Barnacle Bill's Seafood House

★★★☆☆
  • 14 W Castillo Dr

    St Augustine, FL 32084

    Map & Directions
  • 904-824-3663

About Barnacle Bill's Seafood House

Hours
mon - ; tue - ; wed - ; thu - ; fri - ; sat - ; sun -

Food

Food
More choices in St Augustine:
Resultset_next

Oasis

4000 A1a S St Augustine, FL

Resultset_next

Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille

46 Avenida Menendez St Augustine, FL

3.1429 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Barnacle Bill's Seafood House was?
Write a Review
.

The shrimp and sides were excellent and the price for the shrimp special was great.

2
★★★★★

The shrimp and sides were excellent and the price for the shrimp special was great.

.

I have eaten here several times, but this time I was extremely disappointed. I guess the hint should of been that it was after 5 p.m. and the parking lot was not packed. Not like it used to be. There was usually a wait to get in here. The food was mediocre to say the least. Our waiter was not very attentive and never came back but once after we received our meal. The spinach casserole was strange. The next day my stomach was upset and I had to down a lot of Tums. I won't be going back here any time soon. I would of been better off going to Ourback or Longhorns and had fish there.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I have eaten here several times, but this time I was extremely disappointed. I guess the hint should of been that it was after 5 p.m. and the parking lot was not packed. Not like it used to be. There was usually a wait to get in here. The food was mediocre to say the least. Our waiter was not very attentive and never came back but once after we received our meal. The spinach casserole was strange. The next day my stomach was upset and I had to down a lot of Tums. I won't be going back here any time soon. I would of been better off going to Ourback or Longhorns and had fish there.

.

I was ready for some great seafood. I had been here about a year ago and it was pretty good. This time was terrible. I ordered the catch of the day (fried flounder). It came out and accually looked pretty good, but it was not. I tried to cut off a small piece and it would not even cut, they left the skin on and it was unediable. Tried to scrape the fish apart and it was so small of a piece that there was not much fish left to eat. The waiter was not that great either. Never came back to fill our drinks. We use to get a small basket of bread the last time, This time no bread. So for $18.00 I got about 4 bites of fish, 1 baked potato and a small bowl of cole slaw that did not have any flavor. I give this place a 1 start this time. Hope they read this and improve.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I was ready for some great seafood. I had been here about a year ago and it was pretty good. This time was terrible. I ordered the catch of the day (fried flounder). It came out and accually looked pretty good, but it was not. I tried to cut off a small piece and it would not even cut, they left the skin on and it was unediable. Tried to scrape the fish apart and it was so small of a piece that there was not much fish left to eat. The waiter was not that great either. Never came back to fill our drinks. We use to get a small basket of bread the last time, This time no bread. So for $18.00 I got about 4 bites of fish, 1 baked potato and a small bowl of cole slaw that did not have any flavor. I give this place a 1 start this time. Hope they read this and improve.

.

We had a nice dinner here after church on a sunday night. The wait staff was friendly and i personally know some of the cooks and they have been dedicated to this facility for years!!! Dedicated staff means great food!!!

4
★★★★☆

We had a nice dinner here after church on a sunday night. The wait staff was friendly and i personally know some of the cooks and they have been dedicated to this facility for years!!! Dedicated staff means great food!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

When my mom comes to town this is where she request to go. We like the beach location near our house. It has a really nice atmosphere. I love the datil pepper shrimp and their homemade vegetable side items and hush puppies are very good.

5
★★★★★

When my mom comes to town this is where she request to go. We like the beach location near our house. It has a really nice atmosphere. I love the datil pepper shrimp and their homemade vegetable side items and hush puppies are very good.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Barnicles on Castillo is the best!!!!. I have been coming here since at least 1955. Service not always first rate. The new staff shows professionalism and appropriate courtesy.

2
★★★★★

Barnicles on Castillo is the best!!!!. I have been coming here since at least 1955. Service not always first rate. The new staff shows professionalism and appropriate courtesy.

.

Was there 2 weeks ago it was terrible the breading on the scallops was like eating hush puppies (where is th scallops? ) baked tatter was made more than 3 hours before... When I told the waiter he said with a attitude we can make some more ..... I had other plans when I emailed the company they said' it has always been this way... I do not think so I reported them to Better Bunness Bureau for not refunding my money.... they have lost the quality and think the name will keep people coming ( I am a local )

0
★☆☆☆☆

Was there 2 weeks ago it was terrible the breading on the scallops was like eating hush puppies (where is th scallops? ) baked tatter was made more than 3 hours before... When I told the waiter he said with a attitude we can make some more ..... I had other plans when I emailed the company they said' it has always been this way... I do not think so I reported them to Better Bunness Bureau for not refunding my money.... they have lost the quality and think the name will keep people coming ( I am a local )

Cons: greasy bad food terrible service.... no refund

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Barnacle Bill's Seafood House, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review