Bagels By the Bay

★★★★★
  • 1235 Bay St

    Staten Island, NY 10305

    Map & Directions
  • 718-815-4447

About Bagels By the Bay

Hours
Mon-Fri 6 am-5 pm, Sat 6 am-4 pm, Sun 7 am-2 pm

Food

Food
More choices in Staten Island:
Resultset_next

Bagels & Buns

2491 Victory Blvd Staten Island, NY

Resultset_next

Hot Bagels

1307 Arthur Kill Rd Staten Island, NY

5 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Bagels By the Bay was?
Write a Review
.

This place is great, Theon your wrong, these reviews are from when the business was taken over by new management. When the new guys bought this place a couple of years ago, they turned this place around. Their bagels are ALWAYS fresh and

3
★★★★★

This place is great, Theon your wrong, these reviews are from when the business was taken over by new management. When the new guys bought this place a couple of years ago, they turned this place around. Their bagels are ALWAYS fresh and

.

Disregard all the positive reviews below, they are all from when this place was under old management. Ever since the new people bought it, the food is no longer fresh. The bagels have went from wonderful to gross.

3
★★★★★

Disregard all the positive reviews below, they are all from when this place was under old management. Ever since the new people bought it, the food is no longer fresh. The bagels have went from wonderful to gross.

.

i love this place clean great people fresh food all the time you guys should try this place

2
★★★★★

i love this place clean great people fresh food all the time you guys should try this place

Pros: best bagels in s.i

.

I've been living on the Island for 3 years now. We're a military family though I'm from NY originally. There is no better Bagel shop here on Staten Island, in my opinion. The bagels are fresh and HUGE every day, I've placed orders for dozens to take with me when I drive home to FL to give to our local Police/Fire Depts, they make sure they're always hot and ready for me the morning I leave. The guys are super friendly, remember you by face/name and always have a smile on their face. My favorite thing is to get a Roast Beef & Provolone w/ mayo, lettuce and tomato on a plain bagel. Best sandwich, hands down. 2 Thumbs up from this girl! :)

2
★★★★★

I've been living on the Island for 3 years now. We're a military family though I'm from NY originally. There is no better Bagel shop here on Staten Island, in my opinion. The bagels are fresh and HUGE every day, I've placed orders for dozens to take with me when I drive home to FL to give to our local Police/Fire Depts, they make sure they're always hot and ready for me the morning I leave. The guys are super friendly, remember you by face/name and always have a smile on their face. My favorite thing is to get a Roast Beef & Provolone w/ mayo, lettuce and tomato on a plain bagel. Best sandwich, hands down. 2 Thumbs up from this girl! :)

Pros: Best Bagels, Sandwiches, Customer Svc around

Cons: No cons...

.

This place is incredible bagels are so incredibly fresh and tasty nom nom nom....
The staff is very helpful and willing to serve

2
★★★★★

This place is incredible bagels are so incredibly fresh and tasty nom nom nom....
The staff is very helpful and willing to serve

Pros: delish. food

Cons: -

.

this place is the best, they have a very diverse menu to choose from, everything you want is there. they also have great coffee, and they do all of their cooking daily and on premises. and they also have very funny and friendly workers. you should deffinitely try this place, oh and did i mention, their prices are very good and decent.

2
★★★★★

this place is the best, they have a very diverse menu to choose from, everything you want is there. they also have great coffee, and they do all of their cooking daily and on premises. and they also have very funny and friendly workers. you should deffinitely try this place, oh and did i mention, their prices are very good and decent.

.

they have great bagels, and their staff or workers are very friendly and helpful, i always stop by for breakfast and lunch

2
★★★★★

they have great bagels, and their staff or workers are very friendly and helpful, i always stop by for breakfast and lunch

Pros: good food,fast service,clean

Cons: i wish there was more space to sit down

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Bagels By the Bay, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review