Insider Pages Reviews for Buttercup Bake Shop

5 Stars: Cupcake Heaven (by Joan R.)

Joan R. — Tue, 21 Jun 2005 20:09:00 GMT

I think I've died and gone to cupcake heaven (and I don't want to leave!) The cupcakes are as beautiful as they are delicious here. Each one is decorated so exquisitely it's almost a sin to eat them (almost, but not quite.) There are so many flavors and colors to choose from you'll need to try at least two to get a good idea of just how wonderful they are. They also have a delightful array of cakes that would liven up just about any party. This is definitely a gem in NYC.

5 Stars: The Worlds Greatest cup cakes (by Anassa M.)

Anassa M. — Thu, 05 May 2005 14:52:00 GMT

I could just eat my heart out at this bakery. They have a wonderful selection. I love the Dulce de Leche Cup Cake. they also make those mini cupcakes for special occassions.

5 Stars: The Ultimate Bake Sale (by Jayne D.)

Jayne D. — Tue, 23 Aug 2005 10:18:00 GMT

What's the secret?? How does Buttercup make their cupcakes soft and fluffy? The icing is superb - Just sweet enough. Every time I'm having a bad day, I head straight to Buttercup and all is well... I swear, when I walk out the doors, I hear birds chirping and the sun shining - I even caught a rainbow a couple times!

PROS: They serve milk by the glass!
CONS:

4 Stars: Simply the best cupcakes ever (by Vidhi B.)

Vidhi B. — Wed, 04 May 2005 01:13:00 GMT

The buttercup bake shop is one of the most popular bakery in midtown manhattan serving some of the finest american desserts.Just passing by the store can be too overwhelming and its hard to resist not going in.Their colourful and appetzing cup cakes and layer cakes are to die for.And let me tell you you cant stop at just one.

5 Stars: Yum! (by Gianna D.)

Gianna D. — Sun, 10 Jul 2005 02:17:00 GMT

I often hop on the subway just to get some cakes and cupcakes from the Buttercup Bake Shop. They are the best I have ever tasted and so beautiful that you don't want to eat them. They have so many different varieties and flavors to choose from, you won't know what to pick, so you'll have to pick a bunch of them! You'll gain five pounds just from smellling the delicious aroma wafting out of the store. This place is truly out of this world.