Insider Pages Reviews for Casey's Cafe

5 Stars: Best food and the nicest staff ever (by boaterdd)

boaterdd — Fri, 26 Dec 2008 01:00:00 GMT

We came upon Casey's by chance when we were walking around Half Moon Bay we had our dog with us and they are dog Friendly on the patio we looked at the menu and decided to give it a try I had the Artichoke soup and the crab sandwich my friend had the Casey burger and garlic fries well pretty soon after being served food was flying back and forth both of us trying the other's food the dog was also waiting for a bite which he never got.
The food is fresh and great portions and Casey came by the table and talked to us for a while, the whole staff gets an A+ rating all I can say is we always go to Casey's when were in town you should try it also.
Don't forget the homemade Cobbler al a mode. we also found out that Casey Carters so we are calling her next time we need a party taken care off.
Dan,Dave&George(the Basset hound)

4 Stars: Yummy! (by Ariel C.)

Ariel C. — Fri, 14 Nov 2008 09:31:00 GMT

This place is hidden behind a bunch of funky shops on Main St. If you happen to find it, it will be well worth the search! We used to go there in high school and eat it outside in the gardens!

2 Stars: Cute atmosphere, tasty soups, customer service needs improvement (by ESwat)

ESwat — Tue, 09 Sep 2008 02:00:00 GMT

After a 2 hour incredible hike along the beach trail of Half Moon Bay, my mother, daughter and I settled down to eat lunch at Casey's Cafe. My daughter had been here before and said it was a bit pricey (it was), but the clam chowder was very good (it was). After using the bathroom, (it was very cute! ) I found my party seated. It took at least10 minutes of looking around with our menu's down for our waitress to come take our order, there were only 2 other tables in the restaurant.

Drinks were served in a timely fashion. A bread basket came 15 minutes later after I got up to find our waitress and inquired about our soups and salads. We were quite hungry from the hike. She said it was coming. About 5-10 minutes later our meals arrived, a few minutes later the soups were served. A bit backwards I believe!

Mom's shrimp quesidilla and lobster bisque were excellent, hats off to the chef, as was my daughters burger and fries plate. My mini quiche and fruit were ok. The quiche had too much crust and not enough quiche and the fruit was canned melons and pineapple.

The waitress was distracted and unattentive, food was good for the most part.

4 Stars: Excellent Service (by Danielle S.)

Danielle S. — Sat, 30 Aug 2008 13:04:00 GMT

Excellent service and food is what you will get at Casey's Cafe on Main street. The fresh ingredients were so good. The soup tasted very home made. I would go back again to enjoy this nice casual dining experience.