Insider Pages Reviews for One Girl Cookies

5 Stars: Love this place (by Robin P.)

Robin P. — Thu, 14 May 2009 14:09:00 GMT

They have wonderful cookies that taste so good. My daughter really liked visiting this bakery when we were in New York. Felt like the prices were good and it was fun to visit.

2 Stars: Don't believe the Hype (by delirous)

delirous — Tue, 10 Feb 2009 01:00:00 GMT

As a baker, I go around the area searching for bakeries to test my comp. Ok, this place is cute. Real cute. The packaging, store, customers and all are all foo foo she she la la, but the cookies, were ok. Not real sweet, and not enough. I would not come back to this place. The cookies are between the size of a quarter and golden dollar, not silver dollar because those are bigger. NOT WORTH IT! The cup cakes they had displayed were not well decorated. For the price, I can not believe they are still in businss. Who would continue to buy them. The coffee and drinks must be what's pulling them through.

1 Stars: nice packaging (by hr4fc)

hr4fc — Sun, 28 Dec 2008 01:00:00 GMT

i was very excited to taste the cookies, but they had no flavor what so ever. I was very disappointed.

4 Stars: very special (by liz h.)

liz h. — Sun, 07 Dec 2008 17:05:00 GMT

Someone brought us a box of cookies from this tiny little bake shop. These are the most divine and delicate cookies ever. Flavors are special and the design is something to behold

3 Stars: Yummy cookies! (by karysma17)

karysma17 — Wed, 16 Jul 2008 02:00:00 GMT

They have absolutely DELICIOUS DELICIOUS cookies!!! I like them all........The only reason I didn`t give them 5 stars, its because of this HORRIBLE cake they want to pass as RED VELVET CAKE. It was like a red pound cake with a frosting with no taste......But get the cookies!!! Am always begging my friend who work just 2 doors from OGC to get me some!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

4 Stars: Adorable store, great cookies (by wisebrain)

wisebrain — Sun, 06 Jul 2008 02:00:00 GMT

This place is really cute. It is on the higher end of bakeries but is worth it for a special treat or gift.

5 Stars: A great gift to give (by funny_fringe)

funny_fringe — Wed, 04 Jul 2007 02:00:00 GMT

A cute bakery with delicious treats! The staff is very helpful and pleasant. The cookies are great and make wonderful gifts, and are fun to keep around the house for a snack.

4 Stars: Delectable & Delightful (by decafisevil)

decafisevil — Mon, 12 Feb 2007 01:00:00 GMT

This is a charming shop that beckons all who walk by to walk in. The soft jazz and robin's egg blue walls instantly put you at ease. The bite size cookies are soft and sweet enough to be heavenly, but not too sweet. (My favorites are the coconut-topped Sadies and the oatmeal Susannas that sparkle with cinnamon.) It's hard to walk out without taking a whole box of cookies with you. The hot cocoa could use a little more chocolate and a little less milk, but it's still an enjoyable cup. The only noticeable drawback is the uncomfortable chairs that are high like barstools and webbed like a shopping cart.

5 Stars: Wonderful Cookies & Delightful Atmosphere (by brooklyngirl619)

brooklyngirl619 — Thu, 18 May 2006 02:00:00 GMT

This little gem is tucked away on a beautiful little street in Cobble Hill. The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. The owners-who work behind the counter and bake all of the cookies by hand are as nice as can be! The cookies come beautifully packaged with old black & white photos of the owners families. I will buy all of my gifts here from now on!!