My wife and I have an almost four year old digital camera. Recently it started producing images with one pixel wide green lines displayed horizontally through the image. We luckily had about a month left on our 4 year Best Buy warranty so we brought the camera in for service. Best Buy sent it to Precision Camera to be repaired. A week passed and Precision Camera called to state the camera had physical damage and will not be covered under warranty. The cost will be $105.45 to repair a broken lens assembly.
I have two problems with that. First, the physical damage they are referring to is a dent as they called it near the side of the lens assembly. I agree there is accidental damage there, although a small ding would be a more appropriate description. Regardless, the dent has been there since a few weeks after we purchased the camera almost 4 years ago. The camera has successfully been in for service, and successfully serviced, twice with the same dent. It is not new damage, and the dent certainly has nothing to do with the problem we are currently having.
Second, their diagnosis is that the lens assembly is broken. The past two service trips were to fix a twice broken lens assembly. In both of those instances the camera lens would not retract back into the camera body and the pictures were blurry because the lens was not the proper distance from the sensor to focus. That is not the problem we are having at this time. The camera is recording one pixel wide green lines displayed horizontally onto the image. I'll admit that I am not a camera technician, but that sounds like the sensor problem to me, or possibly a power problem (sensor not getting enough juice to work correctly). One pixel wide lines through the image does NOT sound like a lens problem, I can not conceive a situation where a misaligned piece of glass or plastic would cause green lines to appear one pixel wide through the image. Even if you were to completely remove the lens assembly from the camera, it would still take pictures; they would just be very blurry and overexposed. However, they would not have one pixel wide green lines. My non-technician assumption is that their technician saw a dent near the side of the lens assembly and then refused to look any further. Again, the dent had nothing to do with our problem and has been there for almost four years.
Precision Camera in my opinion blew the diagnosis, and also went out of their way to find a reason not to fix the camera. I spoke with Evelyn, Stacie, and supervisor Miles regarding my case number 2096687. To their credit, all phone conversations were cordial by both parties. Miles was unable to find any previous records for the camera and claimed that it had not been repaired prior to this. Miles said they are the only service center used by Best Buy for camera repairs. I contacted Best Buy and they confirmed the only place cameras are sent for repair is Precision Camera. Best Buy was easily able to find paperwork for the first two trips to the service center, but explained that their hands were tied in regards to the current repair; the decision was singularly in the hands of Precision Camera. To Best Buys credit, they explained that they have had similar problems in the past and offered us a $50 credit towards a new camera in retribution. We decided to have the camera sent back un-repaired and we accepted the $50 credit for a new camera.
Best Buys overall performance was acceptable. They did make attempts to correct a situation that I was not pleased with. Best Buy agents and supervisors were very friendly. Precision Cameras overall performance was terrible. They were cordial and professional on the phone, but a bad diagnosis, excuse to not repair it, and claim that the camera had not previously been repaired left a very sour taste in my mouth.
Yes, it was an old camera, and yes it had a small dent near the lens assembly. But it was under warranty and in my opinion should have been repaired.
Posted 08/20/08 | Report Abuse
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?