Insider Pages Reviews for Ye Olde Mill St Pub

4 Stars: Ye Olde Mill St Pub is dependable good food (by Rich B.)

Rich B. — Mon, 07 Sep 2009 21:55:00 GMT

We go there a couple times a month to eat, it's always been very delicious and the atmosphere is nice as well. You can't beat their specials which include soup, salad, and your entree, and dessert.

They have a nice bar there, and it's one of the treats that we look forward to! We love Turkey Tuesday, and of course the Prime Rib meal.

2 Stars: Ye Olde Mill St Pub has lost its quality (by Linda C.)

Linda C. — Sun, 05 Jul 2009 16:28:00 GMT

Over the years I've been to Ye Olde Mill St. Pub countless times and was always fully satisfied with the food and service. But the owner died a while back and now it's run by family members that seem to want to do things more "on the cheap." Last time I was there was with my supper club about 3 months ago. While my dinner of shrimp scampi was ok, two of my group said that their prime rib was awful. Tasteless and tough. They won't go back again. Another good friend who has eaten there at least twice a month and orders the prime rib when it's the special of the night said that hers was terrible the last 2 times she went as well. This is too often to be coincidence. I really can't recommend it anymore. I'll still go for a lunch salad occasionally - but not for that special night out.

4 Stars: Local Pub (by Deborah P.)

Deborah P. — Tue, 02 Dec 2008 07:52:00 GMT

The Mill Street Pub has been a landmark restaurant in Mays Landing for a long time. Food is affordable and delicious. The wait staff is friendly, too! Nice bar to gather around to for lunch or late night snack!