I have been to The Pit probably 15 times, so this review is not based on one good or bad experience. I've been for lunch and dinner, weekday and weekend. I'd say overall, this is a fantastic place to dine. The food has been consistently delicious. Of the 15 times I've been, maybe 2 times the food was not "amazing" but just "okay." One time the ribs were dry and the other time the pulled pork (at lunch) tasted like MAYBE it was warmed over. But the other 13 times, it was delicious. I think that's a pretty good percentage. I definitely prefer the ribs, pulled pork, barbecued and fried chicken to their chopped pork (which I thought was slightly mushy but I only tried it once). They also have a "turkey barbecue" that is delicious and a healthier opton. The sides are fresh and the food is always hot.
Sometimes I have to say the service is not that great, but it does seem to be getting better. All the service problems I had were in the first few months of them opening. But lately I have not had problems.
I also think the prices are really reasonable. You get a full r a c k (LOL: citysearch won't let me type the word R A C K!) of ribs with sides for $20 and you can go to chain places and the ribs cost more and aren't as tasty. Plus the Pit has organic (antibiotic free) pork, if that matters to you.
This doesn't take the place of the "greasy diner" type 'cue places like Coopers, but there is room for both folks, so don't go trashing the Pit b/c it's not Coopers. This is a great place to take the family out to dinner at night, to take out-of-town guests, or have business lunches.
The Pit is definitely a favorite.
Pros: delicious food, great ambience
Cons: spotty service