Robert's

★★★★☆
  • 755 Montauk Hwy

    Water Mill, NY 11976

    Map & Directions
  • 631-726-7171

About Robert's

Hours
Fri-Sat: 6pm-9:30pm, Sun-Thu: 6pm-9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Water Mill:
Resultset_next

Espresso

184 Division St Sag Harbor, NY

Resultset_next

Armand's

1271 Noyack Rd Southampton, MA

4.0 1
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Robert's was?
Write a Review
.

We've had one great meal and one terrible meal at Robert's. The great meal was a wonderful, romantic experience. The terrible meal was just a nightmare...We were a group of 7, and they was something wrong with at least half the appetizers and entrees. And when we pointed out that the calamari were incredibly chewy, or that the pasta was glutinous and all stuck together, we were told "Sorry it's not to your liking," clearly placing the burden on us, rather than taking responsibility for poor quality food and/or preparation. And when we complained to the host, he only offered excuses (the calamari is "local" and therefore more chewy than normal...the pasta is "rustic" and therefore more sticky"...Not even the hint of an apology. We're going to give it one more try, but if it's a disappointment, that's the end of Robert's for us.

2
★★★★☆

We've had one great meal and one terrible meal at Robert's. The great meal was a wonderful, romantic experience. The terrible meal was just a nightmare...We were a group of 7, and they was something wrong with at least half the appetizers and entrees. And when we pointed out that the calamari were incredibly chewy, or that the pasta was glutinous and all stuck together, we were told "Sorry it's not to your liking," clearly placing the burden on us, rather than taking responsibility for poor quality food and/or preparation. And when we complained to the host, he only offered excuses (the calamari is "local" and therefore more chewy than normal...the pasta is "rustic" and therefore more sticky"...Not even the hint of an apology. We're going to give it one more try, but if it's a disappointment, that's the end of Robert's for us.

Pros: Atmosphere, Food (when good!)

Cons: Service can be snippy, Food (when bad!)

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Robert's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review