, and the owners, Marc and Jen. Since selling the bakery to a godzilla-like woman last month, things have all gone to hell there. I

Pros: Being able to visit the place before it was sold.

Cons: New owner, stale product.

.

Don?t be fooled by previous rave reviews! Unquestionably the worst cookies ever! I learned the hard way! With the departure of its original owners last month - Jennifer and Marc Limotte - went a charming West Village favorite! Gone

3
★★★★★

Don?t be fooled by previous rave reviews! Unquestionably the worst cookies ever! I learned the hard way! With the departure of its original owners last month - Jennifer and Marc Limotte - went a charming West Village favorite! Gone

Pros: The name - Milk and Cookies Bakery

Cons: Hard, flavorless cookies

.

The service was very friendly and helpful. We got our custom order of cookies very promptly and they were delicious. They don't skimp on the ingredients so each cookie was bursting with chocolate chips and the cookies stayed chewy for a

3
★★★★★

The service was very friendly and helpful. We got our custom order of cookies very promptly and they were delicious. They don't skimp on the ingredients so each cookie was bursting with chocolate chips and the cookies stayed chewy for a

.

I placed an order from across the country for delivery on the Upper East Side. Customer service was excellent, especially since I changed delivery times on day of delivery. Cookies arrived fresh at the requested time change. Will

3
★★★★★

I placed an order from across the country for delivery on the Upper East Side. Customer service was excellent, especially since I changed delivery times on day of delivery. Cookies arrived fresh at the requested time change. Will

.

The chocolate chip is quite nice and makes you close your eyes with delight. Buy some for the loves in our life and after dinners out stop by and sneak a few for yourself.

3
★★★★★

The chocolate chip is quite nice and makes you close your eyes with delight. Buy some for the loves in our life and after dinners out stop by and sneak a few for yourself.

.

This place was just what I needed in the neighborhood when it first opened. Cozy, cute and a great spot to meet up with friends! However, I refuse to go here anymore! My last few experiences have been awful! Everytime I go in the

3
★★★★★

This place was just what I needed in the neighborhood when it first opened. Cozy, cute and a great spot to meet up with friends! However, I refuse to go here anymore! My last few experiences have been awful! Everytime I go in the

.

I brought my parents here to enjoy a "home-made" treat. Instead we encountered rude service and lousy food. The chocolate chip cookie was stale and lacked any hint of flavor. The walnut brownie had one walnut in it and was also stale.

3
★★★★★

I brought my parents here to enjoy a "home-made" treat. Instead we encountered rude service and lousy food. The chocolate chip cookie was stale and lacked any hint of flavor. The walnut brownie had one walnut in it and was also stale.

Cons: all

.

Every time I have walked into this place (and friends have confirmed the experience) I feel like the girl behind the counter (no matter which one it is) wonders why the hell someone would dare bother her. Umm, do you actually WANT

3
★★★★★

Every time I have walked into this place (and friends have confirmed the experience) I feel like the girl behind the counter (no matter which one it is) wonders why the hell someone would dare bother her. Umm, do you actually WANT

Pros: Brownies

Cons: AWFUL service

.

The cookies were sweet and delicious, and the service was sweet too. The guy at the counter warmed up my cookie for me and didn't seem to mind when I asked him for both milk and cream in my coffee. I'll definitely go back.

3
★★★★★

The cookies were sweet and delicious, and the service was sweet too. The guy at the counter warmed up my cookie for me and didn't seem to mind when I asked him for both milk and cream in my coffee. I'll definitely go back.

Pros: GOOD VARIETY, organic milk

.

I needed a break from my homework and my friend suggested this place. It was so much fun. They have so many great options. I went with 3 peanut butter chocolate chip cookies and green tea. I will definitely go back.

3
★★★★★

I needed a break from my homework and my friend suggested this place. It was so much fun. They have so many great options. I went with 3 peanut butter chocolate chip cookies and green tea. I will definitely go back.

.

We visited this cute shop when we were in New York for a vacation. Absolutely adorable. We picked up a gift tin to bring back to my mom. I highly recommend this place and wish there were one in LA.

3
★★★★★

We visited this cute shop when we were in New York for a vacation. Absolutely adorable. We picked up a gift tin to bring back to my mom. I highly recommend this place and wish there were one in LA.

.

These are simply the best cookies I ever had. The peanut butter cookie was so rich and decadent it should be rated NC-17. Also try the oatmeal raisin and chocolate mint.
This place is well worth the trip I made from uptown

3
★★★★★

These are simply the best cookies I ever had. The peanut butter cookie was so rich and decadent it should be rated NC-17. Also try the oatmeal raisin and chocolate mint.
This place is well worth the trip I made from uptown

.

The cookies were delicious. Also try the egg nog latte for the Holidays.

3
★★★★★

The cookies were delicious. Also try the egg nog latte for the Holidays.

.

We had a great time making our own cookies at a Design Your Own party. It's a great idea and the girls had a fabulous time. The cookies were delicious.

3
★★★★★

We had a great time making our own cookies at a Design Your Own party. It's a great idea and the girls had a fabulous time. The cookies were delicious.

.

I will never go here again! My girlfriends and I were having a M&C craving and was I disappointed. The service was terrible. they were so unhelpful and made us feel unwanted. Such an awkward experience. Were we inappropriate to just want

3
★★★★★

I will never go here again! My girlfriends and I were having a M&C craving and was I disappointed. The service was terrible. they were so unhelpful and made us feel unwanted. Such an awkward experience. Were we inappropriate to just want

Cons: Service, Service, Service

.

M&C is well located in w.village, tucked away on a quiet tree lined block. A great place to stop when you're taking in the west village and want to get away from the crowds. As for the cookies, Awesome. I have a big sweet tooth and have

3
★★★★★

M&C is well located in w.village, tucked away on a quiet tree lined block. A great place to stop when you're taking in the west village and want to get away from the crowds. As for the cookies, Awesome. I have a big sweet tooth and have

.

I went here tonight, hoping to find a really quaint, cute spot where one can get freshly baked cookies that are warm, gooey and fantastic, but I was sorely disappointed to find that the service was awful (the woman at the counter was really mean), and the cookies weren't really that great. They weren't warm or gooey - mainly just greasy and sugary, and the chocolate chip cookies (which one would *think* should be their top-seller and absolute best) were tasteless. I was sorely disappointed. Try other places on Bleeker nearby instead.

2
★★☆☆☆

I went here tonight, hoping to find a really quaint, cute spot where one can get freshly baked cookies that are warm, gooey and fantastic, but I was sorely disappointed to find that the service was awful (the woman at the counter was really mean), and the cookies weren't really that great. They weren't warm or gooey - mainly just greasy and sugary, and the chocolate chip cookies (which one would *think* should be their top-seller and absolute best) were tasteless. I was sorely disappointed. Try other places on Bleeker nearby instead.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Selection of many would-be favorites and all very tasty. Many choices worth coming back for and find the quality that seems to be the result of careful attention to detail. Great tastes and fun to visit.

3
★★★★★

Selection of many would-be favorites and all very tasty. Many choices worth coming back for and find the quality that seems to be the result of careful attention to detail. Great tastes and fun to visit.

.

i went to milk and cookies with a girlfriend who had heard of the place on the today show. when we arrived, the place looked adorable - like quaint, old country kitchen - and smelled amazing - like, well, cookies. i ordered an oatmeal

3
★★★★★

i went to milk and cookies with a girlfriend who had heard of the place on the today show. when we arrived, the place looked adorable - like quaint, old country kitchen - and smelled amazing - like, well, cookies. i ordered an oatmeal

Pros: good variety, decor and atmosphere

Cons: subpar cookies, inadequate waitstaff

.

The cookies are great, even better with ice cream or a shake. the brownies and bar cookies are equally fantastic - a sweet-tooth's heaven!

3
★★★★★

The cookies are great, even better with ice cream or a shake. the brownies and bar cookies are equally fantastic - a sweet-tooth's heaven!

.

Milk & Cookies is an absolute GEM! The owners have struck gold in this place. You have some many choices it's almost impossible to decide what to get. The S'Mores brownie is like no other s'more you'll ever have! Recommendation - order

3
★★★★★

Milk & Cookies is an absolute GEM! The owners have struck gold in this place. You have some many choices it's almost impossible to decide what to get. The S'Mores brownie is like no other s'more you'll ever have! Recommendation - order

Pros: Outrageous cookies, Friendly Staff, Huge selection

.

Milk and Cookies is ingenious! I went with two friends and had the smores bar - two yummy chocolate chip cookies with marshmallows and chocolate melted between, and they serve it piping hot! It was to die for. They'll make you custom

3
★★★★★

Milk and Cookies is ingenious! I went with two friends and had the smores bar - two yummy chocolate chip cookies with marshmallows and chocolate melted between, and they serve it piping hot! It was to die for. They'll make you custom

.

The cookies are nice and soft and good - just like Mom makes. I tried the "snickerdoodle" and it was my favorite. The generous servings of milk finish of this lovely treat.

3
★★★★★

The cookies are nice and soft and good - just like Mom makes. I tried the "snickerdoodle" and it was my favorite. The generous servings of milk finish of this lovely treat.

Pros: Good cookies, Large servings milk, Dog friendly!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Milk & Cookies Bakery, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review