Romeo's New York Pizza

★★★★★
34.0181 -84.1901
Map and Directions to Romeo's New York Pizza

678-514-1111

9700 Medlock Bridge Rd ste 168

John's Creek, GA

30097

Get Directions

About Romeo's New York Pizza

Food

Food
More choices in Duluth:
Resultset_next

Pepperoni's Pizza

2750 Buford Hwy # 5b Duluth, GA

Resultset_next

Stevi B's Pizza

1500 Pleasant Hill Rd Duluth, GA

4.84 25
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Romeo's New York Pizza was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 25 of 25.

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

This is pizza at its best, and the most friendly owners you have ever met! My family of five BEG for Romeo's at least once a week. The service is fast, and the pizza is the most delicious you will ever taste. They aren't sharing the family secret for this very special, light and perfect crust, and for good reason! They have unlocked the secret to perfect pizza with neighborly service!

5
★★★★★

This is pizza at its best, and the most friendly owners you have ever met! My family of five BEG for Romeo's at least once a week. The service is fast, and the pizza is the most delicious you will ever taste. They aren't sharing the family secret for this very special, light and perfect crust, and for good reason! They have unlocked the secret to perfect pizza with neighborly service!

.

Once you taste Romeo's pizza, you won't ever settle for anything else. This is a neighborhood family-owned place with a secret recipe, turning out some of the finest pizza I have ever tasted. What is about that crust that makes the whole pizza so amazing? The owners aren't sharing the secret, but they sure do know how to make some great pizza. Don't miss the great salads and sandwiches, too. Come in for lunch - they have a special slice/salad/drink deal (or double slice/drink) that is priced right and very fast. The owners are so nice. This is what a neighborhood pizza place should be!

5
★★★★★

Once you taste Romeo's pizza, you won't ever settle for anything else. This is a neighborhood family-owned place with a secret recipe, turning out some of the finest pizza I have ever tasted. What is about that crust that makes the whole pizza so amazing? The owners aren't sharing the secret, but they sure do know how to make some great pizza. Don't miss the great salads and sandwiches, too. Come in for lunch - they have a special slice/salad/drink deal (or double slice/drink) that is priced right and very fast. The owners are so nice. This is what a neighborhood pizza place should be!

Pros: Fabulous, friendly service, DELICIOUS

.

AVOID THIS PLACE AT ALL COSTS!!!! The owner is an unstable, rude man worse than any episode you have ever seen on Seinfeld. If you go...be prepared to be insulted!

1
★☆☆☆☆

AVOID THIS PLACE AT ALL COSTS!!!! The owner is an unstable, rude man worse than any episode you have ever seen on Seinfeld. If you go...be prepared to be insulted!

Pros: I wouldn't know - the owner wouldn't serve us.

Cons: They don't like children or groups.

.

If you're looking for yummy, authentic NY style pizza this place is the best in North Atlanta bar none. Growing up on the mainline near Philadelphia I know good pizza. Romeo's uses the highest quality incredients and the sauce and the way they cook the crust until it's crispy makes for a delicious pizza pie. Combine that with an ice-cold Peroni malt beverage and you'll be well satisfied.

5
★★★★★

If you're looking for yummy, authentic NY style pizza this place is the best in North Atlanta bar none. Growing up on the mainline near Philadelphia I know good pizza. Romeo's uses the highest quality incredients and the sauce and the way they cook the crust until it's crispy makes for a delicious pizza pie. Combine that with an ice-cold Peroni malt beverage and you'll be well satisfied.

.

Originally from Upstate NY, I've been down in Atlanta for quite some time and stumble on many "authentic NY Pizza" joints. Until now that has been a false claim. Romeo's makes a great tasting authentic NY Pizza, with fresh ingredients. I only wish one was closer to my part of town!
Great job!

5
★★★★★

Originally from Upstate NY, I've been down in Atlanta for quite some time and stumble on many "authentic NY Pizza" joints. Until now that has been a false claim. Romeo's makes a great tasting authentic NY Pizza, with fresh ingredients. I only wish one was closer to my part of town!
Great job!

Pros: Finally, a real NY Pizza down south!

Cons: Only 1 location

.

Well, Finally!
After 20 freakin years, a true NY Pizza joint.

I had just about given up on eating pizza period. If i did indulge it would be Johnny's NY Pizza and not because it's NY style because it ain't! it's because it was palatable pizza but then again not all the time.
So, as i was saying; i had just about given up on eating pizza while in Ga. and along comes a authentic NY Pizza spot that i can actually sit there and eat slice after slice after slice and still want more.....
Who ever that short stubby guy behind the register with the NJ accent is (i was told he was the owner), I want to thank you for opening up a spot that i don't mind driving 40Min's to (because i actually do drive that distance from Decatur). Please, Please, Please (look now I'm singing about it), Please open up a location somewhere in Decatur, we need it badly..

5
★★★★★

Well, Finally!
After 20 freakin years, a true NY Pizza joint.

I had just about given up on eating pizza period. If i did indulge it would be Johnny's NY Pizza and not because it's NY style because it ain't! it's because it was palatable pizza but then again not all the time.
So, as i was saying; i had just about given up on eating pizza while in Ga. and along comes a authentic NY Pizza spot that i can actually sit there and eat slice after slice after slice and still want more.....
Who ever that short stubby guy behind the register with the NJ accent is (i was told he was the owner), I want to thank you for opening up a spot that i don't mind driving 40Min's to (because i actually do drive that distance from Decatur). Please, Please, Please (look now I'm singing about it), Please open up a location somewhere in Decatur, we need it badly..

Pros: Great Pizza!

Cons: Need to put a 22" pie on the menu.

.

My family and I have been down South for 10 years - Relocated from Rockland County, NY (appx. 30 miles north of NYC)
We grew up eating some of the best pizza in the world.
After many failed attempts to find a true NY pizza in the South, we finally can now say - we have found one.

Romeo's uses quality ingredients (which is key in making a great pie)

The guys there are very customer oriented and want to be sure their product exceeds expectations.

We frequent Romeo's quite often and are impressed with the quality and the modest pricing.

Great job Guys !!

5
★★★★★

My family and I have been down South for 10 years - Relocated from Rockland County, NY (appx. 30 miles north of NYC)
We grew up eating some of the best pizza in the world.
After many failed attempts to find a true NY pizza in the South, we finally can now say - we have found one.

Romeo's uses quality ingredients (which is key in making a great pie)

The guys there are very customer oriented and want to be sure their product exceeds expectations.

We frequent Romeo's quite often and are impressed with the quality and the modest pricing.

Great job Guys !!

Pros: Good Sauce, Quality ingredients, thin crust

Cons: None

.

Finding a decent NY pizza in this area can be difficult.

Romeo's does not disappoint . By the pie or by the slice their pizza is awesome as is their signature salad.

Service is quick and friendly. Great pizza at a reasonable price.

5
★★★★★

Finding a decent NY pizza in this area can be difficult.

Romeo's does not disappoint . By the pie or by the slice their pizza is awesome as is their signature salad.

Service is quick and friendly. Great pizza at a reasonable price.

.

The variety of pizza's and the awesome salads with homemade dressing.
Viony

5
★★★★★

The variety of pizza's and the awesome salads with homemade dressing.
Viony

Pros: Great salads.

Cons: Need more locations

.

If you are looking for exceptional Pizza, you've gotta try Romeo's New York Pizza, located right next door to the Regal Movie Theater. I will assure you it will be a great dining experience.
I love their excellent salads, it's not the bagged cheap stuff. The salads are always fresh and served with their family dressing, which is superb.
If you like chicken wings, well they serve those too, and they are pretty tasty.

************************************************************************************************************************

Another thing I'd like to mention about Romeo's is that it is family owned and operated. In this day and age it is refreshing to see a family working together, and enjoying what they do. The atmosphere is clean, warm and inviting.
If you appreciate really good pizza I hope you will try Romeo's at least once, I have a feeling it won't be your last time stopping in for a bite to eat.

5
★★★★★

If you are looking for exceptional Pizza, you've gotta try Romeo's New York Pizza, located right next door to the Regal Movie Theater. I will assure you it will be a great dining experience.
I love their excellent salads, it's not the bagged cheap stuff. The salads are always fresh and served with their family dressing, which is superb.
If you like chicken wings, well they serve those too, and they are pretty tasty.

************************************************************************************************************************

Another thing I'd like to mention about Romeo's is that it is family owned and operated. In this day and age it is refreshing to see a family working together, and enjoying what they do. The atmosphere is clean, warm and inviting.
If you appreciate really good pizza I hope you will try Romeo's at least once, I have a feeling it won't be your last time stopping in for a bite to eat.

Pros: Excellent food, pricing & friendly atmosphere

.

I didn't think I would ever find Great Pizza again without a plain ticket back home but I was pleasantly suprised when I happend upon Romeo's NY Pizza. Plentiful great quality ingrediants at a more than a fair price. I have to be truly impressed for me to make the effort to write a review but it was that good! I was in and out in ten minutes before the previews for my movie next door were even over. Sure beat the overpriced popcorn I thought I was going to end up with. Check it out!

5
★★★★★

I didn't think I would ever find Great Pizza again without a plain ticket back home but I was pleasantly suprised when I happend upon Romeo's NY Pizza. Plentiful great quality ingrediants at a more than a fair price. I have to be truly impressed for me to make the effort to write a review but it was that good! I was in and out in ten minutes before the previews for my movie next door were even over. Sure beat the overpriced popcorn I thought I was going to end up with. Check it out!

.

We found this place after watching a movie next door. Wow.. we had to go back. The food is well prepared and plentiful, the atmosphere is good. It's worth the drive even when youlive 20 miles away. We have been back a number of times since just for the Pizza!

5
★★★★★

We found this place after watching a movie next door. Wow.. we had to go back. The food is well prepared and plentiful, the atmosphere is good. It's worth the drive even when youlive 20 miles away. We have been back a number of times since just for the Pizza!

Pros: Great Pizza

Cons: None

.

Romeo's pizza is just a superior product. Coming from New Jersey I can without a doubt proclaim that Romeo's pizza has a true, New York authenticity to it unlike any other pizza place in Georgia. Their salads are amazing and their wings are better than the wings at most wings places. I am not only a fan but a repeat customer.

5
★★★★★

Romeo's pizza is just a superior product. Coming from New Jersey I can without a doubt proclaim that Romeo's pizza has a true, New York authenticity to it unlike any other pizza place in Georgia. Their salads are amazing and their wings are better than the wings at most wings places. I am not only a fan but a repeat customer.

Pros: Food, service, authenticity

Cons: That I do not live closer

.

I tried Romeo's on accident when I was visiting a client in the area. I actually was going to another restaurant at the center, but changed my mind when I saw the pizza joint. Absolutely phenomenal pizza. I gorged myself because I ordered two slices and after I was finished, I order another slice. I have not tried anything else, but I will be back when I am on that side of town for sure. I hope they open a place near Vinings closer to me...

5
★★★★★

I tried Romeo's on accident when I was visiting a client in the area. I actually was going to another restaurant at the center, but changed my mind when I saw the pizza joint. Absolutely phenomenal pizza. I gorged myself because I ordered two slices and after I was finished, I order another slice. I have not tried anything else, but I will be back when I am on that side of town for sure. I hope they open a place near Vinings closer to me...

Pros: Pizza is VERY authentic NY style

Cons: Limited Menu, but I guess that's way the pizza great

.

This place has the best N.Y. style pizza I've ever tasted, even the crust is delectable. The Philly cheese steak is fantastic and fillig. It's conveniently by the movies and really hits the spot right before a show. It's also close enough for lunch. I highly recommend this establishment to everyone who enjoys a great dining experience. Keep up the great job!!!

5
★★★★★

This place has the best N.Y. style pizza I've ever tasted, even the crust is delectable. The Philly cheese steak is fantastic and fillig. It's conveniently by the movies and really hits the spot right before a show. It's also close enough for lunch. I highly recommend this establishment to everyone who enjoys a great dining experience. Keep up the great job!!!

Pros: Friendly service, Great Pizza, Fantastic Atmosphere

Cons: There's only one :(

.

The pizza cannot even be compared to a typical pizza place, it is incredibly fresh and tasty. Everything from the cheese to the dough is perfect. Not only can you get great pizza; you can also get great wings. I would recommend this to everyone!

5
★★★★★

The pizza cannot even be compared to a typical pizza place, it is incredibly fresh and tasty. Everything from the cheese to the dough is perfect. Not only can you get great pizza; you can also get great wings. I would recommend this to everyone!

Pros: Best Pizza I Have Ever Had!

Cons: There aren't any

.

The first time I went to Romeo's I started off with two slices of pizza, and I absolutely loved it! That night I ended up leaving with a calzone, and when I got home and started eating it I was like, "OH MY GOD!" It was so good I drove back to Romeo's two days later, got another calzone, and drove from John's Creek to Buford just to let my sister and brother-in-law (who was born and raised in New York) taste it. Their reaction was the same as mine. The ingredients are fresh, the portions are big, the taste is authentic, and they are even open late. I highly recommend this place.

5
★★★★★

The first time I went to Romeo's I started off with two slices of pizza, and I absolutely loved it! That night I ended up leaving with a calzone, and when I got home and started eating it I was like, "OH MY GOD!" It was so good I drove back to Romeo's two days later, got another calzone, and drove from John's Creek to Buford just to let my sister and brother-in-law (who was born and raised in New York) taste it. Their reaction was the same as mine. The ingredients are fresh, the portions are big, the taste is authentic, and they are even open late. I highly recommend this place.

Pros: Great Calzones and Pizza

Cons: none

.

A friend of mine recommended Romeo's. Every time I would get a recommendation for pizza it would be a disappointment . ( since I have been raised in NY ) Not this time !! Just as good if not better than NYC pizza. Their salads are the bomb. Prices are a good value, I go there at least once a week.

5
★★★★★

A friend of mine recommended Romeo's. Every time I would get a recommendation for pizza it would be a disappointment . ( since I have been raised in NY ) Not this time !! Just as good if not better than NYC pizza. Their salads are the bomb. Prices are a good value, I go there at least once a week.

Pros: Big Slices Great Pizza

Cons: Gets crowded

.

True NYC pizza, its right next to the theater so i can't complain.

5
★★★★★

True NYC pizza, its right next to the theater so i can't complain.

Pros: Big slices

.

I"m a picky pizza guy as I'm from NYC and this pizza is amazing. The slices are huge and the taste is extremely authentic. Going back this weekend!!

5
★★★★★

I"m a picky pizza guy as I'm from NYC and this pizza is amazing. The slices are huge and the taste is extremely authentic. Going back this weekend!!

Pros: Better than NYC!

Cons: none

.

Romeo's Ny pizza is the best pizza in the world.
Trust me i know my pizza! if your sick of junk all the time then come to Romeo's they never have junk all made from an authentic new yorker. The owner is from new jersy but he knows his new york pizza!!!!! Now try something new!!!

5
★★★★★

Romeo's Ny pizza is the best pizza in the world.
Trust me i know my pizza! if your sick of junk all the time then come to Romeo's they never have junk all made from an authentic new yorker. The owner is from new jersy but he knows his new york pizza!!!!! Now try something new!!!

Pros: best pizza in town

.

If you're in the mood for New York pizza, Romeo's tops 'em all - truly a delightful dining experience for the whole family.

5
★★★★★

If you're in the mood for New York pizza, Romeo's tops 'em all - truly a delightful dining experience for the whole family.

Pros: Fresh, Hot & Delicious

.

I am a salesman working the Johns Creek area and I stopped by Romeo's NY Pizza to see if the name was bogus or not. Well, take it from a NY Italian. I felt like I was home. The crust actually had taste, the sauce was not straight out of a can, the service was great and the decor was cool. I also tried the wings and they were on the money. They did not have that vinegar taste of hot sauce that so many places think is required. I will absolutely be back.

5
★★★★★

I am a salesman working the Johns Creek area and I stopped by Romeo's NY Pizza to see if the name was bogus or not. Well, take it from a NY Italian. I felt like I was home. The crust actually had taste, the sauce was not straight out of a can, the service was great and the decor was cool. I also tried the wings and they were on the money. They did not have that vinegar taste of hot sauce that so many places think is required. I will absolutely be back.

Pros: Actually tastes like NY pizza

Cons: Too far from my house

.

Pizza was great, they are open late so it was super convenient to catch a slice after my movie. Right next to the Regal theater in John's Creek. Service was fast, pizza was good and it was extremely convenient. Definitely will go again.

5
★★★★★

Pizza was great, they are open late so it was super convenient to catch a slice after my movie. Right next to the Regal theater in John's Creek. Service was fast, pizza was good and it was extremely convenient. Definitely will go again.

.

I have been waiting for a great New York style pizza place in Johns Creek and its finally here!

5
★★★★★

I have been waiting for a great New York style pizza place in Johns Creek and its finally here!

Pros: New York Style

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Romeo's Pizza
    No reviews
    0.01 mi
  2. 2
    Stevi B's Pizza
    No reviews
    0.07 mi
  3. 3
    Pizza Hut
    No reviews
    0.48 mi
  4. 4
    Mellow Mushroom
    No reviews
    0.81 mi
  5. 5
    Sugo
    5% ★★★★★ 36 reviews
    0.95 mi