Mike's Seafood

★★★★☆
  • 4222 Park Rd

    Sea Isle City, NJ 08243

    Map & Directions
  • 609-263-1136

About Mike's Seafood

Food

Food
More choices in Sea Isle City:
Resultset_next

Marie's Seafood Take Out

4304 Park Rd Sea Isle City, NJ

Resultset_next

Captain Tate's Sea Food

980 State Highway 47 Dennisville, NJ

3.5455 11
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Mike's Seafood was?
Write a Review
.

great place we go there all of the time! i really reccomend mike's because of the atmosphere, quality service, and GREAT food.

5
★★★★★

great place we go there all of the time! i really reccomend mike's because of the atmosphere, quality service, and GREAT food.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

A treat for the family. We take out shrimp and scallop and have a feast at home. Great fresh seafood, good selection of fish and with kids menu too. They have a reasturant menu and I really liked the spiced fries.

4
★★★★☆

A treat for the family. We take out shrimp and scallop and have a feast at home. Great fresh seafood, good selection of fish and with kids menu too. They have a reasturant menu and I really liked the spiced fries.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My favorite restaurant ever! I LOVE the atmosphere! You can eat outside on the deck overlooking the water! You order the food yourself at the counter and enjoy! My kids like it too, being that it is so different from the other tradional places. A definite place to go for a fun night out!

5
★★★★★

My favorite restaurant ever! I LOVE the atmosphere! You can eat outside on the deck overlooking the water! You order the food yourself at the counter and enjoy! My kids like it too, being that it is so different from the other tradional places. A definite place to go for a fun night out!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Mike's is one of our favorite spots to pick up seafood we want to cook at home! Great selection and always fresh! You can even order cooked meals to take home if you want! Love it!

5
★★★★★

Mike's is one of our favorite spots to pick up seafood we want to cook at home! Great selection and always fresh! You can even order cooked meals to take home if you want! Love it!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We love Mikes Seafood! It is laid back, with guests sitting at picnic-style tables, BYO (beer and wine only) and good food. No reservations, just wait in line and have a drink!

4
★★★★☆

We love Mikes Seafood! It is laid back, with guests sitting at picnic-style tables, BYO (beer and wine only) and good food. No reservations, just wait in line and have a drink!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

If you want to get some seafood at the shore, this is a decent take out place. The prices are pretty high, but the prices are high at ALL of the restaurants at the shore. It is nice to go if you don't mind casual, and you can bring your own drinks!

3
★★★☆☆

If you want to get some seafood at the shore, this is a decent take out place. The prices are pretty high, but the prices are high at ALL of the restaurants at the shore. It is nice to go if you don't mind casual, and you can bring your own drinks!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We have been getting takeout from Mike's for years. While the food isn't world class, it is decent seafood. The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. It is a reliable place to get takeout seafood on the island.

3
★★★☆☆

We have been getting takeout from Mike's for years. While the food isn't world class, it is decent seafood. The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. It is a reliable place to get takeout seafood on the island.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Mike's is a great CASUAL place by N.J seashore standards. (Hey, the lobster special always sounded too cheap to be true (re previous review)). But I digress. I was so disappointed in the cream of crab soup I picked up at the take out market (thickened white sauce sans crabmeat )that I took to my computer before rinsing the sand off my feet to vent. Don't look for jumbo lump crab at $10 a crabcake but I've always been happy with the fried/steamed specials on the dock. Just don't pick up the takeout crab soup.

2
★★★★☆

Mike's is a great CASUAL place by N.J seashore standards. (Hey, the lobster special always sounded too cheap to be true (re previous review)). But I digress. I was so disappointed in the cream of crab soup I picked up at the take out market (thickened white sauce sans crabmeat )that I took to my computer before rinsing the sand off my feet to vent. Don't look for jumbo lump crab at $10 a crabcake but I've always been happy with the fried/steamed specials on the dock. Just don't pick up the takeout crab soup.

.

Got a $30 meal... came complete with over steamed lobster and crab... rubber and glue. They give you fake butter instead of drawn. Serve you in a disposable alum tray. And you have to get up to place your order. Just another tourist trap.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Got a $30 meal... came complete with over steamed lobster and crab... rubber and glue. They give you fake butter instead of drawn. Serve you in a disposable alum tray. And you have to get up to place your order. Just another tourist trap.

Pros: eat outside BYO

Cons: everything else

.

I am so tired of this kind of review. Please do not rate a restaurant on it's TAKE OUT service. It is a completely different ballgame -especially at the shore in the summer. We stay in Avalon and love Mike's. We like hard shell crabs and they have great ones.

2
★★★★☆

I am so tired of this kind of review. Please do not rate a restaurant on it's TAKE OUT service. It is a completely different ballgame -especially at the shore in the summer. We stay in Avalon and love Mike's. We like hard shell crabs and they have great ones.

.

Just bought house in SIC. Had dinner in SIC's Mike's Seafood last year for the first time. Dinner was so-so. But we were all craving seafood, so it sufficed. We haven't returned since...and we live in SIC all year now.

Second experience with Mike's was in their Ocean City location. We really wanted Campbell's Seafood (oh so good...but they closed). Mike's seems to be the only other option, but we were eager to try it. We ordered dinner for 4 for take-out. We were very excited with all of the food options. We ordered 4 dinners & 1 appetizer and drove home to Sea Isle for dinner. Once we walked in the door, we realized we didn't get one of the 5 things. We called to ask that our credit card be refunded for the missing item. Shockingly, they refused!?!?!!!!!! They insisted that we had received it, um...but we didn't...why would we call? Dinner was over $80 for takeout in styrofoam...and again, mediocre. Best part is that they use Kelchner's tartar & cocktail sauce (but they don't make that themselves). The owner, Mike, finally got on the phone after we simply asked that the card be credited. They said we couldn't prove it. Seriously? Forget customer service apparently!!! Unbelievable! He started yelling at us and we finally just hung up. There were 4 of us standing around, all of us could hear him screaming through the phone, without being on speaker. Honestly, the last time we raised an issue with a pick-up order was almost 4 years ago in a Philadelphia surburban restaurant. The owner of the restaurant drove the missing order over and dropped off a gift certificate. We weren't asking Mike's for anything other than to not be taken advantage of...so bizarre that anyone would think that was good business, much less the ethical thing to do!? In all of our years, that was the worst experience.

Find somewhere else to patronize - they don't deserve it.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Just bought house in SIC. Had dinner in SIC's Mike's Seafood last year for the first time. Dinner was so-so. But we were all craving seafood, so it sufficed. We haven't returned since...and we live in SIC all year now.

Second experience with Mike's was in their Ocean City location. We really wanted Campbell's Seafood (oh so good...but they closed). Mike's seems to be the only other option, but we were eager to try it. We ordered dinner for 4 for take-out. We were very excited with all of the food options. We ordered 4 dinners & 1 appetizer and drove home to Sea Isle for dinner. Once we walked in the door, we realized we didn't get one of the 5 things. We called to ask that our credit card be refunded for the missing item. Shockingly, they refused!?!?!!!!!! They insisted that we had received it, um...but we didn't...why would we call? Dinner was over $80 for takeout in styrofoam...and again, mediocre. Best part is that they use Kelchner's tartar & cocktail sauce (but they don't make that themselves). The owner, Mike, finally got on the phone after we simply asked that the card be credited. They said we couldn't prove it. Seriously? Forget customer service apparently!!! Unbelievable! He started yelling at us and we finally just hung up. There were 4 of us standing around, all of us could hear him screaming through the phone, without being on speaker. Honestly, the last time we raised an issue with a pick-up order was almost 4 years ago in a Philadelphia surburban restaurant. The owner of the restaurant drove the missing order over and dropped off a gift certificate. We weren't asking Mike's for anything other than to not be taken advantage of...so bizarre that anyone would think that was good business, much less the ethical thing to do!? In all of our years, that was the worst experience.

Find somewhere else to patronize - they don't deserve it.

Cons: Ownership, Customer Service, Value - RUN AWAY!!!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Mike's Seafood, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review