Blackstone Steakhouse

★★★★☆
Serving both steak and sushi, this upscale steakhouse offers an alternative to the typical "meat and potatoes" fare.
  • 10 Pinelawn Rd

    Melville, NY 11747

    Map & Directions
  • 631-271-7780

About Blackstone Steakhouse

Hours
Mon - Wed, 11:30am � 10pm; Tues, Fri, 11:30am � 11pm; Sat, 5pm � 11pm; Sun, 3pm � 9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Melville:
Resultset_next

Joes Dreyfus Store Restaurant

2731 Maringouin Rd W Livonia, LA

Resultset_next

False River Seafood

300 1/2 Hospital Rd New Roads, LA

4.0833 12
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Blackstone Steakhouse was?
Write a Review
.

Blackstone's is a superb restaurant! The manager, John is an outstanding asset and consummate professional, the staff is superb! The service and food is impeccable! If you want the BEST dining experience in NY, go to Blackstone's Melville.

3
★★★★★

Blackstone's is a superb restaurant! The manager, John is an outstanding asset and consummate professional, the staff is superb! The service and food is impeccable! If you want the BEST dining experience in NY, go to Blackstone's Melville.

.

* Pros: Great steaks
* Cons: couldn't find any

2
★★★★☆

* Pros: Great steaks
* Cons: couldn't find any

.

This is the place that gets it.
They do it right here, the food is top quality, the service is very professional, and the prices are reasonalble.
Keep it up guys, you are the best in town.

2
★★★★☆

This is the place that gets it.
They do it right here, the food is top quality, the service is very professional, and the prices are reasonalble.
Keep it up guys, you are the best in town.

.

They are masters at what they do. A unforgettable dining experience. A place not to miss if you are a steak lover. No place like in on either the North shore or the South shore of Long Island. The porterhouse for 2 can't be topped! I am hooked on this wonderful place. The service is remarkable as is the food. Excellent steak, sides and service. Very accommodating staff and a nice atmosphere. What more can I say?

2
★★★★★

They are masters at what they do. A unforgettable dining experience. A place not to miss if you are a steak lover. No place like in on either the North shore or the South shore of Long Island. The porterhouse for 2 can't be topped! I am hooked on this wonderful place. The service is remarkable as is the food. Excellent steak, sides and service. Very accommodating staff and a nice atmosphere. What more can I say?

.

I've been to them all, North Shore, South Shore, and Manhattan.
As far as I'm concerned this is the best. The best Steaks the best service and the prices are right. None of that typical bad Steak house attitudes are found here.

2
★★★★★

I've been to them all, North Shore, South Shore, and Manhattan.
As far as I'm concerned this is the best. The best Steaks the best service and the prices are right. None of that typical bad Steak house attitudes are found here.

.

I have dined at Blackstone several times, each experience outdoing the last! They have amazingggg sushi! my fave by far. The steaks are good too, but i'm more of a seafood & sushi lover. I have had a giant shrimp entree that was full of flavor and texture, but the shrimp were still raw in the center. (tsk tsk kitchen) Overall, this place is awesome though- the service is really great, many friendly people, the manager is available & caring (don't remember her name though-sorry!) and they have a beautiful fireplace too- volcano roll all the way! A+++++

2
★★★★★

I have dined at Blackstone several times, each experience outdoing the last! They have amazingggg sushi! my fave by far. The steaks are good too, but i'm more of a seafood & sushi lover. I have had a giant shrimp entree that was full of flavor and texture, but the shrimp were still raw in the center. (tsk tsk kitchen) Overall, this place is awesome though- the service is really great, many friendly people, the manager is available & caring (don't remember her name though-sorry!) and they have a beautiful fireplace too- volcano roll all the way! A+++++

.

The food here was really good but the prices are very very high. I wouldnt bring the family here but it is good for me and my husband. I havent been back because of the prices.

4
★★★★☆

The food here was really good but the prices are very very high. I wouldnt bring the family here but it is good for me and my husband. I havent been back because of the prices.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I would never go back. The food was good. They have both steak and sushi. However, if you are going to drop over $150 on a meal for two, the service should be excellent. The service was very slow we felt like we were forgotten most of the meal. Go to Ruth's Chris instead.

2
★★☆☆☆

I would never go back. The food was good. They have both steak and sushi. However, if you are going to drop over $150 on a meal for two, the service should be excellent. The service was very slow we felt like we were forgotten most of the meal. Go to Ruth's Chris instead.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Really nice steakhouse with a wine list that is out of this world. I have gone here on several occasions for business lunches and occasional dinner and every time the food was excellent.

5
★★★★★

Really nice steakhouse with a wine list that is out of this world. I have gone here on several occasions for business lunches and occasional dinner and every time the food was excellent.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is a very nice place to get a good steak. It is a little bit on the pricey side, but it is worth it. The staff is great and the atmosphere is really nice.

4
★★★★☆

This is a very nice place to get a good steak. It is a little bit on the pricey side, but it is worth it. The staff is great and the atmosphere is really nice.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I've dined at Blackstone on two separate occasions, and both experiences were very positive.
The hostesses are clearly hired for their looks rather than their tact and diplomacy, but the wait-staff is without fault. On both occasions we seemed to have two waiters assigned to our table, which was unusual but not disconcerting: we just had twice the help. The Sushi is incredible--we had the Spicy Roll, which included Jalape?os and Tuna. The salads are very good, including pear slices and candied pecans (pretty typical, but very well-executed). I thoroughly enjoyed the ribeye (too big to finish), but the much vaunted "hashbrowns" were not good at all. The broccoli with a hint of ginger likewise disappointed. On a previous occasion, I had the mignonettes of pork tenderloin, which was very well-seasoned and tender. I would recommend this restaurant to someone looking for a good steakhouse a notch above your Ruth's Chrises.

2
★★★★☆

I've dined at Blackstone on two separate occasions, and both experiences were very positive.
The hostesses are clearly hired for their looks rather than their tact and diplomacy, but the wait-staff is without fault. On both occasions we seemed to have two waiters assigned to our table, which was unusual but not disconcerting: we just had twice the help. The Sushi is incredible--we had the Spicy Roll, which included Jalape?os and Tuna. The salads are very good, including pear slices and candied pecans (pretty typical, but very well-executed). I thoroughly enjoyed the ribeye (too big to finish), but the much vaunted "hashbrowns" were not good at all. The broccoli with a hint of ginger likewise disappointed. On a previous occasion, I had the mignonettes of pork tenderloin, which was very well-seasoned and tender. I would recommend this restaurant to someone looking for a good steakhouse a notch above your Ruth's Chrises.

Pros: Great Sushi, Good Steaks

Cons: Hashbrowns/Broccoli aren't any good, clueless but pretty hostesses

.

went to blackstone the other night had an awful experience. first of all we waited 45 minutes for a table which we reserved for 8:30pm. they didn't even offer us a drink or anything to compensate for the long wait. i heard a lot of people complaining about the wait and some were offered a round or complimentary appetizer. dinner was just ok and nothing special. i've been to their other restaurants and felt that i was treated much better. the sushi was good but not worth the price. we had to ask our server over and over again for things such as steak sauce and drinks. no one, not even the server, asked us how everything was. i guess they know.

0
★☆☆☆☆

went to blackstone the other night had an awful experience. first of all we waited 45 minutes for a table which we reserved for 8:30pm. they didn't even offer us a drink or anything to compensate for the long wait. i heard a lot of people complaining about the wait and some were offered a round or complimentary appetizer. dinner was just ok and nothing special. i've been to their other restaurants and felt that i was treated much better. the sushi was good but not worth the price. we had to ask our server over and over again for things such as steak sauce and drinks. no one, not even the server, asked us how everything was. i guess they know.

Pros: none that i can think of

Cons: long wait, poor service, bad food

Editorial from

This Long Island restaurant serves up traditional steak dishes and sides, but you'll also find sushi, sashimi, and a welcoming setting to boot. The stone facade, dark hardwood floors and expansive room centered by a fireplace evoke the…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Blackstone Steakhouse, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review