American Pie Company

★★★★★
  • 29 CT-37

    Sherman, CT 06784

    Map & Directions
  • 860-350-0662

About American Pie Company

Hours
Mon. 8am - 3pm;Tue. - Thu., Sun. 7am - 8pm;Fri. - Sat. 7am - 9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Sherman:
Resultset_next

Putnam Diner & Restaurant

2600 Route 22 Patterson, AR

Resultset_next

McDonald's

2 Lake Ave Ext Danbury, CT

4.5 2
Hi! Sign in to let us know how American Pie Company was?
Write a Review
.

The little town of Sherman is as Americana as apple pie. How apt, since the in-house bakery serves up the best part of the meal--baked dessets like apple pie! The main seating area is clean and pristine, with about a dozen or more tables. There appears to be more seating upstairs, and there are tables on the outdoor patio. The staff is friendly and attentive.

The food was good to great, and inexpensive. The portions are more than adequate. I had the Yankee PotRoast open faced sandwich served with mashed potatoes, and could not quite finish it. (The dinner portion would likely have been an overkill for me.) I did, however, glean every tender, savory bit of PotRoast. The thick gravy is lightly seasoned with herbs, and really adds to the flavor of the meat. I would rate it "perfect", and would go there again for the PotRoast.

My wife had an open faced, roasted turkey sandwich. It was good, but not great. Certainly worth the modest price. I would order it if I wanted turkey, but would not drive there just to get that dish. (Try the Curtis House in Woodbury for fantastic turkey!) Running a fresh cooked turkey breast through a meat slicer sort of detracts from the taste, but certainly from the appearance of home cooked bird.

Save room for desert, because they have a bakery attached to the restaurant. You can choose from fresh baked pies and cakes, an I think there were some pudding-type deserts. The pie was very good, especially the crust. You definitely know you are eating home-made pie! We had stawberry-rubarb and apple pie, and it was a great finish to a delightful experience. I can't wait to try the peach-raspberry.

Meanwhile, I'm waiting for my meal to settle so I can sample the giant cookies we brought home from the bakery--peanut butter, shortbread, chocolate chip, and oatmeal raisin. A bonus for having a bakery on the way out! Enjoy!

2
★★★★☆

The little town of Sherman is as Americana as apple pie. How apt, since the in-house bakery serves up the best part of the meal--baked dessets like apple pie! The main seating area is clean and pristine, with about a dozen or more tables. There appears to be more seating upstairs, and there are tables on the outdoor patio. The staff is friendly and attentive.

The food was good to great, and inexpensive. The portions are more than adequate. I had the Yankee PotRoast open faced sandwich served with mashed potatoes, and could not quite finish it. (The dinner portion would likely have been an overkill for me.) I did, however, glean every tender, savory bit of PotRoast. The thick gravy is lightly seasoned with herbs, and really adds to the flavor of the meat. I would rate it "perfect", and would go there again for the PotRoast.

My wife had an open faced, roasted turkey sandwich. It was good, but not great. Certainly worth the modest price. I would order it if I wanted turkey, but would not drive there just to get that dish. (Try the Curtis House in Woodbury for fantastic turkey!) Running a fresh cooked turkey breast through a meat slicer sort of detracts from the taste, but certainly from the appearance of home cooked bird.

Save room for desert, because they have a bakery attached to the restaurant. You can choose from fresh baked pies and cakes, an I think there were some pudding-type deserts. The pie was very good, especially the crust. You definitely know you are eating home-made pie! We had stawberry-rubarb and apple pie, and it was a great finish to a delightful experience. I can't wait to try the peach-raspberry.

Meanwhile, I'm waiting for my meal to settle so I can sample the giant cookies we brought home from the bakery--peanut butter, shortbread, chocolate chip, and oatmeal raisin. A bonus for having a bakery on the way out! Enjoy!

Pros: Quaint town setting; clean, attractive dining; bakery attached.

Cons: Limited menu, but diverse and adequate

.

POT ROAST, MEATLOAF, APPLE PIE- THIS PLACE IS GOOD OLD AMERICAN FARE. THE FOOD TASTES LIKE IT IS HOMEMADE. VERY WIDE VARIETY ON MENU TO PLEASE EVEN THE PICKIEST EATER. A LITTLE OUT OF THE WAY BUT IT IS A VERY NICE RIDE. LARGE DINING AREA IS FAMILY FRIENDLY. THERE IS A SEPARATE BAKERY WITHIN THE RESTAURANT WHERE YOU CAN PURCHASE HOMEMADE PIES, COOKIES, ETC.. CATERING IS ALSO AVAILABLE. THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE RESTAURANTS!

5
★★★★★

POT ROAST, MEATLOAF, APPLE PIE- THIS PLACE IS GOOD OLD AMERICAN FARE. THE FOOD TASTES LIKE IT IS HOMEMADE. VERY WIDE VARIETY ON MENU TO PLEASE EVEN THE PICKIEST EATER. A LITTLE OUT OF THE WAY BUT IT IS A VERY NICE RIDE. LARGE DINING AREA IS FAMILY FRIENDLY. THERE IS A SEPARATE BAKERY WITHIN THE RESTAURANT WHERE YOU CAN PURCHASE HOMEMADE PIES, COOKIES, ETC.. CATERING IS ALSO AVAILABLE. THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE RESTAURANTS!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used American Pie Company, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review