O'reilly's Off 5th

★★★★★
  • 21 W 35th St

    New York, NY 10001

    Map & Directions
  • 212-502-5246

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

P J Moran's Irish Pub & Restaurant

3 E 48th St (Between 5th & Madison Av.) New York, NY

Resultset_next

Moran's

103 Washington Street New York, NY

4.5 4
Hi! Sign in to let us know how O'reilly's Off 5th was?
Write a Review
.

OMG, what a great, great Irish Pub on this super entertainment block of Midtown, right by Macy??s. Beautiful and talkative bar where you never fail to find an enormous mix of people, singles-through-seniors, backed by gorgeous high-definition screens full of sports and ?? the biggest plus for me ?? really delicious food. There are a number of different dining environments to choose from: At the bar; near the bar; ??in the back??; and also a large, quieter room upstairs. The menu is altogether outstanding. Everything I have tried is really good, right from the wings and ??mini-burgers?? on the bar menu, straight through to the O??Reilly??s specialty burger which really should be in the city??s ??Best Burgers?? competition: It's that good (be sure you order it ??rare??, though, even if you usually like ??medium rare?? ?? and tell them you want the ??sweet potato fries??, not the regular fries)...and on to great desserts like a truly outstanding apple pie and a real-cream Strawberry Napoleon. Excellent Cobb salad, Chef salad, and Caesar salads as well. Or if you want to keep it really light go with their simple wedge of lettuce with blue cheese dressing and bacon bits: Low in calories and very satisfying. And they??re generous in the mixed drink department. These people know how to keep me coming back. You will not regret going to O??Reilly??s on 35th.

2
★★★★★

OMG, what a great, great Irish Pub on this super entertainment block of Midtown, right by Macy??s. Beautiful and talkative bar where you never fail to find an enormous mix of people, singles-through-seniors, backed by gorgeous high-definition screens full of sports and ?? the biggest plus for me ?? really delicious food. There are a number of different dining environments to choose from: At the bar; near the bar; ??in the back??; and also a large, quieter room upstairs. The menu is altogether outstanding. Everything I have tried is really good, right from the wings and ??mini-burgers?? on the bar menu, straight through to the O??Reilly??s specialty burger which really should be in the city??s ??Best Burgers?? competition: It's that good (be sure you order it ??rare??, though, even if you usually like ??medium rare?? ?? and tell them you want the ??sweet potato fries??, not the regular fries)...and on to great desserts like a truly outstanding apple pie and a real-cream Strawberry Napoleon. Excellent Cobb salad, Chef salad, and Caesar salads as well. Or if you want to keep it really light go with their simple wedge of lettuce with blue cheese dressing and bacon bits: Low in calories and very satisfying. And they??re generous in the mixed drink department. These people know how to keep me coming back. You will not regret going to O??Reilly??s on 35th.

Pros: Great food! Great high-definition sports screens!

Cons: Can be crowded but lots of other options on same block.

.

I was just wandering around making my way to Penn Staion, and I was looking for a pup for a few beers, and a good burger before catching the train back home. This nice, cozy pup has a very warm feel to it and has lots of tv's for the games, and the bacon cheeseburger was cooked to order and quite good. Good service, and the people seemed to be regulars and having a good time. Would come back anytime.

2
★★★★☆

I was just wandering around making my way to Penn Staion, and I was looking for a pup for a few beers, and a good burger before catching the train back home. This nice, cozy pup has a very warm feel to it and has lots of tv's for the games, and the bacon cheeseburger was cooked to order and quite good. Good service, and the people seemed to be regulars and having a good time. Would come back anytime.

Pros: food, sevice, atmosphere

Cons: may be crowded

.

Best Irish pub in NYC. Excellent crowd and a guaranteed good time.

2
★★★★★

Best Irish pub in NYC. Excellent crowd and a guaranteed good time.

.

Lovely environment and bar, always busy during Happy hour and early evenings; food is standard fare - good tasting and well prepared; service depends on how busy they are

2
★★★★☆

Lovely environment and bar, always busy during Happy hour and early evenings; food is standard fare - good tasting and well prepared; service depends on how busy they are

Editorial from

Serving seafood, steaks, salads, hamburgers, sandwiches, chicken, pasta and more.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used O'reilly's Off 5th, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review