Insider Pages Reviews for Pagliacci Pizza

5 Stars: Best Pizza in Seattle (by DebReese)

DebReese — Fri, 24 Jul 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Not only the best pizza in seattle, probably some of the best pizza i have ever had! Great, fresh ingredients, and some of the best customer service I have ever received!!! Seriously!!! Wish there was one close to me on Capitol Hill!

5 Stars: Best Pizza in Seattle. (by ThatDude)

ThatDude — Fri, 26 Jun 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Pagliacci's is simply the best pizza place in Seattle. There pepperoni pizza is awesome. The delivery is usually fast. I order here so often that sometimes they don't charge me for the order. The Pagliacci salad is also really good, although I recommend it without garbanzo beans. If you're looking for a consistent, delicious pizza place in Seattle, go to Pagliacci's.

4 Stars: Good pizza (by Stephen k.)

Stephen k. — Wed, 10 Dec 2008 15:13:00 GMT

They make good pizza that tastes great but they don't sell by the slice. Also a down side to ordering from them is that they are a pretty expensive pizza place.

3 Stars: Pagliacci (by Lexie M.)

Lexie M. — Mon, 17 Nov 2008 10:55:00 GMT

Pagliacci pizza is greasy and excellent but expensive! As a college student at the UW, I live very close to this location but hardly ever go there- Lower their prices and i'm there every day

5 Stars: Great Story (by changnan)

changnan — Mon, 17 Nov 2008 01:00:00 GMT

For my money this is the best pizza in Seattle. I grab a couple slices here every week - usually pepperoni pizza at about $2.73 per slice, including tax. Great deal, especially since they use local, fresh ingredients and hand make their pies on site daily! Great story - to give an idea of how nice the employees and manager are - I ordered my customary two slices of pie in here last week and the manager told me the next pie would be ready in 5 minutes. It turned out the pie he was referring too was a whole pie order, not for slices, and that it would be a few more minutes for the next pie to be done baking. It was really no problem to begin with as I was reading the paper. Without prompting of any kind, one of the employees came over to me, delivered my money back and two piping hot slices. The manager - I think he was the manager - said "I hope it's OK - sorry about the wait and we hope you come back and try us again soon". Of course I said! It was a very gracious thing to do. It showed the quality of their service and Pagliacci Pizza as a company. This is what Nordstrom and Starbucks aim to be like - great service companies. That is what Pagliacci epitomizes.

3 Stars: Go for the AGOG Primo pizza (by K U.)

K U. — Tue, 04 Nov 2008 11:23:00 GMT

Pagliacci's pizza is hands down the best pizza that can come out of a franchise restaurant. Their salads are also great and the staff is very friendly. Another thing I love about Pagliacci's is that they offer great discounts for university students in the area. But the location is not ideal, especially for a late night bite.

4 Stars: how can you go wrong with pizza? (by Laura H.)

Laura H. — Wed, 23 Jan 2008 21:47:00 GMT

pagliacci is great pizza. i like having a location on the ave close to the UW campus. the pizza is great for the price and it is my favorite pizza in seattle!

4 Stars: Pretty good pizza (by kee22)

kee22 — Fri, 17 Nov 2006 01:00:00 GMT

I miss pagliacci's. It wasnt the best pizza, but it's pretty good. Now that I live in another state, I miss it. I liked getting pizza here and also the location in the hub. My favorites are their hawaiian, pepparoni, and cheese pizza. Their pizza by the slice is pretty affordable and their pies aren't expensive.

4 Stars: Mmm... (by northwesttrekker)

northwesttrekker — Thu, 19 Oct 2006 02:00:00 GMT

Pagliacci has the best pizza crust I've tasted outside of NYC. Chewy and crispy, their recipe is to die for.

I'd avoid the "Pesto Primo" pizza, though, if you don't like huge 2" diameter blobs of cold Ricotta cheese. *shudder*

5 Stars: Best Pizza! (by panacea)

panacea — Sat, 12 Nov 2005 01:00:00 GMT

In my opinion, Pagliacci's is hands down the best pizza in Seattle! The crispy thin crust combined with real mozzarella and a smorgasbord of toppings is what makes Pagliacci the great pizzaria it is. I am not a Seattle native which perhaps makes me a bit more vocal about Pagliacci's but trust me, if you want excellent pizza with some unique and delicious toppings, Pagliacci's is the place to go. Also, although some of their specialties can be a bit pricey, the original cheese is very cheap and still my favorite.

5 Stars: Pagliacci Delivery (by lld)

lld — Thu, 21 Aug 2003 02:00:00 GMT

I love this pizza! Not too greasy and a nice thin crust, and the large variety of options is a nice touch. Delivery is fast and the guys are friendly, the only downside is that it's expensive. That makes it an order out treat instead of a staple.

5 Stars: Keep it simple (by phoenix_68)

phoenix_68 — Thu, 07 Nov 2002 01:00:00 GMT

I love the original pizza and the centioli. Both are fresh, simple and very tasty. Unlike other reviewers, I liked the basic salad too. I've eaten at this location, but also had items delivered in a timely and very courteous manner. Note to visitors: the central delivery service WILL deliver to some of the downtown hotels.