Best New York Pizza

★★★★★
Best New York Pizza, Our Name Says It, Our Pizza Proves It!
  • 14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy

    Tampa, FL 33618

    Cross street: Ehrlich Rd

    Map & Directions
  • 813-963-7600

Food

Food
More choices in Tampa:
Resultset_next

Zerillos Italian Grill

11653 Countryway Blvd Tampa, FL

Resultset_next

Donatello

232 N Dale Mabry Hwy Tampa, FL

4.9167 12
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Best New York Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

They may not deliver but it is worth goin to. They have great customer service and AMAZING pizza. The name def. lives up to the product. If you haven't checked it out I would say you MUST see what you've been missing out on !!!! :)

2
★★★★★

They may not deliver but it is worth goin to. They have great customer service and AMAZING pizza. The name def. lives up to the product. If you haven't checked it out I would say you MUST see what you've been missing out on !!!! :)

.

First off just realize I'm in middle school and VERY good at finding the littlest things to criticize. But this is the BEST PIZZA ever! And the staff is amazingly polite! I plan on coming back as soon as possible!

2
★★★★★

First off just realize I'm in middle school and VERY good at finding the littlest things to criticize. But this is the BEST PIZZA ever! And the staff is amazingly polite! I plan on coming back as soon as possible!

.

I am a native New Yorker, moved to Tampa Florida 10 years ago. I really know New York PIZZA. Let me tell you this place is fantastic. This is real NEW YORK PIZZA. In fact their name - BEST NY PIZZA is 100% accurate. Their PIZZA is as good as, if not better than, any Pizza I ever had growing up in New York. Try it yourself, this place is as good as it gets. Beautiful place, freindly staff, and most importantly for me......GREAT PIZZA!

2
★★★★★

I am a native New Yorker, moved to Tampa Florida 10 years ago. I really know New York PIZZA. Let me tell you this place is fantastic. This is real NEW YORK PIZZA. In fact their name - BEST NY PIZZA is 100% accurate. Their PIZZA is as good as, if not better than, any Pizza I ever had growing up in New York. Try it yourself, this place is as good as it gets. Beautiful place, freindly staff, and most importantly for me......GREAT PIZZA!

.

This is the #1 pizza spot in the carrollwood area and possibly all of Tampa. Been going here for years and never get tired of their pizza. Definitely authentic NY pizza, not like the imitators that claim to be and taste nothing like it (and there are alot of them...) Wish they had delivery but not a dealbreaker. Still worth walking out of the house for a better tasting pizza!

2
★★★★★

This is the #1 pizza spot in the carrollwood area and possibly all of Tampa. Been going here for years and never get tired of their pizza. Definitely authentic NY pizza, not like the imitators that claim to be and taste nothing like it (and there are alot of them...) Wish they had delivery but not a dealbreaker. Still worth walking out of the house for a better tasting pizza!

.

Great food, great variety on the menu. You can dine in or carry-out,
I just wish they would deliver :)

5
★★★★★

Great food, great variety on the menu. You can dine in or carry-out,
I just wish they would deliver :)

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

AMAZING PIZZA! If your in the area you gotta try this place...their pizza is to die for! Their salads and other Italian favs are YUM too!! I was visiting Tampa from NYC and happened by this place with the bold name BEST NY PIZZA...& i gotta tell you they really do live up to it! I'm big on customer service & it was outstanding! Very welcoming and friendly staff...only flaw is they don't have another location in my home town...I'd definitely be a regular if they did:)

2
★★★★★

AMAZING PIZZA! If your in the area you gotta try this place...their pizza is to die for! Their salads and other Italian favs are YUM too!! I was visiting Tampa from NYC and happened by this place with the bold name BEST NY PIZZA...& i gotta tell you they really do live up to it! I'm big on customer service & it was outstanding! Very welcoming and friendly staff...only flaw is they don't have another location in my home town...I'd definitely be a regular if they did:)

.

Great pizza! Is usually packed every time I stop by but is very traditional, new york style is my favorite.

5
★★★★★

Great pizza! Is usually packed every time I stop by but is very traditional, new york style is my favorite.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This place is amazing! I'm starting to live off this pizza! I go there for lunch atleat 2 times a week and than I always go back to get another pizza to bring home for dinner! The crust is perfect! It folds in half (like it's supposed to) and a little bit of grease runs down your arm! Reminds me of home! :) The sauce is incredible it has a hint of sweetness to it! The Cheese is just the right amount of gooey! \r\n\r\nLOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!

2
★★★★★

This place is amazing! I'm starting to live off this pizza! I go there for lunch atleat 2 times a week and than I always go back to get another pizza to bring home for dinner! The crust is perfect! It folds in half (like it's supposed to) and a little bit of grease runs down your arm! Reminds me of home! :) The sauce is incredible it has a hint of sweetness to it! The Cheese is just the right amount of gooey! \r\n\r\nLOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!

Pros: Excellent food, Excellent Service Excellent Prices!

.

We're from NY, and used to enjoy getting pizza when we went back there on vacation. Now we skip on the pizza when we're in NY, because the best NY pizza's at home in Tampa!

2
★★★★★

We're from NY, and used to enjoy getting pizza when we went back there on vacation. Now we skip on the pizza when we're in NY, because the best NY pizza's at home in Tampa!

Pros: Best pizza in town

Cons: A little pricey

.

This is a great pizza place. It reminds me of Long Island Pizza I remember as a kid. \r\nThey try so hard to stay in business, I give credit to the guy who stands out by Dale Mabry all the time holding that pizza sign. Help keep this mom and pop pizza place we should keep in business.

2
★★★★☆

This is a great pizza place. It reminds me of Long Island Pizza I remember as a kid. \r\nThey try so hard to stay in business, I give credit to the guy who stands out by Dale Mabry all the time holding that pizza sign. Help keep this mom and pop pizza place we should keep in business.

Pros: Great Pizza

.

i love this place because the pizza is the freshest in the whole universe. they use a combination of dough,tomato sauce(with herbs and spices), and cheese to create the most delicious pizza. You even have the option to order it with different toppings such as onions and they even have pepperoni. I give this plce an A+ in deliciousness, A+ in great name selection, and an A+ in fancy cheese use. i would give it ten stars if my hands were big enough to carry them.

2
★★★★★

i love this place because the pizza is the freshest in the whole universe. they use a combination of dough,tomato sauce(with herbs and spices), and cheese to create the most delicious pizza. You even have the option to order it with different toppings such as onions and they even have pepperoni. I give this plce an A+ in deliciousness, A+ in great name selection, and an A+ in fancy cheese use. i would give it ten stars if my hands were big enough to carry them.

Pros: taste

.

This place is amazing! If you love NY Pizza than this is the place for you! You owe it to yourself to try it. Really, if you want true NY Pizza no other place compares, this is it! I'm a true New Yorker so I know what I'm talking about. Real New Yorkers will know this is for real and not so place that just calls themselves the best or even NY pizza!

2
★★★★★

This place is amazing! If you love NY Pizza than this is the place for you! You owe it to yourself to try it. Really, if you want true NY Pizza no other place compares, this is it! I'm a true New Yorker so I know what I'm talking about. Real New Yorkers will know this is for real and not so place that just calls themselves the best or even NY pizza!

Pros: ALL PROS! Food, Staff, Variety, Pricing! It's all great!

Cons: No Cons.. this place is the BEST!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Best New York Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review