Amish Market

★★★☆☆
  • 240 E 45th St

    New York, NY 10017

    Map & Directions
  • 212-370-1761

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Antique Cafe

55 West 26th Street New York, NY

Resultset_next

Happy Ending

302 Broome St New York, NY

3.4 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Amish Market was?
Write a Review
.

This place has a wide range of fresh and packaged foods, plus lots of prepared foods for lunch. The food is very high quality and they have a great assortment. Not cheap, but you get quality. Lots of organic types of options here.

5
★★★★★

This place has a wide range of fresh and packaged foods, plus lots of prepared foods for lunch. The food is very high quality and they have a great assortment. Not cheap, but you get quality. Lots of organic types of options here.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This place is a favorite of mine. You can get perfect deli food to eat later, or all varieties of snacks. I really enjoy getting coffee beans from the Amish Market. Definitely check this store out.

5
★★★★★

This place is a favorite of mine. You can get perfect deli food to eat later, or all varieties of snacks. I really enjoy getting coffee beans from the Amish Market. Definitely check this store out.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This place has a lot of gourmet foods, bagels, sushi, sandwiches, soup, and more. Don't want to cook, you can drop in and pick up something to heat at home that's like a gourmet meal.

5
★★★★★

This place has a lot of gourmet foods, bagels, sushi, sandwiches, soup, and more. Don't want to cook, you can drop in and pick up something to heat at home that's like a gourmet meal.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I had pizza the other day at the aish market on 45th st., it was some experience. I ordered 2 pies and a roasr beef sandwich from the pizza station. The guy behind the counter was so rude. He's a loud mouth italian, who thinks he owns the place.( Does he? ) He was constantly on the phone with someone yelling and by the words that he used i would assume it was a woman. There was total disregard for customers. By the time he got around to my order, i didn't even want to look over at him. I finally got back to the office with the pies. They were o.k.,but nothing to brag about. I sure don't plan on standing in line again, to get lousy service.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I had pizza the other day at the aish market on 45th st., it was some experience. I ordered 2 pies and a roasr beef sandwich from the pizza station. The guy behind the counter was so rude. He's a loud mouth italian, who thinks he owns the place.( Does he? ) He was constantly on the phone with someone yelling and by the words that he used i would assume it was a woman. There was total disregard for customers. By the time he got around to my order, i didn't even want to look over at him. I finally got back to the office with the pies. They were o.k.,but nothing to brag about. I sure don't plan on standing in line again, to get lousy service.

.

I went here to this market on Good Friday to pick up lunch for a small group in my office and it was very quiet. Approached the deli counter and began to read the sandwich board, the deli man seemed a bit rushed and pressed for my order, when I began to give him the corralating #'s for each of the 5 sandwiches he seemed quite overwhelmed and shouted "whoa whoa whoa". It wasn't busy and it wasn't a complicated order but he was a bit rude. I left with the disticnct feeling I had annoyed the gentleman at the deli counter. To add insult to injury the group said the sandwiches were chewy. Live and learn, I won't be going back.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I went here to this market on Good Friday to pick up lunch for a small group in my office and it was very quiet. Approached the deli counter and began to read the sandwich board, the deli man seemed a bit rushed and pressed for my order, when I began to give him the corralating #'s for each of the 5 sandwiches he seemed quite overwhelmed and shouted "whoa whoa whoa". It wasn't busy and it wasn't a complicated order but he was a bit rude. I left with the disticnct feeling I had annoyed the gentleman at the deli counter. To add insult to injury the group said the sandwiches were chewy. Live and learn, I won't be going back.

.

As a food professional, I can appreciate the variety of items one can find in one place. For any food emergency, Amish Market is there for you. If there is anything missing, it is the informative newsletter that connects people to their place of shopping.

2
★★★★★

As a food professional, I can appreciate the variety of items one can find in one place. For any food emergency, Amish Market is there for you. If there is anything missing, it is the informative newsletter that connects people to their place of shopping.

.

I am done with Amish market. I live around the corner and I have gone often.

No more. Almost every time I've been there, something has gone wrong. They forget to put something in my bag. The milk is bad. I order coffee and get hot chocolate. The girls in the check out stand are more interested in talking to each other than ringing you up, and will turn their backs and ignore you until it's convenient for them to do their job.

The prices on all their food, standard or gourmet, are simply ridiculous and about 20% more than you would pay at other gourmet markets for the same or better quality. Do not waste your time and money here.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I am done with Amish market. I live around the corner and I have gone often.

No more. Almost every time I've been there, something has gone wrong. They forget to put something in my bag. The milk is bad. I order coffee and get hot chocolate. The girls in the check out stand are more interested in talking to each other than ringing you up, and will turn their backs and ignore you until it's convenient for them to do their job.

The prices on all their food, standard or gourmet, are simply ridiculous and about 20% more than you would pay at other gourmet markets for the same or better quality. Do not waste your time and money here.

Pros: decent salad bar

Cons: horrible service, low quality food

.

Great selection, blah, blah blah.. I live around the corner, so I shop there all the time and I have never gotten out of there without them overcharging me. NEVER. Keep track of the prices and WATCH THE REGISTER. Intentional or not, it ruins what should be a great market.

1
★★☆☆☆

Great selection, blah, blah blah.. I live around the corner, so I shop there all the time and I have never gotten out of there without them overcharging me. NEVER. Keep track of the prices and WATCH THE REGISTER. Intentional or not, it ruins what should be a great market.

.

best customer service, employees are so helpfull, beautiful design, all organic and natural products..
I love that place. You have to see that store..

2
★★★★★

best customer service, employees are so helpfull, beautiful design, all organic and natural products..
I love that place. You have to see that store..

.

Great self-serve "Soup Bar"... ladle up a mixture of 1/2 carrot ginger and 1/2 split pea... delicious!

2
★★★★☆

Great self-serve "Soup Bar"... ladle up a mixture of 1/2 carrot ginger and 1/2 split pea... delicious!

Pros: location, fresh and organic

Cons: no eat-in corner

Editorial from

Mini-chain of international gourmet marketplaces provides specialty products and ingredients, seafoods and meats, cheeses. Prepared foods, buffets, catering available.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Amish Market, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review