Black Sheep Pub

★★★★☆
  • 428 Bergen St

    Brooklyn, NY 11217

    Cross street: nr. Fifth Ave.

    Map & Directions
  • 718-638-1109

About Black Sheep Pub

Hours
Mon-Fri, 4pm-4am; Sat-Sun, noon-4am

Food

Food
More choices in Brooklyn:
Resultset_next

Rooster's Coffee Barn

1074 N Brindlee Mountain Pkwy Arab, AL

Resultset_next

Los Arcos

326 N Brindlee Mountain Pkwy Arab, AL

4.4 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Black Sheep Pub was?
Write a Review
.

This place is small, but can make for a good time. I haven't gone there at night, but have had a few pints there during the day. There food is surprisingly good and considering that there is a shortage of bars in the neighborhood that serve food and still feel like a bar vice restaurant, I would recommend it for pub fare.

3
★★★☆☆

This place is small, but can make for a good time. I haven't gone there at night, but have had a few pints there during the day. There food is surprisingly good and considering that there is a shortage of bars in the neighborhood that serve food and still feel like a bar vice restaurant, I would recommend it for pub fare.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Good music and a conversational atmosphere weren't enough to offset the staff's disregard for 20th century service standards. After placing an order for hot wings and carrying my drink to my table, I noticed a fly frozen in one of the ice cubes. Sweet.

The hot wings never showed, and when I asked a server about them, he became hostile and combative. So I asked for my money back, as I'd already paid for the wings. After several minutes of conference with the bartender, he begrudgingly returned my money. But the guy still felt it necessary to throw out rude and unnecessary comments.

The message: if you expect drinks to not have insects in them and your servers to treat you with respect, do not go here. I left hoping that it quickly and permanently goes out of business.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Good music and a conversational atmosphere weren't enough to offset the staff's disregard for 20th century service standards. After placing an order for hot wings and carrying my drink to my table, I noticed a fly frozen in one of the ice cubes. Sweet.

The hot wings never showed, and when I asked a server about them, he became hostile and combative. So I asked for my money back, as I'd already paid for the wings. After several minutes of conference with the bartender, he begrudgingly returned my money. But the guy still felt it necessary to throw out rude and unnecessary comments.

The message: if you expect drinks to not have insects in them and your servers to treat you with respect, do not go here. I left hoping that it quickly and permanently goes out of business.

Pros: Good music, at a good volume for conversation

Cons: Rude waiters, unsanitary conditions

.

I don't think I can even describe this place well enough. Looking for somewhere good to relax and have a drink after a busy work week and super busy Friday, I found this spot on citysearch and set out to hit-up this tucked away spot on Bergen St. Located in trendy trendy trendy park slope, this spot is discreet yet popular with the locals. An unpretentious crowd is bustling around inside, while a few brave souls face the chilly fall evening for a casual smoke. The bar seemed packed but at the same time, everyone had room to breathe in the small ground level spot. An old cult classic is projected on the large blank wall while free tunes till 8pm got the crowd dancing. The staff was friendly and attentive, even sat down to explain the movie to us, since the sound wasn't on and we missed the intro. Plenty of drinks for my group of friends, and still didn't hear our wallets crying...all in all I couldn't have been happier to hang out down here and can't wait to do it again!!!

2
★★★★★

I don't think I can even describe this place well enough. Looking for somewhere good to relax and have a drink after a busy work week and super busy Friday, I found this spot on citysearch and set out to hit-up this tucked away spot on Bergen St. Located in trendy trendy trendy park slope, this spot is discreet yet popular with the locals. An unpretentious crowd is bustling around inside, while a few brave souls face the chilly fall evening for a casual smoke. The bar seemed packed but at the same time, everyone had room to breathe in the small ground level spot. An old cult classic is projected on the large blank wall while free tunes till 8pm got the crowd dancing. The staff was friendly and attentive, even sat down to explain the movie to us, since the sound wasn't on and we missed the intro. Plenty of drinks for my group of friends, and still didn't hear our wallets crying...all in all I couldn't have been happier to hang out down here and can't wait to do it again!!!

Pros: Atmosphere, Staff, Drink Selection, Jukebox and Movies!!

Cons: Lighting was kinda low

.

This is just my favourite place to go relax - Awesome atmosphere, best jukebox in town and just about the least pretentious bar that exists. Comparable to Commonwealth (another awesome joint) but with some thought put into the color scheme. Honestly I don't go there with an agenda BUT I have been quite lucky to meet some new lady friends on occasion. Give the place a few trys and sink right in.

2
★★★★★

This is just my favourite place to go relax - Awesome atmosphere, best jukebox in town and just about the least pretentious bar that exists. Comparable to Commonwealth (another awesome joint) but with some thought put into the color scheme. Honestly I don't go there with an agenda BUT I have been quite lucky to meet some new lady friends on occasion. Give the place a few trys and sink right in.

Pros: home away from home

Cons: off the strip a little

.

I'm all about the wine. Each Mon & Wed the sheep cuts the wine prices in half. They have quite a selection for a New York bar, all European and all really tasty. Check it out girls and oh, no sleazy guys hassling you, and I'm a hottie before anybody comments :)

2
★★★★★

I'm all about the wine. Each Mon & Wed the sheep cuts the wine prices in half. They have quite a selection for a New York bar, all European and all really tasty. Check it out girls and oh, no sleazy guys hassling you, and I'm a hottie before anybody comments :)

Pros: Good wine Cheap - Friendly bartenders - good people

Cons: Has to close at 4AM - NY state law apparently

.

On my first and lonely visit to this small inconspicuous bar I met about ten people, all of whom were attending this bar on a regular basis. Unpretentious and intelligent, most importantly very interesting and easy going. I've been to Black Sheep about six times now and it just keeps getting better. Best group of regulars i have ever seen. One of those bars where you can go with your buddies, girlfriend or simply alone and be just as comfortable. Great drink specials, half price wine nights(best wine selection i have seen in a regular pub), awesome Trivia night, and my favorite: Foosball table with very competitive players. Great jukebox. THE place to watch soccer matches.

2
★★★★★

On my first and lonely visit to this small inconspicuous bar I met about ten people, all of whom were attending this bar on a regular basis. Unpretentious and intelligent, most importantly very interesting and easy going. I've been to Black Sheep about six times now and it just keeps getting better. Best group of regulars i have ever seen. One of those bars where you can go with your buddies, girlfriend or simply alone and be just as comfortable. Great drink specials, half price wine nights(best wine selection i have seen in a regular pub), awesome Trivia night, and my favorite: Foosball table with very competitive players. Great jukebox. THE place to watch soccer matches.

Pros: ambience, service, value

Cons: no food

.

I come to Black Sheep often and am never disappointed. The cozy decor, cheap drinks, and good conversation make this my favorite bar in the Slope. As a female I know I can go to the Sheep and always feel comfortable. It helps that all the bartenders are pretty cool too. My favorites: customer contributions to the already awesome jukebox, great beer selection, and HALF PRICED WINE nights!

2
★★★★★

I come to Black Sheep often and am never disappointed. The cozy decor, cheap drinks, and good conversation make this my favorite bar in the Slope. As a female I know I can go to the Sheep and always feel comfortable. It helps that all the bartenders are pretty cool too. My favorites: customer contributions to the already awesome jukebox, great beer selection, and HALF PRICED WINE nights!

Pros: always a good laugh, good date spot

.

A very warm and friendly bar that reinvents itself every few months with new specials and events. As a fan of foosball I have found some of the best players in this bar so don't expect it to be easy. Great happy hr!!!

2
★★★★★

A very warm and friendly bar that reinvents itself every few months with new specials and events. As a fan of foosball I have found some of the best players in this bar so don't expect it to be easy. Great happy hr!!!

Pros: Value, Foosball, atmosphere

.

amazing spot -- just what the neighborhood needed. i love o'connor's as well, but this place has a slightly different vibe, with the big screen and fooseball table, great juxebox and board games (!). the prices cannot be beat... we live around the corner and love stopping by for a drink.

2
★★★★★

amazing spot -- just what the neighborhood needed. i love o'connor's as well, but this place has a slightly different vibe, with the big screen and fooseball table, great juxebox and board games (!). the prices cannot be beat... we live around the corner and love stopping by for a drink.

Pros: drink prices, big screen, great juxebox,

.

Nice neighborhood bar to hang with friends. There are always some type of drink deals , like 1/2 price wines, and other events going on .....Casual vibe

2
★★★★★

Nice neighborhood bar to hang with friends. There are always some type of drink deals , like 1/2 price wines, and other events going on .....Casual vibe

Pros: atmosphere, drink specials, bar crowd

Cons: no food

Editorial from

In Short
At this unpretentious neighborhood pub, drinks are cheap, and a jukebox blasts classic and indie rock for free until 8 pm nightly. Seated at the short oak bar, regulars chat with the bartenders over well-poured pints…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Black Sheep Pub, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review