Sal's Pizza

★★★★★


Write a Review
43.298136 -87.988687
Map and Directions to Sal's Pizza

262-375-0011

W63 N635 Washington Ave

Cedarburg, WI

53012

Get Directions

About Sal's Pizza

4.6 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sal's Pizza was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 10 of 10.
.

I've been walking past this place for a year, and finally went in and bought a piece of pizza. It was fantastic. I was there 3 times in a week. However, the last time I went. I found that the plain cheese pizza went up in price and was the same as a piece with meat, or 2-3 toppings pizza. I know I paid $3/piece just a few days before that. So I was surprized and annoyed they raised their prices on the plain cheese pizza.

3
★★★☆☆

I've been walking past this place for a year, and finally went in and bought a piece of pizza. It was fantastic. I was there 3 times in a week. However, the last time I went. I found that the plain cheese pizza went up in price and was the same as a piece with meat, or 2-3 toppings pizza. I know I paid $3/piece just a few days before that. So I was surprized and annoyed they raised their prices on the plain cheese pizza.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Great pizza, VERY, VERY UNRELIABLE. I tried to call and order several times and nobody answered the phone, not even a machine. They are supposedly open everyday from 11am on.

4
★★★★☆

Great pizza, VERY, VERY UNRELIABLE. I tried to call and order several times and nobody answered the phone, not even a machine. They are supposedly open everyday from 11am on.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I'm from the east coast and New York style pizza is hard to find in Wisconsin. Sal's is the closest I have found - huge pie-shaped slices with yummy delicious cheese dripping with sauce and oil. You have to fold them in half to pick them up. It's a little pricey, but soooo worth it!

4
★★★★☆

I'm from the east coast and New York style pizza is hard to find in Wisconsin. Sal's is the closest I have found - huge pie-shaped slices with yummy delicious cheese dripping with sauce and oil. You have to fold them in half to pick them up. It's a little pricey, but soooo worth it!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Sal Pizza is the only pizza we will eat in Cedarburg it is the best in the area. The pizza sizes are so large you can never eat it all.The prices are fair and the service is great.

4
★★★★☆

Sal Pizza is the only pizza we will eat in Cedarburg it is the best in the area. The pizza sizes are so large you can never eat it all.The prices are fair and the service is great.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

nickthejew\r
\r
GREAT PIZZA, good service, new owner is a young guy, who really wants to make everyone happy...sandwiches and wings awesome too.\r
Real NYC style pizza!

3
★★★★★

nickthejew\r
\r
GREAT PIZZA, good service, new owner is a young guy, who really wants to make everyone happy...sandwiches and wings awesome too.\r
Real NYC style pizza!

.

stopped in to pick up a pie for the first time... and the last time. walked in and witnessed the owner berating an employee, to the point of tears, in front of the whole restaurant, and then proceed to argue with a customer. small towns

3
★★★★★

stopped in to pick up a pie for the first time... and the last time. walked in and witnessed the owner berating an employee, to the point of tears, in front of the whole restaurant, and then proceed to argue with a customer. small towns

.

hand down the best pizza!!! sometimes there is a wait but it is worth it, real deal NYC pies and the ORIGINAL owners are back and better then ever!

3
★★★★★

hand down the best pizza!!! sometimes there is a wait but it is worth it, real deal NYC pies and the ORIGINAL owners are back and better then ever!

.

bobby you left the night of a festival you knew it would be rediculus and you couldnt handle it you know none of that is true and i dont know why you would say any of that random unfactual bull

....you need to chill out it was a crazy time for the buisness and you knew that damn well it had nothing to with the owner ..name a buisness that didnt have a rough time that weekend... writeing some thing like this is rediculus and childish i hope to figure out a way to erase this before you look more stupid ...

2
★★★★★

bobby you left the night of a festival you knew it would be rediculus and you couldnt handle it you know none of that is true and i dont know why you would say any of that random unfactual bull

....you need to chill out it was a crazy time for the buisness and you knew that damn well it had nothing to with the owner ..name a buisness that didnt have a rough time that weekend... writeing some thing like this is rediculus and childish i hope to figure out a way to erase this before you look more stupid ...

.

Sal's does a great job on the pizza...when they get it right for delivery. The people who take the orders are never the same, and they often have NO clue what's on the menu, or what's available. Garlic bread has never been the same twice...sometimes great, other times not so much. Pizza is consistently good -- when they get it straight the first time.

1
★★★☆☆

Sal's does a great job on the pizza...when they get it right for delivery. The people who take the orders are never the same, and they often have NO clue what's on the menu, or what's available. Garlic bread has never been the same twice...sometimes great, other times not so much. Pizza is consistently good -- when they get it straight the first time.

Pros: home delivery in Cedarburg area, reasonable prices

Cons: inconsistent people taking orders

.

This is my family's very favorite pizza place. When ever we are in the area, we always make a trip here. The pizza is served by the piece or whole. Which is great, we like to try a variety. Always fresh and hot, and very reasonably priced. Extremely customer friendly. When my family comes in from Arizona they beg for Sal's. Worth my 30 min. drive.

2
★★★★★

This is my family's very favorite pizza place. When ever we are in the area, we always make a trip here. The pizza is served by the piece or whole. Which is great, we like to try a variety. Always fresh and hot, and very reasonably priced. Extremely customer friendly. When my family comes in from Arizona they beg for Sal's. Worth my 30 min. drive.

Pros: everything

Cons: West Bend location not as good

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sal's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review