Pisticci Restaurant

★★★★★
  • 125 La Salle St

    New York, NY 10027

    Map & Directions
  • 212-932-3500

About Pisticci Restaurant

Hours
11 am-3:30 pm, 4:30-11 pm. Bar: Sun-Thurs until 11:30 pm, Fri-Sat until midnight

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Casa Mono

52 Irving Pl New York, NY

Resultset_next

'ino

21 Bedford St New York, NY

5 25
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Pisticci Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

I eat out frequently, in excellent restaurants, and travel extensively, often in Italy where I have family and friends. I love this restaurant. The food is very good, the prices reasonable, service pleasant and the atmosphere

3
★★★★★

I eat out frequently, in excellent restaurants, and travel extensively, often in Italy where I have family and friends. I love this restaurant. The food is very good, the prices reasonable, service pleasant and the atmosphere

.

Terrific dining experience! Pasta al dente delicious. Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Going back soon!

3
★★★★★

Terrific dining experience! Pasta al dente delicious. Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Going back soon!

.

I went here on a date last night. It was really nice. The atmosphere is inviting and the food was delicious. The date was forgettable, but the food wasn't. Try the artichoke appetizer.

3
★★★★★

I went here on a date last night. It was really nice. The atmosphere is inviting and the food was delicious. The date was forgettable, but the food wasn't. Try the artichoke appetizer.

.

I think this place is really popular in part because a) there are so few places like it up in that neighborhood, and b) it's pretty affordable -- esp. for all those students on budgets.

The place has it's charm and for the price, it's

3
★★★★★

I think this place is really popular in part because a) there are so few places like it up in that neighborhood, and b) it's pretty affordable -- esp. for all those students on budgets.

The place has it's charm and for the price, it's

Pros: Prices; fresh, simple rustic fare; tasty cocktails

Cons: Crowded & (not necessarily bad thing) younger crowd

.

Overall, I'm happy with this place -- their food is excellent, service is usually friendly, they have good wine and great ambiance. Add some good company and nice conversation -- life is not so bad after all...

3
★★★★★

Overall, I'm happy with this place -- their food is excellent, service is usually friendly, they have good wine and great ambiance. Add some good company and nice conversation -- life is not so bad after all...

Pros: Great food, friendly service, ambiance

Cons: Expensive specials

.

I'm confused by some of these glowing reviews. Who are these people, and do they actually have any restaurant experience? The place is average at best. The portions are terribly small-- so the prices are actually high for what they offer.

3
★★★★★

I'm confused by some of these glowing reviews. Who are these people, and do they actually have any restaurant experience? The place is average at best. The portions are terribly small-- so the prices are actually high for what they offer.

Pros: it's not awful food (just not exceptional)

Cons: hostess however, is awful

.

It was my first time at Pisticci. Our server was kind of brusque and the service was slow... which we could have understood -- or even found charming -- if we weren't two of only eight or so customers in the entire place at the time. Decor

3
★★★★★

It was my first time at Pisticci. Our server was kind of brusque and the service was slow... which we could have understood -- or even found charming -- if we weren't two of only eight or so customers in the entire place at the time. Decor

Pros: Cute, Good Pasta

Cons: Slow Service

.

Great food, fun atmosphere. Jazz night every sunday. Convenient to get to from the 1 train. Servers are friendly. They have a great brunch on weekends.

5
★★★★★

Great food, fun atmosphere. Jazz night every sunday. Convenient to get to from the 1 train. Servers are friendly. They have a great brunch on weekends.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

When a friend recommended this restaurant, she simply told me, "you have to go, you won't believe it," and she was right! A year ago, I went to Pisticci for the first time, and I've been back several times ever since. This place has

3
★★★★★

When a friend recommended this restaurant, she simply told me, "you have to go, you won't believe it," and she was right! A year ago, I went to Pisticci for the first time, and I've been back several times ever since. This place has

Pros: Delicious food, friendly waitstaff, great prices, nice decor

.

The food is usually good but they often (2x in 2 weeks) mix up orders. The manager is irritatingly ditzy!

3
★★★★★

The food is usually good but they often (2x in 2 weeks) mix up orders. The manager is irritatingly ditzy!

.

The menu is very limited and the price is high, but the atmosphere is great. Make reservations if possible.

3
★★★★★

The menu is very limited and the price is high, but the atmosphere is great. Make reservations if possible.

.

I think there must be 2 Pisticcis. I didn't find it to be anything like the reviews I read. The atmosphere was depressing, food was eh, (very limited menu) and service was OK. I wouldn't recommend it , or go back..

3
★★★★★

I think there must be 2 Pisticcis. I didn't find it to be anything like the reviews I read. The atmosphere was depressing, food was eh, (very limited menu) and service was OK. I wouldn't recommend it , or go back..

Pros: good service

Cons: ambience, limited menu, food was eh.

.

I totally LOVE this place, the food is excellent and not over the top, its all Italian but very finely done. The staff is amazing, as soon as you walk in your completely relaxed and feel as if you are in another era and another country !

3
★★★★★

I totally LOVE this place, the food is excellent and not over the top, its all Italian but very finely done. The staff is amazing, as soon as you walk in your completely relaxed and feel as if you are in another era and another country !

Pros: the ambience

Cons: hard to park but still worth it

.

So sad,\r
how can you possibly dump a sea of hot canned tomato sauce\r
on top of a mozzarella di bufala and grilled eggplant?\r
The polenta blocks were tasteless and, again, drowning under cheap tomato sauce.\r
The fettuccine were

3
★★★★★

So sad,\r
how can you possibly dump a sea of hot canned tomato sauce\r
on top of a mozzarella di bufala and grilled eggplant?\r
The polenta blocks were tasteless and, again, drowning under cheap tomato sauce.\r
The fettuccine were

Pros: nice atmosphere

Cons: bad food, I still smell like tomato sauce

.

We live right by Pisticci and eat here often. they manage to provide a cozy ambiance and an excellent quality of food. They have some amazing daily specials. Excellent desserts (would eat the chocolate mousse for dinner if i wer'nt worried

3
★★★★★

We live right by Pisticci and eat here often. they manage to provide a cozy ambiance and an excellent quality of food. They have some amazing daily specials. Excellent desserts (would eat the chocolate mousse for dinner if i wer'nt worried

Pros: Ambience, Friendly Wait Staff, Food!!!

Cons: Slightly pricey ( but worth it!)

.

This restaurant is a block away from my wife and my appartment, and we eat here probably twice a month. We adore the staff and devour the food. Fabulous.

3
★★★★★

This restaurant is a block away from my wife and my appartment, and we eat here probably twice a month. We adore the staff and devour the food. Fabulous.

Pros: great food, great staff, great atmosphere

Cons: slightly pricy

.

I had just moved to New York a few months before Pisticci opened, and I lived just around the corner, so this place is very near and dear to my heart. I remember being served free pasta and wine the night of the grand opening, and I've

3
★★★★★

I had just moved to New York a few months before Pisticci opened, and I lived just around the corner, so this place is very near and dear to my heart. I remember being served free pasta and wine the night of the grand opening, and I've

Pros: Food, "Homey" feeling

.

This place has simple, tasty Italian fare for a great price, and the place is small enough (even with its new extension) to feel like home. Drinks are served in jelly jars and a bowl of spaghetti is just $6.50! The signature iced tea,

3
★★★★★

This place has simple, tasty Italian fare for a great price, and the place is small enough (even with its new extension) to feel like home. Drinks are served in jelly jars and a bowl of spaghetti is just $6.50! The signature iced tea,

Pros: Friendly waitstaff, Great prices, Lovely decor

.

This place is great, i probably shouldn't be saying anything in fact but they have always been great to me and they will be great to you as well. It's a warm restaurant with delicious meals at fair prices. Don't miss out on the

3
★★★★★

This place is great, i probably shouldn't be saying anything in fact but they have always been great to me and they will be great to you as well. It's a warm restaurant with delicious meals at fair prices. Don't miss out on the

Pros: Inexpensive, Delicious, Friendly

.

after traveling around italy and yearning for more, i am happy to find the one spot in town where i feel transported back. pisticci has terrific food, creative choices and a genuinely warm atmostphere that cannot be manufactured. a

3
★★★★★

after traveling around italy and yearning for more, i am happy to find the one spot in town where i feel transported back. pisticci has terrific food, creative choices and a genuinely warm atmostphere that cannot be manufactured. a

Pros: everything

.

Pisticci is not only a neighborhood favorite, but a place the whole upper west side should get familiar with. The food is wonderful, the specials are creative and make use of the best season items around. The fig salad is amazing, as is

3
★★★★★

Pisticci is not only a neighborhood favorite, but a place the whole upper west side should get familiar with. The food is wonderful, the specials are creative and make use of the best season items around. The fig salad is amazing, as is

Pros: inventive specials, well-informed staff

.

Pisticci has a great little spot on the Upper West Side and for the most part is a quality restaurant where you can expect pretty standard pasta dishes and above average taste. I recommend the polenta over meatballs. The wait staff is a

3
★★★★★

Pisticci has a great little spot on the Upper West Side and for the most part is a quality restaurant where you can expect pretty standard pasta dishes and above average taste. I recommend the polenta over meatballs. The wait staff is a

Pros: Inexpensive, Tasty, Nice Ambience

.

Comfortable place to dine. Wonderful food. Friendly staff. Outside seating. Small, but good use of space.

3
★★★★★

Comfortable place to dine. Wonderful food. Friendly staff. Outside seating. Small, but good use of space.

Pros: Food, Service

.

West Harlem doesn't have many places for a 'going-out' meal, so Pisticci would be welcome enough even if they didn't serve delicious homemade pasta, inventive specialty dishes, delicious desserts, and tasty brunch food in a rustic-chic,

3
★★★★★

West Harlem doesn't have many places for a 'going-out' meal, so Pisticci would be welcome enough even if they didn't serve delicious homemade pasta, inventive specialty dishes, delicious desserts, and tasty brunch food in a rustic-chic,

Pros: friendly service, delicious pasta, cozy atmosphere

.

A dependable local institution, in an area that doesn't have much in the way of choice in Italian restaurants. Very friendly and welcoming. The food is pretty good, but the main point is that it's a pleasant, useful place to have around

3
★★★★★

A dependable local institution, in an area that doesn't have much in the way of choice in Italian restaurants. Very friendly and welcoming. The food is pretty good, but the main point is that it's a pleasant, useful place to have around

Pros: Friendly, Welcoming

Cons: Slightly overpriced

Editorial from

Serving Italian pasta, salad, soup, meatballs, dessert and more.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Pisticci Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review