La Cantina Toscana

★★★★★
Tuscan-style restaurant with a selection of wild game, in addition to pasta, other meats and fish; lunch and dinner, wine list.

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Ribot

780 3rd Ave New York, NY

Resultset_next

Lombardi's Pizza

32 Spring St A New York, NY

5 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how La Cantina Toscana was?
Write a Review
.

I recently went here for a dinner party and was very happy with the service. The hostess' were gracious and the restaurant wasn't too crowded. The food was delicious and not overpriced.

4
★★★★☆

I recently went here for a dinner party and was very happy with the service. The hostess' were gracious and the restaurant wasn't too crowded. The food was delicious and not overpriced.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The food is way overpriced based on both its quality and quantity. The service is bad. It may have been good at one time, but not when I went. Skip it.

3
★★★★★

The food is way overpriced based on both its quality and quantity. The service is bad. It may have been good at one time, but not when I went. Skip it.

.

Delicious homemade pastas, a menu heavy on wild game, baby eels, and under-offered meats like pheasant and dishes like panzanella. I had a delicious homemade papardelle with porcini mushrooms that was perfectly seasoned with soft, meaty,

3
★★★★★

Delicious homemade pastas, a menu heavy on wild game, baby eels, and under-offered meats like pheasant and dishes like panzanella. I had a delicious homemade papardelle with porcini mushrooms that was perfectly seasoned with soft, meaty,

Pros: Authentic italian, not red sauce, no reservations necessary

Cons: Uninspired ambience, across from Bed Bath & Beyond

.

We ate here two weeks ago and had an amazing meal. There was a problem with our reservation, but the owner gave us a free bottle of wine which we were able to choose from the wine list. We all had the wild game tasting menu which was

3
★★★★★

We ate here two weeks ago and had an amazing meal. There was a problem with our reservation, but the owner gave us a free bottle of wine which we were able to choose from the wine list. We all had the wild game tasting menu which was

Pros: Amazing food

Cons: Might have to wait to be seated

.

Thank goodness catsmom will not go here anymore!\r
Only you (or your husband) know how asparagus can be overwhelming in taste! they are used to balance out flavors because they are mild...your husband probably wanted cheese because people

3
★★★★★

Thank goodness catsmom will not go here anymore!\r
Only you (or your husband) know how asparagus can be overwhelming in taste! they are used to balance out flavors because they are mild...your husband probably wanted cheese because people

Pros: true tuscan food

Cons: ignorant guests

.

We have been going to this restaurant for the past year and it is one of our favorites--and we have dined as some of the best. The chef and host/server (Maximiliano) are co-owners from Italy. You cannot get more authentic. For the

3
★★★★★

We have been going to this restaurant for the past year and it is one of our favorites--and we have dined as some of the best. The chef and host/server (Maximiliano) are co-owners from Italy. You cannot get more authentic. For the

Pros: Specials, Service, Authenticity

.

My husband, mother (85), daughter and I had a unique experience at La Cantina Toscana last week. My husband wanted to try a new dish (pasta with shrimp and asparagus) and I ordered a pasta with porcini mushrooms. When we received our

3
★★★★★

My husband, mother (85), daughter and I had a unique experience at La Cantina Toscana last week. My husband wanted to try a new dish (pasta with shrimp and asparagus) and I ordered a pasta with porcini mushrooms. When we received our

.

Having just returned from vacation in Firenze, I was shopping at a store near this restaurant and happened upon it! What luck. It is very small and I felt as if we were back in Tuscany. My mouth was watering reading the menu, so we

3
★★★★★

Having just returned from vacation in Firenze, I was shopping at a store near this restaurant and happened upon it! What luck. It is very small and I felt as if we were back in Tuscany. My mouth was watering reading the menu, so we

Pros: fresh authentic food, wild game, italian vibe

Cons: small, one bathroom

.

The restaurant looks quaint and inviting from the street. they have an interesting menu with a variety of wild game dishes - ex: wild boar etc along with your more traditional dishes. Server had a bit of an attitude when told that the

3
★★★★★

The restaurant looks quaint and inviting from the street. they have an interesting menu with a variety of wild game dishes - ex: wild boar etc along with your more traditional dishes. Server had a bit of an attitude when told that the

Pros: ambience, quiet

Review Partner
.

i am from italy and this is the best meal i had so far.......the owners are from florence.. and the caos is...

2
★★★★★

i am from italy and this is the best meal i had so far.......the owners are from florence.. and the caos is...

Editorial from

In Short
A cloth banner bearing the Italian name for Florence proudly declares the chef's origins at this narrow brick-lined restaurant. White tablecloths and glass sconces keep the neighborhood's moneyed crowd feeling pampered,…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used La Cantina Toscana, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review