Sal's Pizza

★★★☆☆
  • 2040 W Wisconsin Ave

    Milwaukee, WI 53233

    Map & Directions
  • 414-344-9931

About Sal's Pizza

Details

Food

Food
More choices in Milwaukee:
Resultset_next

Pepi's Pizza

3929 S Howell Ave Milwaukee, WI

Resultset_next

Lisa's Pizzeria

2961 N Oakland Ave. Milwaukee, WI

3.3333 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sal's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Pizza is great...but my wife and two of her friends went to Sal's after the Robyn concert on Feb 12th and the guy making the pizzas flung pizza sauce on her and got it all over her jacket because he did not like the fact that her gay friend was dancing around the place having a good time. Great Pizza! Next time order up a side of homophobia and disorderly conduct.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Pizza is great...but my wife and two of her friends went to Sal's after the Robyn concert on Feb 12th and the guy making the pizzas flung pizza sauce on her and got it all over her jacket because he did not like the fact that her gay friend was dancing around the place having a good time. Great Pizza! Next time order up a side of homophobia and disorderly conduct.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The folks who own Sal's used to own Casa Bianca in Madison, which closed about a year ago. When we tracked them down in Milwaukee, they recognized me from all my visits in Madison! I complemented them and told them it's the best NY style pizza I've ever had, and the owner responded "I hope so - we're from Brooklyn!" So folks this is the real deal. Not just "NY style" but REAL New York Pizza.

We buy the 14 or 16" cheese pizza, plain - the best way to enjoy this fantastic NY pizza. It's thin crust with chewy edges (unlike the cracker-style thin crust prevalent up here), with a flavorful, herb-filled sauce, and just a thin layer of cheese with a splash of olive oil. The 16" is huge and every pizza comes with some unbelievably good garlic knots, so there's plenty to feed a group or party. The pizza is also inexpensive - only about $12 for a large - which is a great deal for such a good pie.

We've done both carry-out and eat in and had great experiences with both. They also sell by the slice and have an awesome deal of a soda, slice, and garlic knot for under $3. When we carry out, they've always had the pizza ready exactly on time. When we've eaten in, they've given us extra garlic knots and free soda refills. There's not many tables so if you go when they're busy you may have trouble finding a seat, but just get it for carry-out instead - the pizza is well worth it. I'd recommend Sal's over any other pizza place in Wisconsin!

5
★★★★★

The folks who own Sal's used to own Casa Bianca in Madison, which closed about a year ago. When we tracked them down in Milwaukee, they recognized me from all my visits in Madison! I complemented them and told them it's the best NY style pizza I've ever had, and the owner responded "I hope so - we're from Brooklyn!" So folks this is the real deal. Not just "NY style" but REAL New York Pizza.

We buy the 14 or 16" cheese pizza, plain - the best way to enjoy this fantastic NY pizza. It's thin crust with chewy edges (unlike the cracker-style thin crust prevalent up here), with a flavorful, herb-filled sauce, and just a thin layer of cheese with a splash of olive oil. The 16" is huge and every pizza comes with some unbelievably good garlic knots, so there's plenty to feed a group or party. The pizza is also inexpensive - only about $12 for a large - which is a great deal for such a good pie.

We've done both carry-out and eat in and had great experiences with both. They also sell by the slice and have an awesome deal of a soda, slice, and garlic knot for under $3. When we carry out, they've always had the pizza ready exactly on time. When we've eaten in, they've given us extra garlic knots and free soda refills. There's not many tables so if you go when they're busy you may have trouble finding a seat, but just get it for carry-out instead - the pizza is well worth it. I'd recommend Sal's over any other pizza place in Wisconsin!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

While at WISN, they would often order here for our parties. The pizza was so delicious and the prices are okay. I would recommend to try. Staff are nice and patience.

4
★★★★☆

While at WISN, they would often order here for our parties. The pizza was so delicious and the prices are okay. I would recommend to try. Staff are nice and patience.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sal's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review