Island Mermaid

★★☆☆☆
  • 780 Bay Walk

    Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    Map & Directions
  • 631-583-8088

Food

Food
More choices in Ocean Beach:
Resultset_next

Argyle Grill & Tavern

90 Deer Park Ave Babylon, NY

Resultset_next

McDonald's

131 Sunrise Hwy West Islip, NY

2.2 5
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Island Mermaid was?
Write a Review
.

I would like to thank Mr. Zero Tolerance for his warm,friendly,accomodating demeanor embracing my guest and I.
After being seated,we anxiously waited to place our order for the clambake.This was our sole and primary reason for choosing this establishment.We were informed that the clambake was no longer available. I requested to speak to the manager or the person in charge.I stood by my table awaiting his arrival.Before I even opened my mouth.Mr.Zero Tolerance psychologically ambushed me in a smug,arrogant,obnoxious condescending manner and barked,"Sit Down!"I was totally appalled at such reprehensible behavior but relented in order to not make a scene..Mr.Diplomacy gave us our options for a meal.We settled on the crab legs which turned out to be $20.00 more when our bill had arrived..
At no point during our meal did Mr. Congeniality pass by our table to make an accomodation.concession or the most minute inkling of a gesture for just minimal appeasement.
(ex.Is everything satisfactory ?or How are you enjoying your meal?) It was as if Mr. Personality deliberately went out of his way to ostracize us even though he did give us the sole privilege of dining in this hostile environment.
Though I was the one that conceded.I felt as if I was ""eating crow"" instead of ""crab legs""..
In conclusion, I can honestly say that I have never been subjected or treated in such a deigning.demeaning, degradating manner in any establishment that I had patronized.
So diners if you dare to dine at Island Mermaid
''BEWARE U2
may encounter a venomous ''SEA SERPENT""

0
★☆☆☆☆

I would like to thank Mr. Zero Tolerance for his warm,friendly,accomodating demeanor embracing my guest and I.
After being seated,we anxiously waited to place our order for the clambake.This was our sole and primary reason for choosing this establishment.We were informed that the clambake was no longer available. I requested to speak to the manager or the person in charge.I stood by my table awaiting his arrival.Before I even opened my mouth.Mr.Zero Tolerance psychologically ambushed me in a smug,arrogant,obnoxious condescending manner and barked,"Sit Down!"I was totally appalled at such reprehensible behavior but relented in order to not make a scene..Mr.Diplomacy gave us our options for a meal.We settled on the crab legs which turned out to be $20.00 more when our bill had arrived..
At no point during our meal did Mr. Congeniality pass by our table to make an accomodation.concession or the most minute inkling of a gesture for just minimal appeasement.
(ex.Is everything satisfactory ?or How are you enjoying your meal?) It was as if Mr. Personality deliberately went out of his way to ostracize us even though he did give us the sole privilege of dining in this hostile environment.
Though I was the one that conceded.I felt as if I was ""eating crow"" instead of ""crab legs""..
In conclusion, I can honestly say that I have never been subjected or treated in such a deigning.demeaning, degradating manner in any establishment that I had patronized.
So diners if you dare to dine at Island Mermaid
''BEWARE U2
may encounter a venomous ''SEA SERPENT""

Pros: waterfront dining & music

Cons: Everythiing else!

.

Steamers were fantastic; clams on the half shell were good too. Had the best cheddar cheese burger medium rare. Was out of this world. Would definitely go back on my next trip to Fire Island, Ocean Beach!

2
★★★★☆

Steamers were fantastic; clams on the half shell were good too. Had the best cheddar cheese burger medium rare. Was out of this world. Would definitely go back on my next trip to Fire Island, Ocean Beach!

Pros: Deck, of course

Cons: None that I know of

.

They messed up my order. Wouldn't fix it. Didn't offer an alternative, or a free drink; nothing. I had to sit with no meal while my friends finished theirs.
Very strange.

0
★☆☆☆☆

They messed up my order. Wouldn't fix it. Didn't offer an alternative, or a free drink; nothing. I had to sit with no meal while my friends finished theirs.
Very strange.

Pros: view

Cons: service

.

The lunch was great here. Great atmosphere and view of the Great South Bay. Just pull up on your boat. The food is fresh. If you come late in the season they do not have everything on the menu. Good Service.

4
★★★★☆

The lunch was great here. Great atmosphere and view of the Great South Bay. Just pull up on your boat. The food is fresh. If you come late in the season they do not have everything on the menu. Good Service.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The service was abominable. It took 20 minutes to get a drink and 40-45 to get my Cobb Salad. The salad had less than an ounce of protein. I wanted to return it but that would have taken too long. When I gave the female server cash for my check she disappeared. I had to contac tanother server to locate her for the change.. NEVER AGAIN!

0
★☆☆☆☆

The service was abominable. It took 20 minutes to get a drink and 40-45 to get my Cobb Salad. The salad had less than an ounce of protein. I wanted to return it but that would have taken too long. When I gave the female server cash for my check she disappeared. I had to contac tanother server to locate her for the change.. NEVER AGAIN!

Pros: I sat by the dock outdoors.

Cons: Service and food.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Island Mermaid, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review