Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

★★★★☆
40.9236 -73.0459
Map and Directions to Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

631-928-4972

1049 Rte 112

Port Jeffrsn Sta, NY

11776

Get Directions

About Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

Details
Hours
Daily, 11am - midnight
4.375 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 8 of 8.
.

Absolute favorite pizza ever! I grew up in Port Jefferson, and I moved away about 3 years ago, and I frequently make the 30 minute trip JUST to get their pizza!!! Incredible.

5
★★★★★

Absolute favorite pizza ever! I grew up in Port Jefferson, and I moved away about 3 years ago, and I frequently make the 30 minute trip JUST to get their pizza!!! Incredible.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Colosseo is a family favorite. Even though we don't live as close anymore, we occasionally make a special trip just for Colosseo pizza and garlic knots.

4
★★★★☆

Colosseo is a family favorite. Even though we don't live as close anymore, we occasionally make a special trip just for Colosseo pizza and garlic knots.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

Colosseo serves pizza only....And what pizza ! The crusts and sauces are consistently authentic and done to perfection. You can have a salad as well and that, too, is good. It gets crowded at the usual eating hours, but you can order ahead and pick up your pies.

5
★★★★★

Colosseo serves pizza only....And what pizza ! The crusts and sauces are consistently authentic and done to perfection. You can have a salad as well and that, too, is good. It gets crowded at the usual eating hours, but you can order ahead and pick up your pies.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

the pizza is pretty good the crust is a little crunchy i prefer it a little less so. the short girl in the front always hooks up my son and i with free slices and free ice's. it's pretty expensive to go all the time, but i make sure to go

6
★★★★★

the pizza is pretty good the crust is a little crunchy i prefer it a little less so. the short girl in the front always hooks up my son and i with free slices and free ice's. it's pretty expensive to go all the time, but i make sure to go

.

Good pizza but over rated and overpriced. usually long wait and crowded. Most expensive around. Never coupons or specials. You'd think with such a loyal following they could do something for their customers once and a while.

3
★★★☆☆

Good pizza but over rated and overpriced. usually long wait and crowded. Most expensive around. Never coupons or specials. You'd think with such a loyal following they could do something for their customers once and a while.

.

The workers at counter try to get you out so fast the food is never hot .I wrote this after many tries at saying please make it very hot figuring at least i could get home(1mile)with warm pizza and of course i was wrong .I ordered a stuff slice which of course i knew would be cold.When I saw him put it in the box I asked why it was half the size of the other stuffed slices and his rocket science answer was it has a lot of meat in it and i don't make the prices.So i asked what does that have to do with you picking one half the size out of the three on the pan he laughed and said thats the way it is..So I called to tell them i wrote this review. I would go to Carnival up the road better system for pizza and i haven't met anyone as stupid as the guy i got today on may 16@6:30...another customer lost due to bad service i am sure there will be more

2
★★☆☆☆

The workers at counter try to get you out so fast the food is never hot .I wrote this after many tries at saying please make it very hot figuring at least i could get home(1mile)with warm pizza and of course i was wrong .I ordered a stuff slice which of course i knew would be cold.When I saw him put it in the box I asked why it was half the size of the other stuffed slices and his rocket science answer was it has a lot of meat in it and i don't make the prices.So i asked what does that have to do with you picking one half the size out of the three on the pan he laughed and said thats the way it is..So I called to tell them i wrote this review. I would go to Carnival up the road better system for pizza and i haven't met anyone as stupid as the guy i got today on may 16@6:30...another customer lost due to bad service i am sure there will be more

Pros: good if you sit

Cons: cold and incompetent at counter

.

we have to travel from wading river , this pizza is great , I wish they had one near our home,great service and taste

5
★★★★★

we have to travel from wading river , this pizza is great , I wish they had one near our home,great service and taste

Pros: parking , location

Cons: a little far

.

There pizza is to die for, Its the greatest on long island.

5
★★★★★

There pizza is to die for, Its the greatest on long island.

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Carnival Restaurant
    5% ★★★★★ 8 reviews
    0.43 mi
  2. 2
    Sicily Pizza Cafe
    No reviews
    0.59 mi
  3. 3
    Camillo's Pizza
    6% ★★★★★ 2 reviews
    0.63 mi
  4. 4
    0.88 mi
  5. 5
    0.90 mi