I made an 8:00 reservation on a Friday night for a one year anniversary. I ordered flowers from Fallon's Flowers and had them sent to the restaurant and requested they be on the table when we arrived. I also brought my own wine; only $15.00 corking fee to enjoy my own Cab without a ridiculous markup.
The service was excellent. Nothing stands out as not up to par. The flowers were on the table when we were sat. Because this was a special occasion, the server brought champagne and strawberries with chocolate on the house. We ordered the Bibb Salad and the cheese cart for starters. The only negative thing at all is we ordered the Onion Soup and it never came out; the server just forgot, and we were so busy with the cheese and salads that we didn't care. I'm sure if we'd mentioned it, it would have been delivered immediately. The server, Nicole, was absolutely WONDERFUL at pacing our meal; that's not something I see very often. Nothing was rushed, and there was very little sitting and waiting for the next course. The cheese cart was fantastic, we sampled four cheeses, and the Bibb wedge was also good, if not a little on the sparse side.
I ordered the Kansas City Prime strip, and she ordered the Choice strip. Her steak was on par with a decent chain steakhouse, but mine definitely goes into my top 5 steaks I've ever eaten; and I ate steaks almost every night for eight years traveling every state between upstate New York and South Florida. It had the characteristic slight gamey taste of a Prime dry aged cut of beef. Cooked perfectly, I couldn't ask for better for $32.00 . The sweet potatoes are a must-have side, the potatoes with white truffle oil are delectable, and the creamed spinach, though nothing out-of-this-world, was very good. We topped it off with Creme Brulee and I had the gourmet coffee brewed at the table with a French press. Both of these were outstanding, particularly the coffee.
We weren't disappointed at all.
Pros: Went out of their way to make the evening special
Cons: Still somewhat pricey