Angelo & Maxie's

★★★★☆
  • 233 Park Ave S

    New York, NY 10003

    Cross street: at 19th St.

    Map & Directions
  • 212-220-9200

About Angelo & Maxie's

Hours
Mon 11:30am-3pm, 5pm-10pm Tue-Wed 11:30am-3pm, 5pm-11pm Thu-Fri 11:30am-3pm, 5pm-12am Sat 11:30am-4pm, 5pm-12am Sun 4pm-10pm

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Rainbow Room

30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY

Resultset_next

Blue Ribbon Bakery & Cafe

35 Downing St New York, NY

4.0459 109
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Angelo & Maxie's was?
Write a Review
  « Previous 1 3
.

Hi! everybody, Our shop cheap wholesale and retail Air Jordans shoes,Air Max Shoes,Designer Handbags,Jewelry,Belts,hats,Jeans,Sports Jerseys,sunglasses online,high quality goods and Low price,outlet online,free shipping,Welcome to order at cxcztrade.com
Cheap Jordan shoes http://www.cxcztrade.com
Fashion Jewelry $15 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Jordan hats $10 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Brand Belts $27 http://www.cxcztrade.com
AAA Jeans $52 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Sports Jerseys $25 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Jordans for sale $56 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Designer Sunglasses $16 http://www.cxcztrade.com
(DG MK LV) Handbags $46 http://www.cxcztrade.com

5
★★★★★

Hi! everybody, Our shop cheap wholesale and retail Air Jordans shoes,Air Max Shoes,Designer Handbags,Jewelry,Belts,hats,Jeans,Sports Jerseys,sunglasses online,high quality goods and Low price,outlet online,free shipping,Welcome to order at cxcztrade.com
Cheap Jordan shoes http://www.cxcztrade.com
Fashion Jewelry $15 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Jordan hats $10 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Brand Belts $27 http://www.cxcztrade.com
AAA Jeans $52 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Sports Jerseys $25 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Jordans for sale $56 http://www.cxcztrade.com
Designer Sunglasses $16 http://www.cxcztrade.com
(DG MK LV) Handbags $46 http://www.cxcztrade.com

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I??ve been traveling in and out of New York for years. When I come, I want pizza. They tell me it has something to do with the water. Whatever Angelo & Maxie is doing, they need to keep doing it. Their crust was the perfect consistency to fold over and the slice was cheesy without it being obnoxiously cheesy. I could have eaten the entire pizza on my own. The servers were very friendly, too. They kept napkins on the table and my drink glass full. It??s all I could ask for in a pizza place.

5
★★★★★

I??ve been traveling in and out of New York for years. When I come, I want pizza. They tell me it has something to do with the water. Whatever Angelo & Maxie is doing, they need to keep doing it. Their crust was the perfect consistency to fold over and the slice was cheesy without it being obnoxiously cheesy. I could have eaten the entire pizza on my own. The servers were very friendly, too. They kept napkins on the table and my drink glass full. It??s all I could ask for in a pizza place.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Pizza was delicious! Great prices too. I really enjoyed the atmosphere and customer service. Thanks!!!

5
★★★★★

Pizza was delicious! Great prices too. I really enjoyed the atmosphere and customer service. Thanks!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My friend and I yesterday evening decided to stop by Angelo & Maxies for a glass of wine and a lite snack. We decided to sit by the bar. The second we walked in the hostess ran up to us to say that the high tables are reserved. There was

3
★★★★★

My friend and I yesterday evening decided to stop by Angelo & Maxies for a glass of wine and a lite snack. We decided to sit by the bar. The second we walked in the hostess ran up to us to say that the high tables are reserved. There was

.

Have been to Maxies with friends on three different occassions. The quality of the food and portions is always consistently outstanding. The wait staff goes out of their way to cater to each person, keep their drinks full and to ensure the food is delivered as ordered. So, I ended up making reservations to celebrate my son's 21st birthday. I knew I culd count on a great experience and everybody raved about the food. Would highly recommend this steakhouse to anyone looking to celebrate a special occassion.

5
★★★★★

Have been to Maxies with friends on three different occassions. The quality of the food and portions is always consistently outstanding. The wait staff goes out of their way to cater to each person, keep their drinks full and to ensure the food is delivered as ordered. So, I ended up making reservations to celebrate my son's 21st birthday. I knew I culd count on a great experience and everybody raved about the food. Would highly recommend this steakhouse to anyone looking to celebrate a special occassion.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I came and had a great time with my friends, They have some good food and the drinks are okay. I ordered some steak and it was very tender.!

4
★★★★☆

I came and had a great time with my friends, They have some good food and the drinks are okay. I ordered some steak and it was very tender.!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This Friday night, December 15, 2010, my elderly aunt and I (middle aged) visited Angelos and Maxis on 19th and Park Avenue. Even though my aunt had made a reservation and we arrived in a timely manner, the restaurant refused to seat us!

3
★★★★★

This Friday night, December 15, 2010, my elderly aunt and I (middle aged) visited Angelos and Maxis on 19th and Park Avenue. Even though my aunt had made a reservation and we arrived in a timely manner, the restaurant refused to seat us!

.

I went to Angelo and Maxie's with a large group two days ago (Friday Dec 10). I ordered the 2006 Clos du Bois cabernet and the waiter brought the wine, showed it to me a bit too fast and withdrew it to pour it. Something in the speed

3
★★★★★

I went to Angelo and Maxie's with a large group two days ago (Friday Dec 10). I ordered the 2006 Clos du Bois cabernet and the waiter brought the wine, showed it to me a bit too fast and withdrew it to pour it. Something in the speed

.

So the boys and I had a night out, one of us were finally getting married. Kinda like walking a man down death row, it's a long green mile.

The steaks were actually very good. I had the porterhouse, a bit on the underdone side but very

3
★★★★★

So the boys and I had a night out, one of us were finally getting married. Kinda like walking a man down death row, it's a long green mile.

The steaks were actually very good. I had the porterhouse, a bit on the underdone side but very

.

Visiting New York with my wife during "Restaurant Week", I researched restaurants in the Gramercy/Flat Iron/Chelsea neighborhoods and found Angelo and Maxie's. We made our long distance reservations over the phone, which was an efficient and pleasant experience in itself. Unlike the previous evening where the restaurant offered a limited RW menu with many surcharges added, A&Ms offered their specialties at the standard RW rate of $35 for three courses. The service was efficient and gracious, and the 12-oz filet mignon literally melted in our mouths. Furthermore, the chef produced a "medium well" and "medium" which matched our expectations perfectly. The first-course salad was both ample and fresh. Lastly, I opted for the NY cheesecake dessert while my more disciplined wife chose the fruit (and couldn't resist some of MY delicious fattening item!). All in all, it was a fine experience which capped off a fine day in NYC.

2
★★★★★

Visiting New York with my wife during "Restaurant Week", I researched restaurants in the Gramercy/Flat Iron/Chelsea neighborhoods and found Angelo and Maxie's. We made our long distance reservations over the phone, which was an efficient and pleasant experience in itself. Unlike the previous evening where the restaurant offered a limited RW menu with many surcharges added, A&Ms offered their specialties at the standard RW rate of $35 for three courses. The service was efficient and gracious, and the 12-oz filet mignon literally melted in our mouths. Furthermore, the chef produced a "medium well" and "medium" which matched our expectations perfectly. The first-course salad was both ample and fresh. Lastly, I opted for the NY cheesecake dessert while my more disciplined wife chose the fruit (and couldn't resist some of MY delicious fattening item!). All in all, it was a fine experience which capped off a fine day in NYC.

.

Angelo and Maxies is the finest steakhouse in NYC! Not only is the food of high quality and reasonably priced, but the service is exceptional. Hats off to Marcellus and the entire service staff. I am a regular and extraordinarily picky about my dining experiences. The portions are very generous and rather ample for large parties. My favorite is the petite filet mignon. Perfection!

Angelo and Maxies NEVER disappoints!

Frederick A. Myers

2
★★★★★

Angelo and Maxies is the finest steakhouse in NYC! Not only is the food of high quality and reasonably priced, but the service is exceptional. Hats off to Marcellus and the entire service staff. I am a regular and extraordinarily picky about my dining experiences. The portions are very generous and rather ample for large parties. My favorite is the petite filet mignon. Perfection!

Angelo and Maxies NEVER disappoints!

Frederick A. Myers

Pros: Price, service, food quality

Cons: Ambience can get noisy during peak lunch hours and at dinner

.

Sure, it's crowded and noisy and we had to shout to make ourselves heard, but the steak is phenomenal , the staff is friendly and the drinks are flowing. Wouldn't recommend for an intimate dinner, but great for our big group of eight.

4
★★★★☆

Sure, it's crowded and noisy and we had to shout to make ourselves heard, but the steak is phenomenal , the staff is friendly and the drinks are flowing. Wouldn't recommend for an intimate dinner, but great for our big group of eight.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I used to like this place, but I had dinner here with my boyfriend on a sunday evening and the experience was awful. When we sat down there were crumbs all over the seat. Our waiter brought our drinks and my wine glass had food crusted on the rim, and my boyfriends beer glass was chipped. We ordered 3 appetizers, one entree and a side, and instead of coursing out our meal the waiter brought everything at once. The table was packed and our steak got cold while we ate our apps. We were pretty annoyed. The waiter knew we were upset, so he avoided our table, and didn't even bother to check in on our meal. If he had, we would have told him that he forgot our mash potatoes. Then the waiters held open the emergency door for an extended period of time, and since we were sitting right across from it, we froze, and our food froze. By the time we reached desert, I wanted to get out of there, but my boyfriend wanted the pecan pie. When it came it was warm on the top and refrigerator cold in the middle and on the bottom. I was going to talk to a manager, but my boyfriend said it would be pointless. If you're looking for a nice dinner experience, try another steak house. Angelo and Maxie's is past it's prime.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I used to like this place, but I had dinner here with my boyfriend on a sunday evening and the experience was awful. When we sat down there were crumbs all over the seat. Our waiter brought our drinks and my wine glass had food crusted on the rim, and my boyfriends beer glass was chipped. We ordered 3 appetizers, one entree and a side, and instead of coursing out our meal the waiter brought everything at once. The table was packed and our steak got cold while we ate our apps. We were pretty annoyed. The waiter knew we were upset, so he avoided our table, and didn't even bother to check in on our meal. If he had, we would have told him that he forgot our mash potatoes. Then the waiters held open the emergency door for an extended period of time, and since we were sitting right across from it, we froze, and our food froze. By the time we reached desert, I wanted to get out of there, but my boyfriend wanted the pecan pie. When it came it was warm on the top and refrigerator cold in the middle and on the bottom. I was going to talk to a manager, but my boyfriend said it would be pointless. If you're looking for a nice dinner experience, try another steak house. Angelo and Maxie's is past it's prime.

.

Recently ate here again after having not been impressed a year ago, and all I can say is 'Wow!' Not a "kitchen nightmares" kind of turnaround (because the restaurant was far from a dump last year, but nice to begin with and remains a classy steak joint), but what a huge service improvement nonetheless. The experience this time was superlative! Ken at the door squeezed our party of four in, and we were waited on by a trio of waiters named Matt, who took wonderful care of us. Service was amazingly prompt, and delivered with gusto, and attention to detail. Even when there was a slight mistake with one of our entrees, Matt quickly corrected it with an insistance on what he described as 'diamond service,' everyone had great humor, and were complete professionals. We knew we were in good hands from all our servers' fantastic attention to detail. The previous time was not the case, the service and experience were somewhat lacking, but I can comfortably say that is no longer the case. I plan to come back with friends real soon and will seek out 'the Matts' once again for a steak the size of staten island, cooked to perfection, with super service to boot!

2
★★★★★

Recently ate here again after having not been impressed a year ago, and all I can say is 'Wow!' Not a "kitchen nightmares" kind of turnaround (because the restaurant was far from a dump last year, but nice to begin with and remains a classy steak joint), but what a huge service improvement nonetheless. The experience this time was superlative! Ken at the door squeezed our party of four in, and we were waited on by a trio of waiters named Matt, who took wonderful care of us. Service was amazingly prompt, and delivered with gusto, and attention to detail. Even when there was a slight mistake with one of our entrees, Matt quickly corrected it with an insistance on what he described as 'diamond service,' everyone had great humor, and were complete professionals. We knew we were in good hands from all our servers' fantastic attention to detail. The previous time was not the case, the service and experience were somewhat lacking, but I can comfortably say that is no longer the case. I plan to come back with friends real soon and will seek out 'the Matts' once again for a steak the size of staten island, cooked to perfection, with super service to boot!

.

The restaurant was nice but way too crowded to charge you the prices they do. The bar area is nice if you want to meet a few friends, but they do not have any drink service at the small tables near the front of the restaurant so you have to shuffle through people to get drinks. Not comfortable after 7pm.

3
★★★☆☆

The restaurant was nice but way too crowded to charge you the prices they do. The bar area is nice if you want to meet a few friends, but they do not have any drink service at the small tables near the front of the restaurant so you have to shuffle through people to get drinks. Not comfortable after 7pm.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.


I reacently dined at this place and I have to say it was awsome. From the wait staff to the food it was all good. The staff acomidated all of our needs and then some. If that wasn't enough, I am asuming he is a manager everything was taken into account. Well done! I will return.

2
★★★★★


I reacently dined at this place and I have to say it was awsome. From the wait staff to the food it was all good. The staff acomidated all of our needs and then some. If that wasn't enough, I am asuming he is a manager everything was taken into account. Well done! I will return.

Pros: Food,staff and managment!

Cons: none

.

my friend and i celebrated my 40th birthday there on a thursday nite. the drinks were super strong which was great. the door staff and bartenders were terrific. our server was lacking sincerity and interest, but then another server stopped by, 'cal' i think she said her name was and she was pleasant. the food was really exceptional, something i wasn't expecting. from the shrimp and clams oreganato to the ceasar salad. the ny sirloin was tender, juicy, sooo tasty and the garlic potatoes, although not a favorite were just right. the bread pudding was crazy good and the cheesecake and lava cake were amazing too. really a great nite, where i thought two girls surrounded by too much testosterone would get lost.

2
★★★★☆

my friend and i celebrated my 40th birthday there on a thursday nite. the drinks were super strong which was great. the door staff and bartenders were terrific. our server was lacking sincerity and interest, but then another server stopped by, 'cal' i think she said her name was and she was pleasant. the food was really exceptional, something i wasn't expecting. from the shrimp and clams oreganato to the ceasar salad. the ny sirloin was tender, juicy, sooo tasty and the garlic potatoes, although not a favorite were just right. the bread pudding was crazy good and the cheesecake and lava cake were amazing too. really a great nite, where i thought two girls surrounded by too much testosterone would get lost.

Pros: strong drinks, great food

Cons: server was a stiff

.

I usually love angelo & maxies and will probably still go back despite my last experience. We had a late reservation and were the last table to be seated in the dining room. There were 3 of us that sat and we had one more on the way - we promised to order for him and get everything in motion. We had about 4 appetizers (seafood tower, beef tartar, etc) and our last guest arrived after we had ordered the entrees (his included). About 1/2 way through the restaurant was empty except for our table and another one with two girls who were paying the bill. I kept watching the manager send the busboys over to try and clear our food when we were nowhere near finished. The manager even came over after dessert menus were dropped and overheard us talking about a club we were thinking about heading to afterwards. His words exactly "I know the doorman over there, so if you guys skip dessert I'll make a call and get you right in." We told him no thanks and ordered dessert and coffee. About 5 minutes later he cut the music and turned the lights on. At this point, the meal was ruined and we were really annoyed Our server was amazing and even apologized numerous times for his manager.................the guy even followed us out the door to promptly lock it behind us!! I like the steaks there and the service is usually great - the night manager (a large guy with no manners) needs to go!!!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I usually love angelo & maxies and will probably still go back despite my last experience. We had a late reservation and were the last table to be seated in the dining room. There were 3 of us that sat and we had one more on the way - we promised to order for him and get everything in motion. We had about 4 appetizers (seafood tower, beef tartar, etc) and our last guest arrived after we had ordered the entrees (his included). About 1/2 way through the restaurant was empty except for our table and another one with two girls who were paying the bill. I kept watching the manager send the busboys over to try and clear our food when we were nowhere near finished. The manager even came over after dessert menus were dropped and overheard us talking about a club we were thinking about heading to afterwards. His words exactly "I know the doorman over there, so if you guys skip dessert I'll make a call and get you right in." We told him no thanks and ordered dessert and coffee. About 5 minutes later he cut the music and turned the lights on. At this point, the meal was ruined and we were really annoyed Our server was amazing and even apologized numerous times for his manager.................the guy even followed us out the door to promptly lock it behind us!! I like the steaks there and the service is usually great - the night manager (a large guy with no manners) needs to go!!!

Pros: Good Steaks

Cons: Horrible Manager

.

My company recently hosted a dinner for a rather large group at Angelo and Maxie's. We had a rowdy crowd, plus the complication of bringing in a kosher meal, but the waitstaff handled everything flawlessly. The food was also outstanding...sometimes limited menus for large groups can disappoint, but we felt we had the pick of all the best things on the menu. This group makes a point of going to great steakhouses for this annual event, and A&M's definitely lived up to -or even exceeded- everyone's expectations. Also, I was impressed with how easy it was to plan the dinner with A&M's event coordinator...just a few quick phone calls and we were all set to go. We will definitely look forward to returning for future events.

2
★★★★★

My company recently hosted a dinner for a rather large group at Angelo and Maxie's. We had a rowdy crowd, plus the complication of bringing in a kosher meal, but the waitstaff handled everything flawlessly. The food was also outstanding...sometimes limited menus for large groups can disappoint, but we felt we had the pick of all the best things on the menu. This group makes a point of going to great steakhouses for this annual event, and A&M's definitely lived up to -or even exceeded- everyone's expectations. Also, I was impressed with how easy it was to plan the dinner with A&M's event coordinator...just a few quick phone calls and we were all set to go. We will definitely look forward to returning for future events.

Pros: Great, timely service for large group and nice limited menu.

Cons: Would have preferred a private room, but the semi-private room worked just fine.

.

Great place steak and seafood, also have great lunch menu. A little on the expensive side, but consistently good.

2
★★★★★

Great place steak and seafood, also have great lunch menu. A little on the expensive side, but consistently good.

.

I was responsible for putting together a bachelor party for the groom. After searching out the deals of several steakhouses in the city, Angelo & Maxie's had the best pre-fix menu. Needless to say, the party went VERY smoothly, without the occassional bumps people expect with large groups. The food was delicious and service incredibly attentive. I would definitely go back with a large group or with a few friends. It's hard to find a courteous and yummy restaurant in the city without loosing your shirt on the price.

2
★★★★★

I was responsible for putting together a bachelor party for the groom. After searching out the deals of several steakhouses in the city, Angelo & Maxie's had the best pre-fix menu. Needless to say, the party went VERY smoothly, without the occassional bumps people expect with large groups. The food was delicious and service incredibly attentive. I would definitely go back with a large group or with a few friends. It's hard to find a courteous and yummy restaurant in the city without loosing your shirt on the price.

Pros: Service, Good for Groups, Booth Seats, Yummy Steaks and Sides

Cons: None

.

Have been to A&M a few times with clients. Always can count on good food, atmosphere and attentive staff. You really can't go wrong if you are looking for steak... especially if you have the expense account!

2
★★★★☆

Have been to A&M a few times with clients. Always can count on good food, atmosphere and attentive staff. You really can't go wrong if you are looking for steak... especially if you have the expense account!

.

I finally got to try Angelo and Maxie's after hearing much buzz about it. IT did not disappoint. We all got steak and it was delicous. The bar scene was bussing too. I would recommend this place for a friends dinner or a romanti night out.

2
★★★★★

I finally got to try Angelo and Maxie's after hearing much buzz about it. IT did not disappoint. We all got steak and it was delicous. The bar scene was bussing too. I would recommend this place for a friends dinner or a romanti night out.

Pros: atmosphere

.

I would never visit here again. The service was horrible, and sadly the food just isn't good enough to make up for the rude waitstaff.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I would never visit here again. The service was horrible, and sadly the food just isn't good enough to make up for the rude waitstaff.

Cons: Service

.

The ambiance is wonderful and if you love steaks then this is the place for you. My niece took her boyfriend here and he just loved it since he loves steaks. The food here is delicious. I would highly recommend people going here.

4
★★★★☆

The ambiance is wonderful and if you love steaks then this is the place for you. My niece took her boyfriend here and he just loved it since he loves steaks. The food here is delicious. I would highly recommend people going here.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My expectations of this restaurant far exceeded. The service was efficient and friendly, great ambience. A little pricy, but well worth it. Will definitely visit again.

4
★★★★☆

My expectations of this restaurant far exceeded. The service was efficient and friendly, great ambience. A little pricy, but well worth it. Will definitely visit again.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

A friend of mine and I happened upon Angelo and Maxie's while looking for somewhere to eat dinner on a trip to NY this summer... the wait was relatively short, the steak and chocolate souffle were outstanding, the prices reasonable and the service extremely friendly and fast. Would definitely go back on my next trip.

2
★★★★★

A friend of mine and I happened upon Angelo and Maxie's while looking for somewhere to eat dinner on a trip to NY this summer... the wait was relatively short, the steak and chocolate souffle were outstanding, the prices reasonable and the service extremely friendly and fast. Would definitely go back on my next trip.

Pros: Atmosphere, Service, Food

Cons: Slightly crowded

.

Just got back from maxie's on Sunday night and i gotta tell you
the service was great as usual i came in around 7:30 pm without
reservations and without any waiting time food was great also had the
seafood sampler for 2 as impressive as ever delicious the sides were
wonderful creamed spinach and mashed were awesome my only problem was with
the steak i ordered the T-Bone medium and unfortunately it came a little
undercooked for my taste but still was a wonderful cut of meat i have to
say this place never fails to amaze food service and ambiance were great

2
★★★★☆

Just got back from maxie's on Sunday night and i gotta tell you
the service was great as usual i came in around 7:30 pm without
reservations and without any waiting time food was great also had the
seafood sampler for 2 as impressive as ever delicious the sides were
wonderful creamed spinach and mashed were awesome my only problem was with
the steak i ordered the T-Bone medium and unfortunately it came a little
undercooked for my taste but still was a wonderful cut of meat i have to
say this place never fails to amaze food service and ambiance were great

Pros: Steaks Seafood no matter what you choose you can't miss

Cons: None that i can see

.

very good food and service, but pricey. for an occasional splurge, or if you're spending with company $, highly recommended.

2
★★★★☆

very good food and service, but pricey. for an occasional splurge, or if you're spending with company $, highly recommended.

.

I am completely in love with Angelo's. I was introduced to A&M's
by my boss when i he took me here for a company dinner. I have been back
here 3 times since for dinner and the last time was for my bday and i have
to say the steak for 2 was one of the best steaks I have ever had. It
ranks right up there with the Luger's and Morton's and the Ruth's Chris but
after going to all three i have to say for sheer value flavor and fun
factor this is my choice i especially love the raw bar sampler for 2 wow
what an amazing seafood spread with lobster clams shrimps and oysters all
in all i have to say go here and try it for yourself and you will be
hooked.

2
★★★★★

I am completely in love with Angelo's. I was introduced to A&M's
by my boss when i he took me here for a company dinner. I have been back
here 3 times since for dinner and the last time was for my bday and i have
to say the steak for 2 was one of the best steaks I have ever had. It
ranks right up there with the Luger's and Morton's and the Ruth's Chris but
after going to all three i have to say for sheer value flavor and fun
factor this is my choice i especially love the raw bar sampler for 2 wow
what an amazing seafood spread with lobster clams shrimps and oysters all
in all i have to say go here and try it for yourself and you will be
hooked.

Pros: Amazing seafood and steaks. Nothing beats an after dinner Cognac with a fat stogie in their cigar room.

Cons: Parking can be a challenge being as it is located on Park and 19th

.

date_visited: Thanksgiving 2007
comments: Great clubby ambience and excellent waitstaff wearing stylish
suspendered uniforms. Huge portions of delicious food ;decadent deserts;
great value.
Thank you for a memorable Thanksgiving dining experience!

2
★★★★★

date_visited: Thanksgiving 2007
comments: Great clubby ambience and excellent waitstaff wearing stylish
suspendered uniforms. Huge portions of delicious food ;decadent deserts;
great value.
Thank you for a memorable Thanksgiving dining experience!

Pros: Clubby ambience,great service, excellent food

Cons: Why aren't there more branches of A&M?

.

my family is very aware that all birthdays,holidays,etc are spent at A&G. I can't eat asteak anywhere else for the last five years[especially the RIBEYE]! The drinks are the real stuff and plenty of it.When i pay the check i always feel "MONEY WELL SPENT". It's always a party and the sides are great in taste and size. my family and i always walk alittle just to get over the party at A&G. OH! BYE THE WAY THE SERVICE IS THE BEST!

2
★★★★★

my family is very aware that all birthdays,holidays,etc are spent at A&G. I can't eat asteak anywhere else for the last five years[especially the RIBEYE]! The drinks are the real stuff and plenty of it.When i pay the check i always feel "MONEY WELL SPENT". It's always a party and the sides are great in taste and size. my family and i always walk alittle just to get over the party at A&G. OH! BYE THE WAY THE SERVICE IS THE BEST!

.

Forget about the steak. Anything that spoils a great dinner is
bad attitude and service. Plenty of that at this lower tier steakhouse.
From the hostess to the reservation check in guy, you will forget
your steak and fume with disgust at the attitude.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Forget about the steak. Anything that spoils a great dinner is
bad attitude and service. Plenty of that at this lower tier steakhouse.
From the hostess to the reservation check in guy, you will forget
your steak and fume with disgust at the attitude.

.

Have been to Angelo & Maxie's three of four times before - so I'm a fan to begin with. But this time was for a small party (13 people). Highly recommend it. Amazing food... and tons of it! Unbelievably fair prices for a steakhouse in the city. Great service too. Not a single hiccup. I didn't have to worry about a thing - everything went as planned. The other guests absolutely loved it. They couldn't stop raving about it. And the honest truth, I didn't have to do much! For a good steak dinner in the city - try this place! You won't regret it.

2
★★★★★

Have been to Angelo & Maxie's three of four times before - so I'm a fan to begin with. But this time was for a small party (13 people). Highly recommend it. Amazing food... and tons of it! Unbelievably fair prices for a steakhouse in the city. Great service too. Not a single hiccup. I didn't have to worry about a thing - everything went as planned. The other guests absolutely loved it. They couldn't stop raving about it. And the honest truth, I didn't have to do much! For a good steak dinner in the city - try this place! You won't regret it.

.

The ambience is straight from the 80s with all the cliches where men were men and women were women. If you're looking for the nostalgic atmosphere of 80s decadence and gluttony then this is the place. It was fun to dine in this type of setting. The food was amazingly delicious. The steaks were aged perfectly and tasted amazing. The sides and appetizers were also equally tasty. The portions are made for sharing, but if you are feeling a bit indulgent then you can always eat the rib eye by yourself.

2
★★★★☆

The ambience is straight from the 80s with all the cliches where men were men and women were women. If you're looking for the nostalgic atmosphere of 80s decadence and gluttony then this is the place. It was fun to dine in this type of setting. The food was amazingly delicious. The steaks were aged perfectly and tasted amazing. The sides and appetizers were also equally tasty. The portions are made for sharing, but if you are feeling a bit indulgent then you can always eat the rib eye by yourself.

Pros: I had ordered the Rib eye steak for 2. I tried to share but it was so darn delicious.

Cons: 80s decadence and overindulgence is a bit tacky for me.

.

As a young working professional it's hard to get good service
but never at Angelo Maxies. I always enjoy the sophisticaed selection of
cigars (motnecrsito no2 is my favorite) and of course the premuim quality
of steaks. I always look forward to taking my clients, close friends, and
relatives for an awsome steak and service at the Maxies. Once agian thank
you.

2
★★★★★

As a young working professional it's hard to get good service
but never at Angelo Maxies. I always enjoy the sophisticaed selection of
cigars (motnecrsito no2 is my favorite) and of course the premuim quality
of steaks. I always look forward to taking my clients, close friends, and
relatives for an awsome steak and service at the Maxies. Once agian thank
you.

.

Ate at the restaurant for lunch during restaurant week. It was great, the steak was wonderful and i intend to come back for dinner with my husband soon. My coworkers and I were quite impressed with the food and
left feeling completely satisfied. Great job :)

2
★★★★★

Ate at the restaurant for lunch during restaurant week. It was great, the steak was wonderful and i intend to come back for dinner with my husband soon. My coworkers and I were quite impressed with the food and
left feeling completely satisfied. Great job :)

.

My favorite steakhouse in NYC. If you want a great steak, awesome service - this is your place. I used to live nearby and now I live in Miami and I still recommend and go there every chance I get. I also entertain customers there a lot and they love it. For the price, you can't beat it - compared to the best steak houses in the city, this one is tops. if you have someone to share the porterhouse with, do so! Under $50 for 2 ppl and you get 2 sides!! best deal for an awesome steak - if you're smart enough to order it medium rare of course! Nice wine selection too!

2
★★★★★

My favorite steakhouse in NYC. If you want a great steak, awesome service - this is your place. I used to live nearby and now I live in Miami and I still recommend and go there every chance I get. I also entertain customers there a lot and they love it. For the price, you can't beat it - compared to the best steak houses in the city, this one is tops. if you have someone to share the porterhouse with, do so! Under $50 for 2 ppl and you get 2 sides!! best deal for an awesome steak - if you're smart enough to order it medium rare of course! Nice wine selection too!

Pros: Delicious steaks, great price, nice ambiance

Cons: sometimes too crowded and tables are too close to each other - but that's NYC!

.

I am rarely pleasantly surprised by Restaurants any more. We all had
one of the best Dinners in a very long time. Each Dinner, the Appetizers,
the Sides Dishes and Salads were perfectly prepared and the portions very
generous. My Rib Eye was cooked to perfection and truly medium rare,
as requested. We ended up with 3 Potato orders because no one could
agree on which was best. Now I can?t either ? Shoestring Fries, Garlic
Mashed with brown onions and a House Specialty ? Fried Round disks
of Potato. The Creamed Spinach was wonderful. I am a lover of
Calamari and usually hesitant to order in an unknown Restaurant due to
the typical lack of expertise in preparing it correctly. The Calamari was
cooked to perfection - crispy light breading, not oily, and perfectly
prepared ? no rubber bands! The Dipping Sauce was not the usual
Fra Diavlo or Marinara, but a wonderful Tai Sauce that I would love
to have the Recipe for - it starts out on your pallet as sweet and soon
brings a wonderful tang and a little heat.

We all waddled out completely full and I have enough Ribeye in my
take home bag to look forward to for another dinner and possibly a
sandwich for lunch!

On top of it all - our Waiter was fun, perfectly attentive and extremely
courteous. My Sister-in-Law has extreme dietary needs which he
coordinated with the kitchen on several dishes politely and adeptly.
He served us well on a very busy Saturday Night - our reservations
were for 7:30 PM. We were not hurried and did not realize how long
we had stayed due to the great food and atmosphere.

Angelo and Maxie?s has perfected their food and service to the delight of us
all! We thank them for making our eating experience one we will all return to
repeat. Every Client I have will be taken there in the future. I can not wait
for my Son and Daughter-in-Law?s next visit from Los Angeles ? I have a
real treat for them!

2
★★★★★

I am rarely pleasantly surprised by Restaurants any more. We all had
one of the best Dinners in a very long time. Each Dinner, the Appetizers,
the Sides Dishes and Salads were perfectly prepared and the portions very
generous. My Rib Eye was cooked to perfection and truly medium rare,
as requested. We ended up with 3 Potato orders because no one could
agree on which was best. Now I can?t either ? Shoestring Fries, Garlic
Mashed with brown onions and a House Specialty ? Fried Round disks
of Potato. The Creamed Spinach was wonderful. I am a lover of
Calamari and usually hesitant to order in an unknown Restaurant due to
the typical lack of expertise in preparing it correctly. The Calamari was
cooked to perfection - crispy light breading, not oily, and perfectly
prepared ? no rubber bands! The Dipping Sauce was not the usual
Fra Diavlo or Marinara, but a wonderful Tai Sauce that I would love
to have the Recipe for - it starts out on your pallet as sweet and soon
brings a wonderful tang and a little heat.

We all waddled out completely full and I have enough Ribeye in my
take home bag to look forward to for another dinner and possibly a
sandwich for lunch!

On top of it all - our Waiter was fun, perfectly attentive and extremely
courteous. My Sister-in-Law has extreme dietary needs which he
coordinated with the kitchen on several dishes politely and adeptly.
He served us well on a very busy Saturday Night - our reservations
were for 7:30 PM. We were not hurried and did not realize how long
we had stayed due to the great food and atmosphere.

Angelo and Maxie?s has perfected their food and service to the delight of us
all! We thank them for making our eating experience one we will all return to
repeat. Every Client I have will be taken there in the future. I can not wait
for my Son and Daughter-in-Law?s next visit from Los Angeles ? I have a
real treat for them!

Pros: Steak cooked to pefection - Family member with extreme dietary needs was accommodated

Cons: None

.

What a great time! We had a bachelor party of 8 people in the semi-private back room. All of our pre-selected appetizers and side dishes came out as ordered, service was fast and accurate. Our main dishes came out piping hot and everything was great tasting. I had the NY sirloin and it was amazing...tender and juicy. One of the better steaks I have had. Atmosphere was great and the price was right on point, waiters standing by to replenish drinks. No one left with an empty stomach. It felt like Thanksgiving! I'm still getting emails saying how great the food was. Two thumbs way up!

2
★★★★★

What a great time! We had a bachelor party of 8 people in the semi-private back room. All of our pre-selected appetizers and side dishes came out as ordered, service was fast and accurate. Our main dishes came out piping hot and everything was great tasting. I had the NY sirloin and it was amazing...tender and juicy. One of the better steaks I have had. Atmosphere was great and the price was right on point, waiters standing by to replenish drinks. No one left with an empty stomach. It felt like Thanksgiving! I'm still getting emails saying how great the food was. Two thumbs way up!

.

I had a party of 35 people in the private room. The steak, salmon and lamb were excellent and there were no mistakes with any of the orders made by our dinner party. The food from appetizers to all of the dinner choices we had worked out very well for the entire group. The service was amazing!!Drinks were constantly being served to the tables and food was served on a timely fashion throughout the evening. This was a AAA+ dinner from all aspects.

2
★★★★★

I had a party of 35 people in the private room. The steak, salmon and lamb were excellent and there were no mistakes with any of the orders made by our dinner party. The food from appetizers to all of the dinner choices we had worked out very well for the entire group. The service was amazing!!Drinks were constantly being served to the tables and food was served on a timely fashion throughout the evening. This was a AAA+ dinner from all aspects.

.

We had a group of 15 in the semi-private room. It was phenomenal service, the food was excellent and the waiters were on point anytime we needed a drink. The 28oz blackened rib eye that I had was one of the best pieces of meat I?ve ever tasted.

One of the best steakhouses I?ve ever eaten at; will surely make it back there. can not beat their menu for the price.

**Highly recommend

2
★★★★★

We had a group of 15 in the semi-private room. It was phenomenal service, the food was excellent and the waiters were on point anytime we needed a drink. The 28oz blackened rib eye that I had was one of the best pieces of meat I?ve ever tasted.

One of the best steakhouses I?ve ever eaten at; will surely make it back there. can not beat their menu for the price.

**Highly recommend

.

Listen if you love steak this is the place to be. Great environment, great food, and great staff. Trust me about this i go there 2 times a week. Of course this place is going to be noisy because its always packed! Great to go with your friends and have a good time.

2
★★★★★

Listen if you love steak this is the place to be. Great environment, great food, and great staff. Trust me about this i go there 2 times a week. Of course this place is going to be noisy because its always packed! Great to go with your friends and have a good time.

Pros: Awesome food and a great place to be

Cons: none

.

Arrived in NYC by private boat on Sunday afternoon. Early 5:30 reservation sat us right down. Waitress was outstanding and incredibly helpful with appetizers, especially the lump crabmeat bowl that was not on the menu ( enough for 3 hungry sailors!) . Carpaccio and oysters were top notch.Nice,reasonable bottle of Cab to go with dinner. I had the ribeye was excellent, had to chew the bone dry, and my mates had the filet au poivre and were duly impressed. Sides are plentiful and tasty, shoestring fries especially, and desserts were too much to handle after everything else. We'll be back by boat again in the fall!!

1
★★★☆☆

Arrived in NYC by private boat on Sunday afternoon. Early 5:30 reservation sat us right down. Waitress was outstanding and incredibly helpful with appetizers, especially the lump crabmeat bowl that was not on the menu ( enough for 3 hungry sailors!) . Carpaccio and oysters were top notch.Nice,reasonable bottle of Cab to go with dinner. I had the ribeye was excellent, had to chew the bone dry, and my mates had the filet au poivre and were duly impressed. Sides are plentiful and tasty, shoestring fries especially, and desserts were too much to handle after everything else. We'll be back by boat again in the fall!!

.

The staff working the door leave something to be desired!! We had an 8:00 reservation for 5, they had us down for a party of 4. Should not have been a real big deal, just add a chair to a 4-top. The "inexperienced" hostess who was working the book did not tell the lead maitre'd we were there and he kept ignoring us. Then other large parties, WITHOUT reservations were being seated, I think becuase the maitre'd did not know we were there. When I went up to him he tried to remedy it. But I'm pretty sure they gave our table away. By this time we actually had a 6th person decide to join us. So I expected to wait a minute, but again should not be a big deal, we were a reservation for 5, so just add a chair (s) to the table (provided it's not in a high traffic area. Instead the maitre'd made us wait for a 1/2 hour and kept asking us if all our party was there. We were 5 out 6. He honestly asked us if we would be ordering drinks if we were seated. No, we'd just sit there and sip tap water. Besides it's not like we were ordering from the bar. You couldn't get to it with all the people just standing around. Finally our 6th showed up, were were seated at (SURPRISE) a 4 top table with 2 chairs added on to make 6. So for our original (mistaken) reservation we waited over a half-hour to be seated. There are better steak houses and better restaurants in the area to choose from than to have to get this kind of service from A&M. Oh & the martini's were awful!!

1
★★★☆☆

The staff working the door leave something to be desired!! We had an 8:00 reservation for 5, they had us down for a party of 4. Should not have been a real big deal, just add a chair to a 4-top. The "inexperienced" hostess who was working the book did not tell the lead maitre'd we were there and he kept ignoring us. Then other large parties, WITHOUT reservations were being seated, I think becuase the maitre'd did not know we were there. When I went up to him he tried to remedy it. But I'm pretty sure they gave our table away. By this time we actually had a 6th person decide to join us. So I expected to wait a minute, but again should not be a big deal, we were a reservation for 5, so just add a chair (s) to the table (provided it's not in a high traffic area. Instead the maitre'd made us wait for a 1/2 hour and kept asking us if all our party was there. We were 5 out 6. He honestly asked us if we would be ordering drinks if we were seated. No, we'd just sit there and sip tap water. Besides it's not like we were ordering from the bar. You couldn't get to it with all the people just standing around. Finally our 6th showed up, were were seated at (SURPRISE) a 4 top table with 2 chairs added on to make 6. So for our original (mistaken) reservation we waited over a half-hour to be seated. There are better steak houses and better restaurants in the area to choose from than to have to get this kind of service from A&M. Oh & the martini's were awful!!

Pros: good steak

Cons: very poor service

.

My friend took here for dinner and I must say I was impressed. I ordered the new york strip steak and it was the best steak I have had in a long time. The portion was just right and wonderfully seasoned and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere while a bit loud is quite appealing with great music. The service was outstanding. But the best of the best the whole nite was the chocolate martinis and the mojitos. Absolutely outstanding drinks. This is definately a must go to spot that I highly recommend, it won't disappoint.

2
★★★★☆

My friend took here for dinner and I must say I was impressed. I ordered the new york strip steak and it was the best steak I have had in a long time. The portion was just right and wonderfully seasoned and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere while a bit loud is quite appealing with great music. The service was outstanding. But the best of the best the whole nite was the chocolate martinis and the mojitos. Absolutely outstanding drinks. This is definately a must go to spot that I highly recommend, it won't disappoint.

Pros: Great steak, delicious cocktails,dim lighting.

Cons: A bit noisy

.

I went to Angelo & Maxies Steakhouse grudgingly- I don't eat red meat, but my friends were raving about it so I gave in. Am I ever glad I did! I had the salmon- which was beyond sublime! It melted in my mouth, it was so flaky and delicious. The sauce was delicate and pleasing to the palate. I also had the creamed spinach and mashed potatoes to accompany my salmon, and they were fabulous as well! The prices were quite reasonable for a steakhouse, and the portions for the side dishes are huge- the spinach and potatoes fed our entire party of four, and there were left overs! The service is prompt and attentive- though the lighting is a little low for my tastes, it made reading the menu a bit difficult- but that didn't detract from my dining experience at all. Overall, I haven't any real complaints about Angelo & Maxies Steakhouse except that they haven't any in L.A. where I now reside- so when I make my forays back home to NYC, I know where I'll definitely be stopping!

2
★★★★★

I went to Angelo & Maxies Steakhouse grudgingly- I don't eat red meat, but my friends were raving about it so I gave in. Am I ever glad I did! I had the salmon- which was beyond sublime! It melted in my mouth, it was so flaky and delicious. The sauce was delicate and pleasing to the palate. I also had the creamed spinach and mashed potatoes to accompany my salmon, and they were fabulous as well! The prices were quite reasonable for a steakhouse, and the portions for the side dishes are huge- the spinach and potatoes fed our entire party of four, and there were left overs! The service is prompt and attentive- though the lighting is a little low for my tastes, it made reading the menu a bit difficult- but that didn't detract from my dining experience at all. Overall, I haven't any real complaints about Angelo & Maxies Steakhouse except that they haven't any in L.A. where I now reside- so when I make my forays back home to NYC, I know where I'll definitely be stopping!

Pros: Food, service, price and portion size

Cons: Lighting is a little low- not significant enough to be an issue though

.

the cow decor is pretty cute. the ribeye is the best in the city. never dry never overcooked. blackened or not, either way it's the best damn ribeye ever! Service is good. love their cute little bread basket with the little pretzel breads. they make great coffee too. the cappichino is great, never burned and made to perfection. its not too pricey there, and again the cows make it worth while....

2
★★★★☆

the cow decor is pretty cute. the ribeye is the best in the city. never dry never overcooked. blackened or not, either way it's the best damn ribeye ever! Service is good. love their cute little bread basket with the little pretzel breads. they make great coffee too. the cappichino is great, never burned and made to perfection. its not too pricey there, and again the cows make it worth while....

.

After hearing from everyone how great Angelo & Maxie's was, I finally decided to check it out for myself and went there with a group of friends. Our reservation for 5 was honored in a very timely fashion and we were seated promptly. Our servers were very helpful in chosing the right cuts of meat and we were extremely satisfied. Our party ordered salmon (amazing), filet mignon (succulent as ever), NY strip (packed with intense flavor) and ribeye (lick-your-fingers declicious). Creamed spicach was perfect too. There were two minor downsides -- one that the wine list was rather limited and the other was that our shoestring fries got cold really fast and were not as enjoyable as they could have been. Overall, it was a great experience and we will definately be back again.

2
★★★★★

After hearing from everyone how great Angelo & Maxie's was, I finally decided to check it out for myself and went there with a group of friends. Our reservation for 5 was honored in a very timely fashion and we were seated promptly. Our servers were very helpful in chosing the right cuts of meat and we were extremely satisfied. Our party ordered salmon (amazing), filet mignon (succulent as ever), NY strip (packed with intense flavor) and ribeye (lick-your-fingers declicious). Creamed spicach was perfect too. There were two minor downsides -- one that the wine list was rather limited and the other was that our shoestring fries got cold really fast and were not as enjoyable as they could have been. Overall, it was a great experience and we will definately be back again.

Pros: best steaks and creamed spinach

Cons: limited wine list

.

I dont even know where to begin...my husband and I got a gift certificate to eat here as a wedding present. I waiter was absent almost the entire meal and very short and snotty when he was at our table. At the end of the night, my husband went to pay the bill and put down his credit card as well as our gift certificate. The waiter threw an absolute hissy fit, saying he hated when people used gift cards becuase those people never tip (my husband always leaves over 20%). I got up to use the ladies room after the waiter left and walked by him on the way. He said 'Nice a$$' and snickered as I walked past.
I was furious, so when I got back to the table, my husband and I got up to leave. My husband was very flustered at this point, and he accidentally left the wrong CC receipt copy in the folder (both were signed with tip included). As we were walking out to leave, he came and grabbed my husband and started screaming at him, accusing him of walking out on his tab. We were so confused and dumbfounded. My husband gave him the other reciept, and we left very upset.
To make matters worse...I contacted the restaurant afterwards (which I have NEVER done, but it was that bad) and the owner had the audacity to question my story. He challenged me to come in and 'pick him out in a line up' . I will NEVER eat at this horrible place again, and I suggest you pick another place to eat if you are looking for a good steak house - the food is mediocre and its not worth the horrible treatment. Try The Knickerbocker, Keens, or Ruths Chris - I have never been disappointed at any of these places.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I dont even know where to begin...my husband and I got a gift certificate to eat here as a wedding present. I waiter was absent almost the entire meal and very short and snotty when he was at our table. At the end of the night, my husband went to pay the bill and put down his credit card as well as our gift certificate. The waiter threw an absolute hissy fit, saying he hated when people used gift cards becuase those people never tip (my husband always leaves over 20%). I got up to use the ladies room after the waiter left and walked by him on the way. He said 'Nice a$$' and snickered as I walked past.
I was furious, so when I got back to the table, my husband and I got up to leave. My husband was very flustered at this point, and he accidentally left the wrong CC receipt copy in the folder (both were signed with tip included). As we were walking out to leave, he came and grabbed my husband and started screaming at him, accusing him of walking out on his tab. We were so confused and dumbfounded. My husband gave him the other reciept, and we left very upset.
To make matters worse...I contacted the restaurant afterwards (which I have NEVER done, but it was that bad) and the owner had the audacity to question my story. He challenged me to come in and 'pick him out in a line up' . I will NEVER eat at this horrible place again, and I suggest you pick another place to eat if you are looking for a good steak house - the food is mediocre and its not worth the horrible treatment. Try The Knickerbocker, Keens, or Ruths Chris - I have never been disappointed at any of these places.

Pros: none

Cons: service was horrible and it was obnoxiously loud

Editorial from

The after-work home of Wall Street steam blowers, frat reunions, and bachelor parties, it's easy to get put off by the boisterous atmosphere of this meaty joint. Don't be. For starters, the restaurant lacks the prohibitive price tag of…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Angelo & Maxie's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review