Pop's N.Y. Pizza

★★★★★

About Pop's N.Y. Pizza

Hours
Sun 11:30am-10pm; Mon 11:30am-10pm; Tue 11:30am-10pm; Wed 11:30am-10pm; Thu 11:30am-3:30am; Fri 11:30am-3:30am; Sat 11:30am-3:30am
5 15
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Pop's N.Y. Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

My husband and I moved to columbia n really wanted to find a good non chain pizza joint.. Pops was the perfect place. Love the slice N the huge pizza!!

3
★★★★★

My husband and I moved to columbia n really wanted to find a good non chain pizza joint.. Pops was the perfect place. Love the slice N the huge pizza!!

.

I've been here a few times and just found out it was sold and has new management. The pizza was really terrific, they redid the entire restaurant and they have all new items on the menu. I tried the Fried Twinkies, which were amazing.

3
★★★★★

I've been here a few times and just found out it was sold and has new management. The pizza was really terrific, they redid the entire restaurant and they have all new items on the menu. I tried the Fried Twinkies, which were amazing.

.

Had dinner with friends there last night and LOVED the Pizza. Huge slices. Then had a philly and thought I was back in Penn. The bread was the real thing and it was drippng with cheese and onions. The place is great. You'll love it!

3
★★★★★

Had dinner with friends there last night and LOVED the Pizza. Huge slices. Then had a philly and thought I was back in Penn. The bread was the real thing and it was drippng with cheese and onions. The place is great. You'll love it!

.

The Pizza is amazing! Real NY Pizza which is huge! And the pasta we ordered (Chicken Carbonara and Drunken Chicken) was to die for . We then ordered delivery a few days later and it came hot and fresh. You will love this place!

3
★★★★★

The Pizza is amazing! Real NY Pizza which is huge! And the pasta we ordered (Chicken Carbonara and Drunken Chicken) was to die for . We then ordered delivery a few days later and it came hot and fresh. You will love this place!

.

If you are thinking about dining at Pop

3
★★★★★

If you are thinking about dining at Pop

.

Pizza is expensive and not good. Restaurant smells of stale beer and urine from the late night college crowds. you would be better of going to any other nearby pizza place such as Dano's, Village idiot or Thirsty Fellow. Owner of Pops is a

3
★★★★★

Pizza is expensive and not good. Restaurant smells of stale beer and urine from the late night college crowds. you would be better of going to any other nearby pizza place such as Dano's, Village idiot or Thirsty Fellow. Owner of Pops is a

.

I had an unfortunate experience the first time that I went to Pop's with a friend. The menu board was so worn that my friend and I thought we were ordering an 8-inch pizza, only to find that it was in fact an 18-inch pizza when it came to our table. In addition to that surprise, the pizza was terrible. We had tons of leftovers, and I didn't even want to take it home.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I had an unfortunate experience the first time that I went to Pop's with a friend. The menu board was so worn that my friend and I thought we were ordering an 8-inch pizza, only to find that it was in fact an 18-inch pizza when it came to our table. In addition to that surprise, the pizza was terrible. We had tons of leftovers, and I didn't even want to take it home.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Rutherford, who has owned and operated the Columbia pizzeria at 707 Harden St. since 2007, is firmly establishing a reputation around town for not paying his bills. Fellow business owners, beware: Court records obtained by City Paper show

3
★★★★★

Rutherford, who has owned and operated the Columbia pizzeria at 707 Harden St. since 2007, is firmly establishing a reputation around town for not paying his bills. Fellow business owners, beware: Court records obtained by City Paper show

Cons: Past and Current Criminal Activity

.

Waited 30 minutes for cold card board they called Pizza and they gave our credit card to someone else and blamed it on us.

3
★★★★★

Waited 30 minutes for cold card board they called Pizza and they gave our credit card to someone else and blamed it on us.

Pros: Re-heated Pizza comparable to card board.

Cons: Worst service, mgmt and ownership in town.

.

Our experience with Pop's pizza began with a phone call requesting delivery to a guy who asked for my phone number twice and then reported my address to the delivery driver as "East Squadron," I live in West Quad. An hour and ten minutes

3
★★★★★

Our experience with Pop's pizza began with a phone call requesting delivery to a guy who asked for my phone number twice and then reported my address to the delivery driver as "East Squadron," I live in West Quad. An hour and ten minutes

Cons: service

.

My husband and I went to Pop's a month or so after it first opened. It was excellent. The staff was a little "wet-behind-the-ears" and the service was a tad bit slower than we anticipated given there were only 4-5 customers present. But

3
★★★★★

My husband and I went to Pop's a month or so after it first opened. It was excellent. The staff was a little "wet-behind-the-ears" and the service was a tad bit slower than we anticipated given there were only 4-5 customers present. But

Pros: convenient location despite the meters

Cons: everything else

.

The decision to order from Pop's was made because they are near where I work and they offer delivery. I should have read the reviews before I made my decision!\r
\r
I was told when I placed the order that it would take about 45 to one

3
★★★★★

The decision to order from Pop's was made because they are near where I work and they offer delivery. I should have read the reviews before I made my decision!\r
\r
I was told when I placed the order that it would take about 45 to one

Pros: Huge pizza

Cons: The food has no taste and the delivery service is snail-like.

.

I am a third year student at USC. I cannot disagree more with the initial review of this restaurant. I have never walked out of Pop's on a late night disappointed. Cute girls at the counter, knowledgable and friendly staff, and most

3
★★★★★

I am a third year student at USC. I cannot disagree more with the initial review of this restaurant. I have never walked out of Pop's on a late night disappointed. Cute girls at the counter, knowledgable and friendly staff, and most

Pros: Philly cheesesteaks, pizza, and wings

Cons: Needs better sweet tea

.

Store was very clean and appeared well staffed. The pizza was huge and the sauce and pizza bread were flavorful. I was quoted 20 min for carryout and recieved my pie in 15. The blonde Pizza cook was fast and true New York style with his

3
★★★★★

Store was very clean and appeared well staffed. The pizza was huge and the sauce and pizza bread were flavorful. I was quoted 20 min for carryout and recieved my pie in 15. The blonde Pizza cook was fast and true New York style with his

Pros: Beautiful Counter Girls, Great attitude!, Enormous Pizza, Open after 5 Points Bars close.

Cons: Extremely busy Late night (11pm - 3:30 am), Large Number of College Students, Parking

.

If you want to make sure that customers do not return, take a lesson from this restaurant:\r
\r
1. Take a phone order for a large pepperoni pizza and tell the customer it will be ready in 20-30 minutes.\r
\r
2. When the customer arrives,

3
★★★★★

If you want to make sure that customers do not return, take a lesson from this restaurant:\r
\r
1. Take a phone order for a large pepperoni pizza and tell the customer it will be ready in 20-30 minutes.\r
\r
2. When the customer arrives,

Cons: horrible, aggresively bad service. lazy kitchen. employees eat at the counter.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Pop's N.Y. Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review