Carmines

This had to be one of our all-time favorite places to have dinner. The portions are very large so plan on sharing. The chicken Scarpiello is the most amazing. Plan on waiting a while or make a reservation. Worth the wait.

Posted 11/25/08 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

I went to Carmine's on my birthday for a lunch/early dinner, and was happy with the entire experience. The meals are served family style, and the food is delicious. I loved the atmosphere also. The service was good, and for being in New York, the prices were decent. I would definitely go back!

Posted 10/13/08 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Carmine's is a good place to eat. The waitstaff is very energetic and friendly. It is a little strange because the menus are on the walls, but that is made up for since the food is so good. The portions are HUGE so it is definitely better to go with a big group and share a few things.

Posted 03/02/08 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Carmine's is a must do whenever we visit NYC. Food is ordered and served family-style, so go hungry. Menus are posted on the wall and don't panic when you see a price like $34.95 for baked ziti - that's the family style quantity price. It's best to go with at least 2 other people, the more the better because you can try more dishes. The antipasta platter appetizer is amazing - it's almost a meal in itself. You do need to love pasta and Italian food and garlic to eat here - there's even complimentary mouth wash in the bathrooms for all of that garlic!! If you can go for lunch or early afternoon, you will have a better chance of getting in. If you wait until late afternoon, you very well may be turned away because they will be booked for the evening. Make your plans based around theatre times also because of the close proximity. The upper west side location is just as good so if you want to go during busy theatre times, try it instead.

PROS: Unique family-style Italian dining in the heart of NYC.
CONS: Can experience long waits or be turned away completely on busy days.

Posted 04/06/06 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?