Supper

★★★★☆
  • 156 E 2nd St

    New York, NY 10009

    Cross street: nr. Ave. A

    Map & Directions
  • 212-477-7600

About Supper

Hours
Mon-Thu, 4pm-midnight; Fri, 4pm-1am; Sat, 10am-1am; Sun, 10am-midnight

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Tello Ristoranti

198 8th Ave New York, NY

Resultset_next

La Carbonara

202 W 14th St New York, NY

3.7407 27
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Supper was?
Write a Review
.

This place is delicious and the service was quick and friendly.

2
★★★★☆

This place is delicious and the service was quick and friendly.

.

I went to Supper with my bridesmaids for my bachelorette dinner. We had made reservations days before arriving, however when we got there, the hostess told us "someone had messed up our reservation" and that our name was not on the

1
★★☆☆☆

I went to Supper with my bridesmaids for my bachelorette dinner. We had made reservations days before arriving, however when we got there, the hostess told us "someone had messed up our reservation" and that our name was not on the

.

Supper is the go to place for east village locals to grab a bite and a glass of wine. The food is good, the ambiance is chill and the people are cool.

Sugo bar next door is connected to supper and is also very chill--one of my favorite

2
★★★★★

Supper is the go to place for east village locals to grab a bite and a glass of wine. The food is good, the ambiance is chill and the people are cool.

Sugo bar next door is connected to supper and is also very chill--one of my favorite

.

Before the Hollywood festivities of last night, I had the pleasure of visiting a gem of an East Village restaurant. Through, Twitter, I have been privy to (and the winner of) many a contest. I recently started following @suppernyc, the

2
★★★★☆

Before the Hollywood festivities of last night, I had the pleasure of visiting a gem of an East Village restaurant. Through, Twitter, I have been privy to (and the winner of) many a contest. I recently started following @suppernyc, the

.

Everything is delicious and you can't beat the prices. If they have the Burrata Mozz special when you are there don't miss it.

2
★★★★★

Everything is delicious and you can't beat the prices. If they have the Burrata Mozz special when you are there don't miss it.

Pros: Best food this side of Italy

Cons: ?

.

Had a realllllyyy great girls night here.
We were looking for something new, as always.. And we stumbled on this little gem.
First of all, the space is amazing. SUCH good atmosphere.. really cozy, romantic, dim. It's a bit of a maze on the

2
★★★★☆

Had a realllllyyy great girls night here.
We were looking for something new, as always.. And we stumbled on this little gem.
First of all, the space is amazing. SUCH good atmosphere.. really cozy, romantic, dim. It's a bit of a maze on the

Cons: cash only

.

good value

2
★★★★★

good value

Pros: food

Cons: cramped

.

I have been wanting to go to Supper for a long time but since it's not that easy to get to I have been putting it off. What a mistake - it is so worth a cab ride or walk to get to. We went a little before 8 and were told to wait in the

2
★★★★★

I have been wanting to go to Supper for a long time but since it's not that easy to get to I have been putting it off. What a mistake - it is so worth a cab ride or walk to get to. We went a little before 8 and were told to wait in the

Pros: Bartender next door, food, coziness, everything

Cons: It's far from my apartment on the Upper West Side

.

This place is always pretty croweded for dinner so you have to wait at the adjoining bar which is usually not a problem but I was injured and had no where to sit for the 30 min wait and was obviously injured and nobody gave me their seat.

2
★★★★☆

This place is always pretty croweded for dinner so you have to wait at the adjoining bar which is usually not a problem but I was injured and had no where to sit for the 30 min wait and was obviously injured and nobody gave me their seat.

Pros: great atmosphere and food.

Cons: always crowded for dinner

.

I planned a dinner for 12 at Supper for a Saturday night at 7pm. At 7pm, 3 of our party had not yet arrived, but at 7:05, the hostess seated us anyway which I thought was really nice considering they are very explicit about their 10

2
★★★★★

I planned a dinner for 12 at Supper for a Saturday night at 7pm. At 7pm, 3 of our party had not yet arrived, but at 7:05, the hostess seated us anyway which I thought was really nice considering they are very explicit about their 10

Pros: Great service, food...beautiful space for a large party!!

Cons: NONE...

.

Supper is a real treat in a neighborhood where service has gone to s@#$ . The staff are soo nice and the food is soo good. I can't say enough good things about this place. I've taken many new New Yorkers there and they fall in love and

2
★★★★★

Supper is a real treat in a neighborhood where service has gone to s@#$ . The staff are soo nice and the food is soo good. I can't say enough good things about this place. I've taken many new New Yorkers there and they fall in love and

Cons: The only drawbacks are it is hard to get a table at night sometimes

.

I have been eating at Supper very regularly since I moved to New York 5 years ago as I live in the area. So.. they don't take reservations - if you're having a big group of people out for a birthday - be decent and book somewhere else for

2
★★★★★

I have been eating at Supper very regularly since I moved to New York 5 years ago as I live in the area. So.. they don't take reservations - if you're having a big group of people out for a birthday - be decent and book somewhere else for

Pros: Great service, Great food, Great value

Cons: Bridge & Tunnel Crowds Friday and Saturday nights

.

The food was great - nothing too fancy or flashy, just really tasty food with a "home cooked" feel. I had the mozzarella and tomato salad which was really fresh and delicious and then the gnocchi afterwards - real comfort food! I was a

1
★★★☆☆

The food was great - nothing too fancy or flashy, just really tasty food with a "home cooked" feel. I had the mozzarella and tomato salad which was really fresh and delicious and then the gnocchi afterwards - real comfort food! I was a

Pros: Tasty food

Cons: The back room (unless you're in a group)

.

First impression, Godfather meets vampire dungeon. And then you hear Coldplay, which is great yet having the occurring thought this is out of place. Front section of the restaurant has a lighter feel with 4 outdoor tables, and a bar

2
★★★★☆

First impression, Godfather meets vampire dungeon. And then you hear Coldplay, which is great yet having the occurring thought this is out of place. Front section of the restaurant has a lighter feel with 4 outdoor tables, and a bar

Pros: Outdoor Seating, Wine, Service, Quick Seating

Cons: Cash Only, Reservations Null

.

I have been to Supper countless times since it opened and while I've waited and it's been crowded, the food has always been so good that I didn't really care. When a place is as consistently excellent and well priced as Supper is it's

2
★★★★★

I have been to Supper countless times since it opened and while I've waited and it's been crowded, the food has always been so good that I didn't really care. When a place is as consistently excellent and well priced as Supper is it's

.

I lived in Italy and this food is better. No other restaurant has so many simple wonderful fresh vegetables. Great pasta, great meat. The Rabbit on Saturday! Or the Roasted Pork....Nothing is better anywhere. I love the staff, I love

2
★★★★★

I lived in Italy and this food is better. No other restaurant has so many simple wonderful fresh vegetables. Great pasta, great meat. The Rabbit on Saturday! Or the Roasted Pork....Nothing is better anywhere. I love the staff, I love

Pros: Everything

Cons: Too many hungery patrons...hard to get a table...but we go early to avoid that.

.

We had a wonderful dining experience at Supper. The charming host delighted us with his Irish brogue as we waited for the rest of our party. We were a group of ten and were seated in the back of this very cozy dining room right next to a

1
★★★☆☆

We had a wonderful dining experience at Supper. The charming host delighted us with his Irish brogue as we waited for the rest of our party. We were a group of ten and were seated in the back of this very cozy dining room right next to a

.

Went there last Sunday night with 2 friends and had a really great dinner. It was a cold, crappy night and Supper was warm, cozy and filled with delicious smells. Their fresh mozzarella is some of the best I've ever had. Just beware of

2
★★★★☆

Went there last Sunday night with 2 friends and had a really great dinner. It was a cold, crappy night and Supper was warm, cozy and filled with delicious smells. Their fresh mozzarella is some of the best I've ever had. Just beware of

Pros: great mozzarella, cozy atmosphere

Cons: service is a bit slow and forgetful

.

It's not really in my nature to complain and I've never reviewed anything, but Supper was THE worst dining experience I've EVER had ANYWHERE. It was my friend's birthday, so we went this past Saturday to celebrate, because she'd always

0
★☆☆☆☆

It's not really in my nature to complain and I've never reviewed anything, but Supper was THE worst dining experience I've EVER had ANYWHERE. It was my friend's birthday, so we went this past Saturday to celebrate, because she'd always

Pros: Pros? Are you kidding me?! lol

Cons: How much time do you have?

.

Supper used to be one of my favorite resaurants. I hadn't been there in a while and wanted to take my boyfriend there for our anniversary. What a mistake! The hostess was so rude I wanted to leave right away. Things only got worse. We

1
★★☆☆☆

Supper used to be one of my favorite resaurants. I hadn't been there in a while and wanted to take my boyfriend there for our anniversary. What a mistake! The hostess was so rude I wanted to leave right away. Things only got worse. We

.

I adore Supper. Dishes such as pesto, spinach gnocchi with garlic cream and lemon spaghetti are excellent. Dishes are under $15 and the portions (with the exception of ravioli which was good but left me hungry) are good. Their wine list

2
★★★★★

I adore Supper. Dishes such as pesto, spinach gnocchi with garlic cream and lemon spaghetti are excellent. Dishes are under $15 and the portions (with the exception of ravioli which was good but left me hungry) are good. Their wine list

Pros: Authentic Italian food, prices

Cons: Cash only, the wait

.

I headed to Supper with a group of 5 on Saturday night. We called ahead to make reservations, and were told they didn't take reservations, so we figured we'd do as we would at any other restaurant- grab a drink at the bar. We were told

1
★★★☆☆

I headed to Supper with a group of 5 on Saturday night. We called ahead to make reservations, and were told they didn't take reservations, so we figured we'd do as we would at any other restaurant- grab a drink at the bar. We were told

Pros: ambience, good value for money

Cons: no reservations accepted

.

Definitely not the spot for people who don't like to dine in close-quarters, but the food is amazing for the $$, some of the best in NYC! Cozy, warm atmosphere, super comforting dishes, and reasonably priced. Best in the neighborhood.

2
★★★★★

Definitely not the spot for people who don't like to dine in close-quarters, but the food is amazing for the $$, some of the best in NYC! Cozy, warm atmosphere, super comforting dishes, and reasonably priced. Best in the neighborhood.

.

hostess was the best part of the evening, downhill from there. waitress would only take a complete order (app, main and dessert!) at same time. reason - sooo busy! ha! the place had 4 empty tables that i could see (7pm - sunday) i've

0
★☆☆☆☆

hostess was the best part of the evening, downhill from there. waitress would only take a complete order (app, main and dessert!) at same time. reason - sooo busy! ha! the place had 4 empty tables that i could see (7pm - sunday) i've

Pros: location, outdoor seating

Cons: staff, staff, staff!, food! food!, attitude!

.

When we were about to sit at a table by the bar, the host said "don't bother". A disabled patron was about to sit on a bar stool and the host said "...that's reserved...." The host checked a patron into the edge of a table by the bar.

0
★☆☆☆☆

When we were about to sit at a table by the bar, the host said "don't bother". A disabled patron was about to sit on a bar stool and the host said "...that's reserved...." The host checked a patron into the edge of a table by the bar.

Pros: Atrocious customer se

.

No reservations possible for parties less than 10 means no idea when you will be seated. We waited OVER two hours from the time we arrive until our food was served. And all this for average Italian food served in uncomfortable booths.

1
★★☆☆☆

No reservations possible for parties less than 10 means no idea when you will be seated. We waited OVER two hours from the time we arrive until our food was served. And all this for average Italian food served in uncomfortable booths.

Pros: at a popular place

Cons: about everything

.

Supper is a lovely place: good ambiance, cute communal tables and delicious inexpensive food. The service, unfortunately, was a bit obnoxious: my date and I were interrupted too many times by the waitress (who was probably just trying to

2
★★★★☆

Supper is a lovely place: good ambiance, cute communal tables and delicious inexpensive food. The service, unfortunately, was a bit obnoxious: my date and I were interrupted too many times by the waitress (who was probably just trying to

Pros: great ambiance, communal tables, inexpensive good food

Cons: red wine was cold, so, so service

Editorial from

Supper is one of Frank Prisinzano's budget Italian spots (Frank, Lil' Frankie's Pizza) and is more grown-up than its older siblings, exuding a sophisticated yet rustic style (chandeliers, a glassed-in wine cellar), but you still get…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Supper, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review