Dom Dicarlo's

★★★☆☆
  • 654 Logan St

    Noblesville, IN 46060

    Map & Directions
  • 317-776-6500

About Dom Dicarlo's

Food

Food
More choices in Noblesville:
Resultset_next

Michaelangelo's

550 Westfield Rd Noblesville, IN

Resultset_next

Cio's Pizza

3855 E 96th St Indianapolis, IN

2.7273 11
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Dom Dicarlo's was?
Write a Review
.

Oh my! Please be aware, that the Matteo that owns Dom Di Carlos pizza is not the same Matteo that owns Matteo's Restaurant!! If you have eaten at both you would certainly know the difference! The "man" that owns Dom Di Carlos is no where

3
★★★★★

Oh my! Please be aware, that the Matteo that owns Dom Di Carlos pizza is not the same Matteo that owns Matteo's Restaurant!! If you have eaten at both you would certainly know the difference! The "man" that owns Dom Di Carlos is no where

.

If there pizza wasnt so good, we wouldnt come back. we called in take out and the woman/girl or whoever she was,should not be dealing w/customers. we had to repeat the order several times. it was 1 pizza with 2 toppings on half of it. we asked the what the largest size was, turns out she didnt know. we go to pick it up, and ask for a takeout menu. She asks the guy cooking, he tells her to to look in back. lazy pretends to look. said they are changing the menu so they wont be any good in a week. Guy cooking said "News to me",plus clearly she acted put out by us asking for a takeout menu

1
★★★☆☆

If there pizza wasnt so good, we wouldnt come back. we called in take out and the woman/girl or whoever she was,should not be dealing w/customers. we had to repeat the order several times. it was 1 pizza with 2 toppings on half of it. we asked the what the largest size was, turns out she didnt know. we go to pick it up, and ask for a takeout menu. She asks the guy cooking, he tells her to to look in back. lazy pretends to look. said they are changing the menu so they wont be any good in a week. Guy cooking said "News to me",plus clearly she acted put out by us asking for a takeout menu

Pros: Great Pizza

Cons: rudness

.

There's nothing good about Dom Dicarlo's. My husband and I had never been there before and we ate there yesterday! What a dump! My husband's meatball sandwich was dry and on some garbagey bread, I had a salad (iceberg lettuce) and it was just nothing and the pizza was (at best) marginal. I'm shocked to learn that Matteo owns this place. Matteo's is a great restaurant and my husband and I love Emily and Matteo. I seriously DOUBT that he (Matteo) knows how this is being managed. The waitress was abrupt, bordering on rude. We will NEVER go back there! It was a waste of time and money... I didn't even want to give this restaurant one star!

0
★☆☆☆☆

There's nothing good about Dom Dicarlo's. My husband and I had never been there before and we ate there yesterday! What a dump! My husband's meatball sandwich was dry and on some garbagey bread, I had a salad (iceberg lettuce) and it was just nothing and the pizza was (at best) marginal. I'm shocked to learn that Matteo owns this place. Matteo's is a great restaurant and my husband and I love Emily and Matteo. I seriously DOUBT that he (Matteo) knows how this is being managed. The waitress was abrupt, bordering on rude. We will NEVER go back there! It was a waste of time and money... I didn't even want to give this restaurant one star!

Pros: None

Cons: Food & Service

.

We had the worst restaurant experience in Noblesville today at lunch. Don??t visit Dom DiCarlos. I will give you the time line of events:

11:15 We got lucky and had 29 minutes on the parking meter ?? added 25 cents and joked we won??t need 1 hours to eat lunch ?? Oh how I ate those words.

11:25 Decided to get Boli??s ($7) ??Make your own way? so the menu says. I chose a simple tomato, mozzarella, basil, and pepperoni. My lunch date picked a Hawaiian. The internet say to cost is 6.95. We soon learned the menu and or internet price is just a guideline. The owner charges what he wants. ($10.99). We also ordered Bread Knots. How can you go wrong with bread, olive oil, garlic and parmesan? Well at Dom Dicarlos they got it wrong. The bread was undercooked and swimming in oil and cheese. We got our own self serve drinks and sat down. Several other people began arriving. Were served pizza. One couple ordered and then left. Don??t worry an elderly couple came in a few minutes later and were presented with the pizza the young couple had ordered. When the bread arrived we had to ask the waitress for plates ?? she gave us a ??pissed off? eye roll and got us plates. At the same time we asked for another cup of ice tea since one was dirty (we had not noticed when we filled them). She returned with water ?? oh well ?? all the research shows we should drink more water.

12:15 still no food. When I approached the counter ?? the owner/cook yelled at me they would be up soon ?? the ??Boli??s take longer than the pizza?. We waited.

12:30 Food is unceremoniously dropped on the table and the waitress says I will be right back with your sauce. I didn??t order any sauce but figures it was part of the Boli. The sauce was a large bowl of spaghetti sauce that had a funny taste to it so I just ate the Boli without the sauce.

12:45 We ask for the bill. Boli??s 10.99 each, Drinks 1.95 each (remember one was water), Breadknots 4.00 and get this 1.75 for the spaghetti sauce = $31.63. They finally agreed to honor the coupon we had brought in for buy one entre get one free. They would not take off the 1.75 for the unordered food. Final Bill $22.14 I have no idea how they figured this out. We paid and we left.
Save yourself the aggravation and don??t go to the website where Dom talks about ??everyone is treated like family? A hugely dysfunctional family!

1
★☆☆☆☆

We had the worst restaurant experience in Noblesville today at lunch. Don??t visit Dom DiCarlos. I will give you the time line of events:

11:15 We got lucky and had 29 minutes on the parking meter ?? added 25 cents and joked we won??t need 1 hours to eat lunch ?? Oh how I ate those words.

11:25 Decided to get Boli??s ($7) ??Make your own way? so the menu says. I chose a simple tomato, mozzarella, basil, and pepperoni. My lunch date picked a Hawaiian. The internet say to cost is 6.95. We soon learned the menu and or internet price is just a guideline. The owner charges what he wants. ($10.99). We also ordered Bread Knots. How can you go wrong with bread, olive oil, garlic and parmesan? Well at Dom Dicarlos they got it wrong. The bread was undercooked and swimming in oil and cheese. We got our own self serve drinks and sat down. Several other people began arriving. Were served pizza. One couple ordered and then left. Don??t worry an elderly couple came in a few minutes later and were presented with the pizza the young couple had ordered. When the bread arrived we had to ask the waitress for plates ?? she gave us a ??pissed off? eye roll and got us plates. At the same time we asked for another cup of ice tea since one was dirty (we had not noticed when we filled them). She returned with water ?? oh well ?? all the research shows we should drink more water.

12:15 still no food. When I approached the counter ?? the owner/cook yelled at me they would be up soon ?? the ??Boli??s take longer than the pizza?. We waited.

12:30 Food is unceremoniously dropped on the table and the waitress says I will be right back with your sauce. I didn??t order any sauce but figures it was part of the Boli. The sauce was a large bowl of spaghetti sauce that had a funny taste to it so I just ate the Boli without the sauce.

12:45 We ask for the bill. Boli??s 10.99 each, Drinks 1.95 each (remember one was water), Breadknots 4.00 and get this 1.75 for the spaghetti sauce = $31.63. They finally agreed to honor the coupon we had brought in for buy one entre get one free. They would not take off the 1.75 for the unordered food. Final Bill $22.14 I have no idea how they figured this out. We paid and we left.
Save yourself the aggravation and don??t go to the website where Dom talks about ??everyone is treated like family? A hugely dysfunctional family!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I absolutely do not recommend Dom Dicarlos. They are rude, have no customer service ethics, and cheat the customer of their money whenever they can. If you do decide to eat there, please make sure you ask for an itemized receipt, showing what you are charged for, because we have been overcharged the past 3 times we have gone there. They have no idea what they are doing, Big Dom treats his workers like dirt, and the atmosphere is not a good one. I will never return. Period.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I absolutely do not recommend Dom Dicarlos. They are rude, have no customer service ethics, and cheat the customer of their money whenever they can. If you do decide to eat there, please make sure you ask for an itemized receipt, showing what you are charged for, because we have been overcharged the past 3 times we have gone there. They have no idea what they are doing, Big Dom treats his workers like dirt, and the atmosphere is not a good one. I will never return. Period.

Cons: Very rude, overcharge, no customer service

.

Dom's used to be a wonderful place to eat, but for some reason the owner, Matteo, has decided that the customer is never right and that they are never wrong. After two mixed up orders, being accused of ordering the incorrect items, being yelled at, and then having to make a return trip in order to get the correct food, I will most likely think twice before revisiting this eating establishement in the future. I guess the owner thinks that rudeness is the way to win customers and lousy food is the way to keep an establishement going in the midst of these economic times. When is an Italian beef sandwich not an Italian beef sandwich? When you order it from Dom diCarlo's.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Dom's used to be a wonderful place to eat, but for some reason the owner, Matteo, has decided that the customer is never right and that they are never wrong. After two mixed up orders, being accused of ordering the incorrect items, being yelled at, and then having to make a return trip in order to get the correct food, I will most likely think twice before revisiting this eating establishement in the future. I guess the owner thinks that rudeness is the way to win customers and lousy food is the way to keep an establishement going in the midst of these economic times. When is an Italian beef sandwich not an Italian beef sandwich? When you order it from Dom diCarlo's.

Cons: Rude owner, inefficient staff

.

I used to be a big fan of Dom DiCarlo's. The Chicago style pizza and Italian beef sandwiches were great and hard to find in this area. However, even the food will never get me to step into that place again. Last week, I phoned in a carry out order an hour in advance. Two simple items, a sandwich and a kid's pizza, and plenty of notice. When I arrived, I noticed right away that the pizza was huge and obviously not a childrens size. Rather than work with me on this, I got rudely told that I ORDERED wrong and basically to take it or leave it. Because my child was waiting in the car, I took it and paid extra for a pizza I did not order. When I got home, I was upset to find that my sandwich was wrong too!! When I called back and requested the correct sandwich, I was again told it was my fault because I'd ordered wrong. Seriously?? Matteo got on the phone and was so rude, yelling at me and not letting me get a word in edgewise to the point that I finally got frustrated and gave up. What ever happened to the customer is always right? What happened to customer service? Not only did they NOT offer to make the correct items for me, they made us pay for the wrong food and offered NO apology. I have never experienced such poor customer service not only from the staff, but from the owner as well. What a disappointment! I guess the staff is just following in the leaders poor example, but Dom DiCarlos has lost a customer for life!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I used to be a big fan of Dom DiCarlo's. The Chicago style pizza and Italian beef sandwiches were great and hard to find in this area. However, even the food will never get me to step into that place again. Last week, I phoned in a carry out order an hour in advance. Two simple items, a sandwich and a kid's pizza, and plenty of notice. When I arrived, I noticed right away that the pizza was huge and obviously not a childrens size. Rather than work with me on this, I got rudely told that I ORDERED wrong and basically to take it or leave it. Because my child was waiting in the car, I took it and paid extra for a pizza I did not order. When I got home, I was upset to find that my sandwich was wrong too!! When I called back and requested the correct sandwich, I was again told it was my fault because I'd ordered wrong. Seriously?? Matteo got on the phone and was so rude, yelling at me and not letting me get a word in edgewise to the point that I finally got frustrated and gave up. What ever happened to the customer is always right? What happened to customer service? Not only did they NOT offer to make the correct items for me, they made us pay for the wrong food and offered NO apology. I have never experienced such poor customer service not only from the staff, but from the owner as well. What a disappointment! I guess the staff is just following in the leaders poor example, but Dom DiCarlos has lost a customer for life!

Cons: Poor Attitude, Rude, Poor Customer Service

.

I visit Dom DiCarlo's at least once a month. This will be with a delivery,too. Yes, things were a little 'touchy' for awhile. But much improvement is being seen. The pizza, salads, soups, desserts, are and have always been fresh and delicious. Service problems have shown problmes in the past, but this is where improvement is especially being seen.
My visit tonight was like it used to be. Still good pizza, and top notch service. Music beautfiul, atmosphere happy, and sincere.
Dom DiCarlo's is my favorite pizza, still!

2
★★★★★

I visit Dom DiCarlo's at least once a month. This will be with a delivery,too. Yes, things were a little 'touchy' for awhile. But much improvement is being seen. The pizza, salads, soups, desserts, are and have always been fresh and delicious. Service problems have shown problmes in the past, but this is where improvement is especially being seen.
My visit tonight was like it used to be. Still good pizza, and top notch service. Music beautfiul, atmosphere happy, and sincere.
Dom DiCarlo's is my favorite pizza, still!

Pros: Delicious food.Served Hot and fresh.

Cons: Problems being resolved.

.

The food is good but absolutely not worth the frustration. We phoned in a take out order and were told the order would be ready in 30 minutes. Upon arrival at the restaurant-30 minutes later- we were told to have a seat the order wasn't ready yet. After 25 minutes we approached the counter to ask why our order still wasn't ready. We were greeted with quite an attitude from the cashier and Matteo. We were not the only people in line this evening not happy about the service, but the staff does not care. Ten minutes later when our pizza was finally ready we were again greeted with an attitude. We decided to let them keep the pizza and proceeded on to another restaurant for our dinner. We have eaten at Dom Di Carlos on many occasions, and this situation has happened once before. We thought that maybe they had a bad night. But after this last experience we will not be returning.

0
★☆☆☆☆

The food is good but absolutely not worth the frustration. We phoned in a take out order and were told the order would be ready in 30 minutes. Upon arrival at the restaurant-30 minutes later- we were told to have a seat the order wasn't ready yet. After 25 minutes we approached the counter to ask why our order still wasn't ready. We were greeted with quite an attitude from the cashier and Matteo. We were not the only people in line this evening not happy about the service, but the staff does not care. Ten minutes later when our pizza was finally ready we were again greeted with an attitude. We decided to let them keep the pizza and proceeded on to another restaurant for our dinner. We have eaten at Dom Di Carlos on many occasions, and this situation has happened once before. We thought that maybe they had a bad night. But after this last experience we will not be returning.

Pros: Can't think of any

Cons: Horrible Customer service

.

This is my first time writing a review on a restaurant but I just had to write one on a fabulous restaurant my husband and I tried for the first time last Saturday night. He had read on Thanksgiving Day that Dom DiCarlos in Noblesville was declared the best pizza in Indy. Well, I had passed the restaurant several times when my brother lived in Noblesville but didn't ever stop by to sample their food. Mind you, we love going to Chicago to eat at Gino's East but when I went on Dom DiCarlo's website last week I told my husband that I think Gino's had met its match. Even the pictures and the descriptions of their food made me want to drive there immediately! Well, when we visited we ordered our drinks and then tried their house salad. It was wonderful. In the land of salad mixes (that are nasty with the slivered carrots!) Dom's salad was fresh and wonderfully made with diced tomatoes and great dressings. We ordered the Boss Pizza (meat lovers) Pizza Pie style and added mushrooms to it. My husband took one bite and said it was the best pizza he had ever eaten. We were in heaven. The garlic smells and the shiny crust and thick layer of meat was delicious. The owner (Dom himself) came over to our table and introduced himself and we really enjoyed talking with him. His wife was the one who served us (she was great!) and we had a good time. He even had one of his people bring out a bowl of his "red sauce" so we could dip our pizza in it. It was fabulous. Please visit this restaurant . . . you will NOT be disappointed. We plan on going back soon to try the calzones, lasagna and spaghetti as well. Come to Dom's and eat a slice or two or three (!!!) of heaven!!!

2
★★★★★

This is my first time writing a review on a restaurant but I just had to write one on a fabulous restaurant my husband and I tried for the first time last Saturday night. He had read on Thanksgiving Day that Dom DiCarlos in Noblesville was declared the best pizza in Indy. Well, I had passed the restaurant several times when my brother lived in Noblesville but didn't ever stop by to sample their food. Mind you, we love going to Chicago to eat at Gino's East but when I went on Dom DiCarlo's website last week I told my husband that I think Gino's had met its match. Even the pictures and the descriptions of their food made me want to drive there immediately! Well, when we visited we ordered our drinks and then tried their house salad. It was wonderful. In the land of salad mixes (that are nasty with the slivered carrots!) Dom's salad was fresh and wonderfully made with diced tomatoes and great dressings. We ordered the Boss Pizza (meat lovers) Pizza Pie style and added mushrooms to it. My husband took one bite and said it was the best pizza he had ever eaten. We were in heaven. The garlic smells and the shiny crust and thick layer of meat was delicious. The owner (Dom himself) came over to our table and introduced himself and we really enjoyed talking with him. His wife was the one who served us (she was great!) and we had a good time. He even had one of his people bring out a bowl of his "red sauce" so we could dip our pizza in it. It was fabulous. Please visit this restaurant . . . you will NOT be disappointed. We plan on going back soon to try the calzones, lasagna and spaghetti as well. Come to Dom's and eat a slice or two or three (!!!) of heaven!!!

Pros: service, food

Cons: none

.

Fresh, high quality ingredients.
Reasonable prices!
Great service!
The chef sat and talked with us like he was an old friend.
The atmosphere was inviting and relaxing.

2
★★★★★

Fresh, high quality ingredients.
Reasonable prices!
Great service!
The chef sat and talked with us like he was an old friend.
The atmosphere was inviting and relaxing.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Dom Dicarlo's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review