Mustang Grill

Message from Mustang Grill

Southwestern and Tex-Mex cuisine, plus more than 100 tequilas, outdoor dining, big-screen TVs, cigars for sale and more.
  • Brunch
  • Private Parties
  • Hand-rolled Imported Cigars

Mustang Grill is a trendy Southwestern restaurant and features exceptional and creative regional cuisines. There is a lively bar with a selection of over 100 different premium tequilas. Mustang also has one of the largest cigar selections in Manhattan, with over 50 hand-rolled imported cigars. The restaurant boasts nine big screen TVs, outdoor dining and private party rooms. Other features include Monday Night Lobster and Karaoke from 9:30-close, Tuesday Night Paella and Thursday through Saturday live Dj's.

Editorial and merchant content by Citysearch

Marker Mustang Grill

(212) 744-9194

1633 2nd Ave New York, NY 10028
Write a Review

Editorial Description by Citysearch
Southwestern and Tex-Mex cuisine, plus more than 100 tequilas, outdoor dining, big-screen TVs, cigars for sale and more.

68 Reviews of Mustang Grill in New York

Have experience with this business? Write a review


Party while you eat  4 Star Rating - Very good

By Melissa F. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 2,990

Mustang is a great place to have Happy Hour and have fun at the same time. The food is okay, but you go there for the atmosphere and the decor. If you're looking for a quiet place, this is not it.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)

Great for Drinks and Apps  3 Star Rating - Satisfactory

By Millie G. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 2,566

This bar/restaurant has a variety of tex-mex offerings and some great frozen drinks. The outdoor seating is really great when the weather is nice. An overall fun place to have a drink and food with friends.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)

Mustang Grill  4 Star Rating - Very good

By A S. | insider_guru Insider Guru | Rank: 405

This place is a restaurant and party all in one (even though dancing is strictly prohibited by the numerous signs on the walls). The food and drinks are really very good and the atmosphere is colorful and loud. A good way to start or end a fun night out on the Upper East Side!

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)
Latest reviews by Citysearch: (read all 65 reviews on Citysearch)

good atmosphere, so-so food, ues locals 4 Star Rating - Very good

By averagejoe10021

one of the better spots on second avenue followed by the stumble inn and brother jimmys. so-so food.

Posted 02/27/09

Late at Night on weekends! 2 Star Rating - Wouldn't recommend

By maryanmil

If you're craving a burrito or some tacos late at night, you definitely need to come here!

The decor is colorful and the clientele is diverse. Not exactly the cleanest place..but the food is just what one is looking for late at night or after a sweaty basketball game!

Have fun!

Posted 07/05/08

Make sure to check out the specials!!!! 5 Star Rating - World class

By firmbizz1102

My boyfriend and I went to eat at Mustang Grill last Thursday. We sat down, and the server took our order for my favorite strawberry margaritas. Before she left she suggested and explained a few things on the "specials menu". She was very nice and the restaurant was very busy. I appreciated that she was taking her time to explain to us what they had and was not rushing because I knew she was very busy. I have been there to eat a few times now and never really paid attention to exactally what was on the specials menu but from now on I?m going to make sure I do because the food was so delicious!!! We shared the tilapia and the soft crab shell salad, which I highly recommend to anyone who enjoys seafood. There were both so yummy. So to all those who eat at Mustang Grill, pay attention to the specials, they are unbelievable!!

Pros: food and service were both great!
Posted 06/30/08

Awesome time at Mustang Grill!!!! 5 Star Rating - World class

By chicitarosita

My friends and I held a birthday part a Mustang Grill the other night. We had a really good time. They restaurant gave us this really nice back room, so it made our party more private. The service was very good. The waitress took really good care of us. We ordered a lot of appetizers; my favorite was the enchiladas and the chicken quesadillas. They have really good guacamole too! The margaritas were really good especially the iguana and the silver snake. We all had a really good time and I?m definitely going to be going back.

Posted 06/30/08

amazing atmosphere!!!!! 5 Star Rating - World class

By sbfny83

My friend and I decided to walk around the other night to try to find a place to eat. We decided on Mustang Grill because from outside it seems like a fun place to enjoy dinner and drinks. Specifically, because of the outside cafe, the colorful interior, decorations, the great music, the attractive staff, and the open doors in the front make it very inviting to come in. We went in and sat down and ordered our first round of drinks. I ordered a tasty strawberry mojito and my friend ordered a huge peach margarita and a flight. The drinks were so good, but the flights were amazing!!!! You could get four different kinds of tequila for a really good price. If you like tequila I would definitely recommend them!!!! Our food was very good. We ordered the nachos as an appetizer and the pecan chicken and the jumbo shrimp for our entrees. Our waitress was very nice and made sure we had everything we needed. I enjoyed my night tremendously and I?m definitely going back!!! P.S. the music was great!

Posted 06/30/08