I don't really see what the big deal is about Papyrus. Yes it does occasionally have some nice things that you can't find elsewhere, but their prices are outrageous. I went to browse their wedding invitations and the prices were ridiculous. Everything was so overpriced and the quality wasn't even that good. Plus they have a limited selection on almost all of their merchandice. Very disappointing.
You can always depend on a Papyrus store to have some great cards, but this Papyrus is on the small side and has a smaller collection than normal. You can still expect the same high-quality stationary, but do not expect to have much to choose from. Their gift-wrapping options are especially limiting.