Cotters

★★★★☆
  • 200 W Nationwide Blvd

    Columbus, OH 43215

    Map & Directions
  • 614-221-9060

About Cotters

Categories

Food

Food
More choices in Columbus:
Resultset_next

Alicia's Country Store & Grill

4955 Columbus St Washington, AR

Resultset_next

Pat's Burger Plus

1967 Main St Saratoga, AR

4.25 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Cotters was?
Write a Review
.

Cotters is by far may favorite lunch spot in town! It's patio in the warmer months puts you right on the Avenue and you can people watch for hours. Their food is a step above the rest. My favorite is the Tuna Salad - they meld together fresh tuna with veggies and just the right amount of spice for a fabulous lunch (or dinner). My second favorite is their Fish Tacos - before or after a game, they are perfect and always good. The servers there are outstanding. I have never had to ask for more water or a refill. Since it is within walking distance of pretty much anything you want to do for a night out, it is a great spot to grab a bite or just a drink with friends!

2
★★★★★

Cotters is by far may favorite lunch spot in town! It's patio in the warmer months puts you right on the Avenue and you can people watch for hours. Their food is a step above the rest. My favorite is the Tuna Salad - they meld together fresh tuna with veggies and just the right amount of spice for a fabulous lunch (or dinner). My second favorite is their Fish Tacos - before or after a game, they are perfect and always good. The servers there are outstanding. I have never had to ask for more water or a refill. Since it is within walking distance of pretty much anything you want to do for a night out, it is a great spot to grab a bite or just a drink with friends!

Pros: Never had a bad meal there

Cons: I can never decide what I want to eat

.

Cotter's is the prime dining spot in the Arena District. It is located in the heart of the entertainment district and provides a great alternative to your run-of-the-mill dining experience. The food in a word is incredible. The service is unparalleled and I go there with every given opportunity. It is right across the street from the amazing Arena Grand Movie Theatre, they are on the side of Nationwide Arena, and only short stroll from Huntington Park and other attractions. If you haven't been there you are missing out!

2
★★★★★

Cotter's is the prime dining spot in the Arena District. It is located in the heart of the entertainment district and provides a great alternative to your run-of-the-mill dining experience. The food in a word is incredible. The service is unparalleled and I go there with every given opportunity. It is right across the street from the amazing Arena Grand Movie Theatre, they are on the side of Nationwide Arena, and only short stroll from Huntington Park and other attractions. If you haven't been there you are missing out!

Pros: Location, great food, fantastic service, warm atmosphere

Cons: It's too cold to sit on patio in the winter

.

I love the patio at Cotters, it's a great place to sit and sip martinis before heading to a Clipper's game or a concert at the LC.

2
★★★★★

I love the patio at Cotters, it's a great place to sit and sip martinis before heading to a Clipper's game or a concert at the LC.

.

The first time we tried to go to Cotter's we weren't able to get in because the Blue Jackets were playing next door, but we decided to give it another shot on an off night and we're glad we did!

We decided to take our time and have quite a few courses, appetizer, salad, soup, entree and dessert! We had a few glasses of wine each and the manager was able to recommend exactly what would go well with each course we ordered. Not only did we get our fix on delicious food and wine, but we learned a lot too! Perfect place for a relaxed dinner, the dining room is gorgeous. We will be back for sure!

2
★★★★★

The first time we tried to go to Cotter's we weren't able to get in because the Blue Jackets were playing next door, but we decided to give it another shot on an off night and we're glad we did!

We decided to take our time and have quite a few courses, appetizer, salad, soup, entree and dessert! We had a few glasses of wine each and the manager was able to recommend exactly what would go well with each course we ordered. Not only did we get our fix on delicious food and wine, but we learned a lot too! Perfect place for a relaxed dinner, the dining room is gorgeous. We will be back for sure!

Pros: Great food and wine knowledge

Cons: Busy on Blue Jackets Nights

.

Cotters Calamari rocked my work. I usually pass on the squid but my boyfriend insisted that I try it. Wow what have I been missing I was hooked...unfortunately no one else in the city does it that good :( We have been going to cotters for date night now every couple of weeks just so I can get the Calamari!! Hans at the bar usually waits on us and he is a gem. So sweet and can mix a mean drink. Love those Dirty Bloody Mary??s!

2
★★★★★

Cotters Calamari rocked my work. I usually pass on the squid but my boyfriend insisted that I try it. Wow what have I been missing I was hooked...unfortunately no one else in the city does it that good :( We have been going to cotters for date night now every couple of weeks just so I can get the Calamari!! Hans at the bar usually waits on us and he is a gem. So sweet and can mix a mean drink. Love those Dirty Bloody Mary??s!

Pros: close to the Arena and Short North

Cons: pay for parking...but it's not that bad

.

I live in downtown Columbus, so Cotters is right in my backyard. I dine there often because I know that I will always have a fresh, delicious meal, but I won't break the bank. The chef specials are consistently fabulous! I often order take-out on my way home from the office, and the meals are just as good at home as they are at the restaurant!
I love the loft-style, yet intimate feel of the space. Service is always superb. Definitely the best restaurant in the Arena District!

2
★★★★☆

I live in downtown Columbus, so Cotters is right in my backyard. I dine there often because I know that I will always have a fresh, delicious meal, but I won't break the bank. The chef specials are consistently fabulous! I often order take-out on my way home from the office, and the meals are just as good at home as they are at the restaurant!
I love the loft-style, yet intimate feel of the space. Service is always superb. Definitely the best restaurant in the Arena District!

Pros: Great food, friendly service, neighborhood vibe

Cons: Very busy on Blue Jackets game nights

.

My friends and I tried Cotters after a movie at the Arena Grand Theater. A concert at the Arena had just let out, but we were seated pretty quickly and a round of drinks came over within just a few minutes. The drinks were delicious, and the selection rivals any other bar in town. The menu is eclectic with everything from salmon to burgers, and the food was served promptly and was nice and hot when served. All and all a great night! I'm definitely planning to come back!

2
★★★★☆

My friends and I tried Cotters after a movie at the Arena Grand Theater. A concert at the Arena had just let out, but we were seated pretty quickly and a round of drinks came over within just a few minutes. The drinks were delicious, and the selection rivals any other bar in town. The menu is eclectic with everything from salmon to burgers, and the food was served promptly and was nice and hot when served. All and all a great night! I'm definitely planning to come back!

Pros: great food and top notch service

Cons: not sure. we had a fantastic visit

.

Imagine going to a restaurant and after an hour and twenty minutes the only food that had made it to your table was the requiste basket of bread( which by the way was so so as best) . Despite numerous requests on our order's staus all we got were half truths that just prolonged the agony. We ended up leaving after being told the last time our order was now half way done. I was not sure if that meant the cook had just gotten back from the grocery or what. Cotters is no doubt a great place to go if you are on a serious diet, otherwise stay far, far away.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Imagine going to a restaurant and after an hour and twenty minutes the only food that had made it to your table was the requiste basket of bread( which by the way was so so as best) . Despite numerous requests on our order's staus all we got were half truths that just prolonged the agony. We ended up leaving after being told the last time our order was now half way done. I was not sure if that meant the cook had just gotten back from the grocery or what. Cotters is no doubt a great place to go if you are on a serious diet, otherwise stay far, far away.

Pros: Water was cold

Cons: Service,service, service

Editorial from

With items like blackened scallop salad and filet placed atop blue cheese mashed potatoes, and a roasted portobello cap with a Woodford Reserve demi-glace, it's easy to see that the line-up at Cotters Restaurant goes beyond ordinary arena…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Cotters, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review