Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway

★★★★★
Rated One Of America's Best Pizza Places By Bon Appetite Magazine
47.6223 -122.321
Map and Directions to Pagliacci Pizza

206-726-1717

426 Broadway Ave. E.

Seattle, WA

98102

Get Directions Photos

Food

Food
More choices in Seattle:
Resultset_next

Mamma Melina Ristorante

4759 Roosevelt Way NE Seattle, WA

Resultset_next

Perche No Pasta & Vino

1319 N 49th St Seattle, WA

5.5918 49
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 49 of 49.
.

The only reason I continue to order from Pagliacci is that I am occasionally rewarded with a free pizza upon delivery. The pizza has been living on it's reputation for far too long, and many other pizza places have surpassed it in quality.

3
★★★☆☆

The only reason I continue to order from Pagliacci is that I am occasionally rewarded with a free pizza upon delivery. The pizza has been living on it's reputation for far too long, and many other pizza places have surpassed it in quality.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Pagliacci's Pizza is a favorite of Seattle-ites. Thin crust, fresh veggies and not too much cheese. The salads are wonderful too.
The Broadway location is a people-watcher's dream.

4
★★★★☆

Pagliacci's Pizza is a favorite of Seattle-ites. Thin crust, fresh veggies and not too much cheese. The salads are wonderful too.
The Broadway location is a people-watcher's dream.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I was visiting from California and I fell in love with this pizza shop. It was so good and the prices were great. I wish there was one by me! So I would highly recommend it.

5
★★★★★

I was visiting from California and I fell in love with this pizza shop. It was so good and the prices were great. I wish there was one by me! So I would highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Pagliacci is just your average pizza parlor, they serve all the regular types of pizza as well as salads, pasta, and some specialty pizzas. Their service is fast only because the pizza, salad, and pasta is all pre-made, but it still tastes good.

3
★★★☆☆

Pagliacci is just your average pizza parlor, they serve all the regular types of pizza as well as salads, pasta, and some specialty pizzas. Their service is fast only because the pizza, salad, and pasta is all pre-made, but it still tastes good.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We all know that Pagliacci is a staple for Seattle residents, but if you are to pick a location...it has to be the Broadway pizzeria. Great location in the heart of Capitol Hill, with a window wall that opens toward the sidewalk making it a great summertime hangout. We take all of our out of town guest here after a night out and they are never disappointed.

5
★★★★★

We all know that Pagliacci is a staple for Seattle residents, but if you are to pick a location...it has to be the Broadway pizzeria. Great location in the heart of Capitol Hill, with a window wall that opens toward the sidewalk making it a great summertime hangout. We take all of our out of town guest here after a night out and they are never disappointed.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Pagliacci Pizza is unparalled. Their service is impeccable. They greet you quickly and have all your information within seconds. They offer great specials but we have our tried and trues that we order every time. The pizza is always hot and fresh and they have fun facts on their pizza boxes!

5
★★★★★

Pagliacci Pizza is unparalled. Their service is impeccable. They greet you quickly and have all your information within seconds. They offer great specials but we have our tried and trues that we order every time. The pizza is always hot and fresh and they have fun facts on their pizza boxes!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Can't go wrong with Pagliacci Delivery! Wonderful pizza, priced right (about $15 for a good pie) and convenient. They have friendly staff. Definitely worth the price - especially if you are a pizza fan!

4
★★★★☆

Can't go wrong with Pagliacci Delivery! Wonderful pizza, priced right (about $15 for a good pie) and convenient. They have friendly staff. Definitely worth the price - especially if you are a pizza fan!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The Pagliacci pizzas and the different combinations available are great! This is not just another cardboard box pizza. They deliver later at night than most others, and the food and service makes up for it being a little pricier than the other guys.

4
★★★★☆

The Pagliacci pizzas and the different combinations available are great! This is not just another cardboard box pizza. They deliver later at night than most others, and the food and service makes up for it being a little pricier than the other guys.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I use to have a business in West Seattle and we would order pizza from here frequently as it was often hard to leave and pick something up. They have great, unique pizza that is always hot and delivered on time.

4
★★★★☆

I use to have a business in West Seattle and we would order pizza from here frequently as it was often hard to leave and pick something up. They have great, unique pizza that is always hot and delivered on time.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Pagliacci is definitely the best delivery pizza around here. The pizza is good, the delivery service is consistent, and the staff are mostly helpful. The best part is, they will deliver wherever you are! Even if it's in the local Starbucks!

4
★★★★☆

Pagliacci is definitely the best delivery pizza around here. The pizza is good, the delivery service is consistent, and the staff are mostly helpful. The best part is, they will deliver wherever you are! Even if it's in the local Starbucks!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

they have the very best Pizza and especially wonderful salads. I really love pizza crust that is very thin and theirs is. The wait is short and service friendly .

5
★★★★★

they have the very best Pizza and especially wonderful salads. I really love pizza crust that is very thin and theirs is. The wait is short and service friendly .

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

Not a lot to say.. i just love this place

6
★★★★★

Not a lot to say.. i just love this place

.

I was walking to my bus stop yesterday afternoon after work, I was tired and it was rainy ( so UNLIKE seattle I know) but I decided to stop and get a pizza to take home to the family, but when I went in I noticed that they sold pizza by

6
★★★★★

I was walking to my bus stop yesterday afternoon after work, I was tired and it was rainy ( so UNLIKE seattle I know) but I decided to stop and get a pizza to take home to the family, but when I went in I noticed that they sold pizza by

.

Well, it is a pizza joint and so I expected decent pizza. The food was bad to say the least. The service is painfully slow and the quality of the food is tooo mediocre for the time they take to make it. We went here for lunch and were very

6
★★★★★

Well, it is a pizza joint and so I expected decent pizza. The food was bad to say the least. The service is painfully slow and the quality of the food is tooo mediocre for the time they take to make it. We went here for lunch and were very

Cons: Food, Parking, Service

.

This is by far the best pizza I have ever had, in Seattle or elsewhere. I suppose if you order frequently it is kind of expensive, but their customer service is awesome...you call a call center and they place their order for you. They can

6
★★★★★

This is by far the best pizza I have ever had, in Seattle or elsewhere. I suppose if you order frequently it is kind of expensive, but their customer service is awesome...you call a call center and they place their order for you. They can

Pros: Best PIzza in Seattle!

Cons: A tad on the pricey side

.

Found this place by asking a few locals and glad that I did.\r
Pizza was very good and cooked to order as I like it well done, most places will just stop cooking it as they see fit.\r
But the folks here had me look at it before boxing it

6
★★★★★

Found this place by asking a few locals and glad that I did.\r
Pizza was very good and cooked to order as I like it well done, most places will just stop cooking it as they see fit.\r
But the folks here had me look at it before boxing it

.

I couldn't imagine ordering from anywhere else. I recently left town to go to vegas and I couldn't find anything that compared.(even at the expensive strip spots)

6
★★★★★

I couldn't imagine ordering from anywhere else. I recently left town to go to vegas and I couldn't find anything that compared.(even at the expensive strip spots)

.

Whether I order for delivery or visit one of the Pizzeria's I always receive the same great customer service! Which I always weigh so much of my reviews based on the service. So yeah the service is great but the pizza is even better! The

6
★★★★★

Whether I order for delivery or visit one of the Pizzeria's I always receive the same great customer service! Which I always weigh so much of my reviews based on the service. So yeah the service is great but the pizza is even better! The

Pros: Quality, Service,

Cons: None Go to Papa Johns for this one

.

It seems to obvious to call Pags the best pizza in Seattle, but it could be true. They certainly have the best crust. There is also a great selection of toppings. There is also a nice atmospere and it's clean.\r
\r

6
★★★★★

It seems to obvious to call Pags the best pizza in Seattle, but it could be true. They certainly have the best crust. There is also a great selection of toppings. There is also a nice atmospere and it's clean.\r
\r

.

2 slices of Pepperoni pizza at Pagliacci Pizza is $5.40 some odd sense, and that includes tax. One slice at Pagliacci Pizza costs...less than $2 1/2 bucks. Great deal. I love Pagliacci's crust. Always a great choice. Pagliacci Pizza

6
★★★★★

2 slices of Pepperoni pizza at Pagliacci Pizza is $5.40 some odd sense, and that includes tax. One slice at Pagliacci Pizza costs...less than $2 1/2 bucks. Great deal. I love Pagliacci's crust. Always a great choice. Pagliacci Pizza

Pros: pizza, salads, slices, whole pies, delivery

Cons: we need a location in Leschi or Madison Park

.

"Gourmet" pizza can be fantastic: exotic ingredients layered in inspired combinations, just the right olive oil, a nice biting marinara or bolognese sauce (or a garlic cream sauce with clams), etc. Unfortunately, for all its lauds as a

6
★★★★★

"Gourmet" pizza can be fantastic: exotic ingredients layered in inspired combinations, just the right olive oil, a nice biting marinara or bolognese sauce (or a garlic cream sauce with clams), etc. Unfortunately, for all its lauds as a

Pros: they're everywhere

Cons: a regret in every bite

.

I would highly recommend this company. I order delivery regularly and they are always on time. I have never had to wait more than 45 minutes. The pizza tastes fabulous, and it's always consistent in taste and quality. Customer service on

6
★★★★★

I would highly recommend this company. I order delivery regularly and they are always on time. I have never had to wait more than 45 minutes. The pizza tastes fabulous, and it's always consistent in taste and quality. Customer service on

Pros: Speedy delivery. Great Customer Service. Timely. Great Quality.

Cons: Pricy.

.

Excellent. Among the very best pizza I've had anywhere. The restaurant could be a little cleaner.

6
★★★★★

Excellent. Among the very best pizza I've had anywhere. The restaurant could be a little cleaner.

.

It is an added bonus that when I call for delivery, they have my favorites on file. Always good service.

6
★★★★★

It is an added bonus that when I call for delivery, they have my favorites on file. Always good service.

Pros: Good Delivery, Good Restaruants

.

Pags has a bad rap and I have never been able to figure out why--for classic NY-style pizza, I think it might be the best in town. The seasonal primo pizzas, like one right now covered in mushrooms or one with figs and proscuitto, are

6
★★★★★

Pags has a bad rap and I have never been able to figure out why--for classic NY-style pizza, I think it might be the best in town. The seasonal primo pizzas, like one right now covered in mushrooms or one with figs and proscuitto, are

.

I just called Pagliacci on Broadway for a pizza, and I liked the sound of their seasonal special, but then I kind of balked at the price over the phone and decided to get something cheaper. The phone clerk was really sweet and patient

6
★★★★★

I just called Pagliacci on Broadway for a pizza, and I liked the sound of their seasonal special, but then I kind of balked at the price over the phone and decided to get something cheaper. The phone clerk was really sweet and patient

Pros: Incredibly sweet, generous, helpful staff

Cons: Can be a bit pricy for deluxe combinations

.

Here's the situation with Pagliacci: Overrated in taste, but highly consistant. Lets face it people, this pizza is good, but not "wow!, I need to call my friends!" It is number one for knowing what your gonna get, before you get it.

6
★★★★★

Here's the situation with Pagliacci: Overrated in taste, but highly consistant. Lets face it people, this pizza is good, but not "wow!, I need to call my friends!" It is number one for knowing what your gonna get, before you get it.

Pros: Reliable

Cons: Expensive

.

I love Pagliacci Pizzas! I personally love thin crust pizzas, and I think they have one of the best thin crusts. I love their AGOG Primo Pizza. The roasted garlic is o delicious on the AGOG! They also have an excellent Paglliaccio salad. I

6
★★★★★

I love Pagliacci Pizzas! I personally love thin crust pizzas, and I think they have one of the best thin crusts. I love their AGOG Primo Pizza. The roasted garlic is o delicious on the AGOG! They also have an excellent Paglliaccio salad. I

Pros: Pizza, salad

Cons: service

.

Their pizza is totally a kind of their own. Not like the average pizza hut or dominoes, this pizza is jam packed with flavor and ingredients. But crust lovers beware, this pizza is thin crust any which way you order it. I advise anyone to

6
★★★★★

Their pizza is totally a kind of their own. Not like the average pizza hut or dominoes, this pizza is jam packed with flavor and ingredients. But crust lovers beware, this pizza is thin crust any which way you order it. I advise anyone to

Pros: Pesto salad, ingredients on pizza

Cons: Thin crust

.

I have loved Pagliacci since I first found my way out of the suburbs to experience the real Seattle. My favorite used to be the Pesto Primo... but then they made some chicken thing when the Seahawks were in the playoffs this year,

6
★★★★★

I have loved Pagliacci since I first found my way out of the suburbs to experience the real Seattle. My favorite used to be the Pesto Primo... but then they made some chicken thing when the Seahawks were in the playoffs this year,

Pros: the PIZZA!

Cons: nasty bathroom keys?

.

I fell in love with Pagliacci's upon moving to Seattle for school. Their pizza is great!! Very fun staff as well. By the slice or whole, everything is great. The addition of gelatto was wonderful. I go back whenever I can when I am up

6
★★★★★

I fell in love with Pagliacci's upon moving to Seattle for school. Their pizza is great!! Very fun staff as well. By the slice or whole, everything is great. The addition of gelatto was wonderful. I go back whenever I can when I am up

Pros: Best pizza

Cons: Crowds at times

.

Love it! Grab a slice and a coke and you'll think your back home in Brooklyn. The price is right and the atmosphere is casual and fun. The cheese pizza is so good it's a must for first timers.\r
A great place to grab a quick lunch or a

6
★★★★★

Love it! Grab a slice and a coke and you'll think your back home in Brooklyn. The price is right and the atmosphere is casual and fun. The cheese pizza is so good it's a must for first timers.\r
A great place to grab a quick lunch or a

.

Some of the best pizza west of the Mississippi. Thin crusts and lots of cheese are authentic while the vibe is casual without the grease.

6
★★★★★

Some of the best pizza west of the Mississippi. Thin crusts and lots of cheese are authentic while the vibe is casual without the grease.

.

Its really good pizza but you will get better at most small Itallian resturants,and for the money you might as well go to one to get a pizza.Pagliacci is pretty good but for the money id rather go to a small Itallian place where I can

6
★★★★★

Its really good pizza but you will get better at most small Itallian resturants,and for the money you might as well go to one to get a pizza.Pagliacci is pretty good but for the money id rather go to a small Itallian place where I can

Pros: Good pizza

Cons: Expensive

.

Ohhhhhhhhhhh, yeah! I remember when Pagliacci first opened on Broadway, offering pizza by the slice. What a concept! Great pizza, fresh ingredients, and a great East Coast style thin crust. Who could ask for more?

6
★★★★★

Ohhhhhhhhhhh, yeah! I remember when Pagliacci first opened on Broadway, offering pizza by the slice. What a concept! Great pizza, fresh ingredients, and a great East Coast style thin crust. Who could ask for more?

Pros: good variety of offerings but I always stuck to the pizza

Cons: a whole pizza is a bit expensive

.

yum! this pizza is very good and definatley worth your bucks. the service is quick and friendly, and you can watch the chef make YOUR pizza! so cool! yum!

6
★★★★★

yum! this pizza is very good and definatley worth your bucks. the service is quick and friendly, and you can watch the chef make YOUR pizza! so cool! yum!

Pros: yum! great service fun for everyone!

Cons: thin crust, but still good!

.

The tortilla soup is wonderful, definetly recomend. Pizza was also good, though it is reheated, not fresh.

6
★★★★★

The tortilla soup is wonderful, definetly recomend. Pizza was also good, though it is reheated, not fresh.

Pros: inexpensive, tortilla soup, pizza

Cons: parking

.

A great place to grab a couple slices and read the paper!

6
★★★★★

A great place to grab a couple slices and read the paper!

.

If you enjoy cardboard-like crusts for your pizza, this is your place! We used to like their pizza's, but the past couple of pies have left us wondering "what's changed?" We won't be back.

6
★★★★★

If you enjoy cardboard-like crusts for your pizza, this is your place! We used to like their pizza's, but the past couple of pies have left us wondering "what's changed?" We won't be back.

Cons: bad pizza

.

greasy sick pizza might as well get frozen pizza this place is for suckers

6
★★★★★

greasy sick pizza might as well get frozen pizza this place is for suckers

.

I love the variety of the menu and the taste of everything on it from our favorite pizza joint/delivery - Pagliacci! Whenver we have family in from the eastcoast or Chicago we only feel confident about the consistent taste and quality of

6
★★★★★

I love the variety of the menu and the taste of everything on it from our favorite pizza joint/delivery - Pagliacci! Whenver we have family in from the eastcoast or Chicago we only feel confident about the consistent taste and quality of

.

If you like cardboard you will like Pagliacci. As a long time Seattleite, I have never figured out why this place gets such good ratings. I will admit, their Pagliacci salad is good, but I wish the pizza was better.

6
★★★★★

If you like cardboard you will like Pagliacci. As a long time Seattleite, I have never figured out why this place gets such good ratings. I will admit, their Pagliacci salad is good, but I wish the pizza was better.

.

I love their pizza, it's a little pricey but it's huge with fresh toppings and they deliver to where ever I tend to be rather quickly. The toppings are fresh. Sometimes I wish it had a little more sauce though. It doesn't have a greasy

6
★★★★★

I love their pizza, it's a little pricey but it's huge with fresh toppings and they deliver to where ever I tend to be rather quickly. The toppings are fresh. Sometimes I wish it had a little more sauce though. It doesn't have a greasy

.

How can this be the best pizza in Seattle? The pizza is definitely subpar - it doesn't compare to even the average places in any large metropolitan area (NY, Chicago, DC, SF, etc.). The crust was undercooked, there was too much cheese and

6
★★★★★

How can this be the best pizza in Seattle? The pizza is definitely subpar - it doesn't compare to even the average places in any large metropolitan area (NY, Chicago, DC, SF, etc.). The crust was undercooked, there was too much cheese and

Pros: Delivery

Cons: , Bad Crust

.

Anyone who hasnt ventured to the eastern seaboard hasnt really tasted quality pizza. Average pies from national chains like Dominoes here out west doesnt the mustard. However Pagliaccis comes the closest. Tasty crust, the pizza sauce has

6
★★★★★

Anyone who hasnt ventured to the eastern seaboard hasnt really tasted quality pizza. Average pies from national chains like Dominoes here out west doesnt the mustard. However Pagliaccis comes the closest. Tasty crust, the pizza sauce has

Pros: Good pizza

.

Great pizza. Exotic selections available. Value priced. I would recommend shopping and a slice of pizza and the crushed ice is great in coke.

6
★★★★★

Great pizza. Exotic selections available. Value priced. I would recommend shopping and a slice of pizza and the crushed ice is great in coke.

Pros: pizza, selection, fast

.

Pagliacci's is completely overrated!! What's all the hype about......someone please fill me in because I am not tasting it!! When it comes down to it pizza is pizza, tasty suace and good dough and it becomes hard to screw up! Pagliacci

6
★★★★★

Pagliacci's is completely overrated!! What's all the hype about......someone please fill me in because I am not tasting it!! When it comes down to it pizza is pizza, tasty suace and good dough and it becomes hard to screw up! Pagliacci

.

I'm not sure what it is that everyone likes about this place. I've tried it 4 times now from two locations and they were identical. the pizza crust is thin and flimsy, and twice it was under cooked. the toppings are run of the mill and the

6
★★★★★

I'm not sure what it is that everyone likes about this place. I've tried it 4 times now from two locations and they were identical. the pizza crust is thin and flimsy, and twice it was under cooked. the toppings are run of the mill and the

Cons: , poor quality, long delivery time

.

My girlfriend and I went to the Pagliacci's on Broadway and were left unimpressed. After seeing all the awards they won we expected alot more. Instead what we got wasn't special. It was good, but just better than average. We both think

6
★★★★★

My girlfriend and I went to the Pagliacci's on Broadway and were left unimpressed. After seeing all the awards they won we expected alot more. Instead what we got wasn't special. It was good, but just better than average. We both think

Pros: $ reasonable, good portions, fast service

Cons: taste overated, bad parking, nothing special

Message from Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Delivery, Pizza, Pizza Restaurant, Catering, Private Events, etc.



PEAR PRIMO

The Pear Primo is one of our most anticipated seasonal pies of the year. Pizza aficionados just canâ??t get enough of that combination of sweet Washington state pears and tangy gorgonzola. The flavors are further enhanced with walnuts, red onion, mushrooms, mozzarella and fontina cheese on olive oil. This rich pie will make your heart sing throughout the holiday season.



SPINACI PRIMO

This festive pizza will definitely put you in the holiday spirit. It starts with tomato-garlic sauce, red onion, mozzarella and a blanket of fresh spinach. It is finished with feta cheese and pomodoraccio tomatoes.



EGGNOG GELATO

Eggnog is a holiday tradition for many people. The rich, spicy beverage is now available as our latest seasonal gelato flavor.

More about Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway

Pizza, Pizza Delivery, pizza restaurant, catering, delivery

Editorial from

Classic and creative pies are offered at this local chain. Order a whole pie or single slice at the counter and seat yourself. Choose from toppings such as goat cheese with sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms and green peppers on an olive oil…

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Toscana Pizzeria
    5% ★★★★★ 52 reviews
    0.24 mi
  2. 2
    0.43 mi
  3. 3
    Hot Mama's Pizza
    4% ★★★★☆ 21 reviews
    0.49 mi
  4. 4
    Ristorante MacHiavelli
    4% ★★★★☆ 57 reviews
    0.63 mi
  5. 5
    Buca di Beppo
    6% ★★★★★ 17 reviews
    0.91 mi