Insider Pages Reviews for Anselmo's Coal-Fired Brick Oven Pizza

1 Stars: Not Good! (by NotGood)

NotGood — Sat, 14 Nov 2009 01:00:00 GMT

Very small pies, I thought the box was empty. You need two if your a family of three.

It didn't look anything like the website. Overpriced It was almost like eating a pice of pita bread with a little sauce/mozzarella
Im an Italian born & raised in Cobble Hill, this was disappointing.

Im not going to compare it to Grimaldi's because that place is a joke. Waiting on a long line with People that can't pronounce Ricotta, Mozzarella or Manicotti isn't a sign for "good Pizza ahead"

Di Fara is the BEST Pizza in NYC & its here in Brooklyn, Sam's on Court St is better then this place & Grimaldi's.

It seems like the reviews are fabricated. The one star I gave them is for the Cannoli, they were up there with Ferdinando's on Union St.

Think about it, they were going to be a "full line bakery cafe" until they found a brick oven. Does this sound like a Pizzeria that should be "getting better reviews then 40-year-old Pizzeria's" It does explain the good Cannoli.

5 Stars: Delicious, a taste of Italy! (by Lolosan)

Lolosan — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 01:00:00 GMT

Awesome pizza thanks to the great oven... An address you should not miss!

4 Stars: Top-line pizza (by Bokchoy)

Bokchoy — Sun, 23 Aug 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Anselmo?s is a very pleasant surprise in the burgeoning Van Brunt eatery strip. A welcome addition! We ordered the ?house special? pizza which turned out to be their standard margarita pie with generous pepperoni and mushroom supplement. The brick oven made 14? thin crust special pie was sufficient for 2. It was well prepared but slightly burnt ? still a near excellent product. For native Brooklynites, the pizza is reminiscent to the pies at Lento?s Bensonhurst. Saturday night service was better than average - what you can expect in a Brooklyn establishment.

This is a BYOB place luckily with a mini-supermarket (for beer) on the other end of a short block and a corner liquor store diagonally across the street.

A definite return tripper!

5 Stars: Best pizza around (by MisterM)

MisterM — Thu, 16 Jul 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Anselmo's is a diamond in the greasy rough of NY pizza places. Amazing on a Friday night or anytime!

5 Stars: Coal Oven Pizza in NYC!!! (by dowork)

dowork — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Great coal oven pizza, maybe the best pizza I've ever had. Gives grimaldi's a run for its money. For the price and quality you cant go wrong

5 Stars: Best Pizza in Brooklyn (by boyacasha)

boyacasha — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Love, love, love pizzza. this is by far my fave in the area. if i could get everyone in the nyc area one tip its to try this spot. nyc pizza the way its made to me. come on follow me to anselmos!!!!!

5 Stars: Great Pizza (by Strakssss)

Strakssss — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Great thin crust. Some of the best pizza in BK. I would reccommend to anyon......great service and always quick

5 Stars: Best Brick Oven in Brooklyn (by NYC311)

NYC311 — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 02:00:00 GMT

I've headed out to Brooklyn numerous times just for the pizza here. The crust gives youa solid crunch and the cheese and sauce will leave your taste buds dancing. I wish they were around the corner here in NYC, but hey, a trek out to BK for the best pizza going is worth it. Check it out

5 Stars: The Best Pizza I've ever had (by dolphins13)

dolphins13 — Thu, 07 May 2009 02:00:00 GMT

This is literally the best pizza I've ever had. Perfect crust. great sauce, and quality cheese. For coal fired pizza it is very affordable. Definitely worth a trip to Brooklyn

5 Stars: WOW the best pizza i have ever had! And the price amazing (by Pizzafirst)

Pizzafirst — Thu, 07 May 2009 02:00:00 GMT

Just came from there today from word of mouth. The word was right about Anselmo's Coal Oven Pizza in Red Hook. I still can't believe the price! Amazing