Sam's St Johns Seafood Restaurant

★★★★★
  • 1464 Park Ave

    Orange Park, FL 32073

    Map & Directions
  • 904-269-1460

About Sam's St Johns Seafood Restaurant

Hours
Mon. - Thu., Sun. 11am - 9pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 10pm

Food

Food
More choices in Orange Park:
Resultset_next

Trent's Seafood

4553 120TH St Jacksonville, AL

Resultset_next

Red Lobster

32 Blanding Blvd. Orange Park, FL

4.8333 6
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sam's St Johns Seafood Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

Best shrimp! Clean. Hot,fresh seafood. This comment would be longer but we're here now and I'm using my IPhone to type this! : Got to get back to dinner!!

2
★★★★★

Best shrimp! Clean. Hot,fresh seafood. This comment would be longer but we're here now and I'm using my IPhone to type this! : Got to get back to dinner!!

.

Overall the is a terrific seafood restaurant. Mahi is great. Shrimp are terrific. Oysters are always fresh. Side dishes are great. Love the creamy cheese grits and southern style green beans. But we eat at Sam's on Wednesday's when they bring crab legs to your table until you are ready to burst. Served with authentic butter melted to perfection, it is gourmet heavan. Servers are the best in Jacksonville. Everyone is happy, and they treat you like a favorite relative popping in for dinner. Just plan to take off from work early and arrive at 5:00; otherwise you will be stuck waiting in line.

2
★★★★★

Overall the is a terrific seafood restaurant. Mahi is great. Shrimp are terrific. Oysters are always fresh. Side dishes are great. Love the creamy cheese grits and southern style green beans. But we eat at Sam's on Wednesday's when they bring crab legs to your table until you are ready to burst. Served with authentic butter melted to perfection, it is gourmet heavan. Servers are the best in Jacksonville. Everyone is happy, and they treat you like a favorite relative popping in for dinner. Just plan to take off from work early and arrive at 5:00; otherwise you will be stuck waiting in line.

Pros: Great seafood - crab legs are terrific

Cons: Not much choice for dessert

.

This has been one of our favorite places for years. It has a very casual and family-friendly atmosphere, and the low staff turnover means you see familiar faces time after time. They offer lunch portions and prices for Sunday dinner, if you choose, but these portions are enough for anyone in my opinion. Try the cheese grits; they're usually a very good side dish. Sam's can be a bit crowded and noisy right after church, as it is a popular spot at that time. Summary: decent seafood, good (informal) service, and reasonable prices. If I were as free with the stars as some reviewers are, I'd give it 5. (BTW, someone erred in putting this in the "fast food/takeout" category. They do offer take out, but this is not fast food.)

4
★★★★☆

This has been one of our favorite places for years. It has a very casual and family-friendly atmosphere, and the low staff turnover means you see familiar faces time after time. They offer lunch portions and prices for Sunday dinner, if you choose, but these portions are enough for anyone in my opinion. Try the cheese grits; they're usually a very good side dish. Sam's can be a bit crowded and noisy right after church, as it is a popular spot at that time. Summary: decent seafood, good (informal) service, and reasonable prices. If I were as free with the stars as some reviewers are, I'd give it 5. (BTW, someone erred in putting this in the "fast food/takeout" category. They do offer take out, but this is not fast food.)

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

YOU CAN TELL IT'S GOING TO BE GOOD BY THE LINE OUT THE FRONT DOOR. BUT DON'T LET IT FOOL YOU, THEY GET YOU IN QUICKLY!! The service has always been very personable and quick. There's something for everyone. To start off with, I like their Blooming onion. It is a breaded deep fried onion served with a special sauce that is yummy. I personally love the lightly blackened, grilled mahi, salmon, or grouper. They're grilled without drying them out and with a light amount of blackening seasoning and lemon butter. Somethimes I get the fried shrimp and it is delicious also. I think that's what they're known for...their fried food. It is really light, not heavy. They say it's because they fry in peanut oil and bread very lightly. The hush puppies are sweet and have onions in them. They make their cole-slaw home made. Their cheese grits are creamy and very flavorful. Not every time, but when I can I will get a piece of their homemade penut butter pie. Yum-Yum. It's one of my favorite places to eat!

2
★★★★★

YOU CAN TELL IT'S GOING TO BE GOOD BY THE LINE OUT THE FRONT DOOR. BUT DON'T LET IT FOOL YOU, THEY GET YOU IN QUICKLY!! The service has always been very personable and quick. There's something for everyone. To start off with, I like their Blooming onion. It is a breaded deep fried onion served with a special sauce that is yummy. I personally love the lightly blackened, grilled mahi, salmon, or grouper. They're grilled without drying them out and with a light amount of blackening seasoning and lemon butter. Somethimes I get the fried shrimp and it is delicious also. I think that's what they're known for...their fried food. It is really light, not heavy. They say it's because they fry in peanut oil and bread very lightly. The hush puppies are sweet and have onions in them. They make their cole-slaw home made. Their cheese grits are creamy and very flavorful. Not every time, but when I can I will get a piece of their homemade penut butter pie. Yum-Yum. It's one of my favorite places to eat!

Pros: Delicious Food, Fast Service, Family Restaurant

Cons: Alittle small for Very Large Parties

.

This was my first trip to a real seafood restaurant (red lobster doesn't count) since re-locating to the Jacksonville area. Don't get me wrong, I love seafood and had all my favorite restaurants mapped out in my head when I lived up north. However, I've been a little hesitant to try any since I been here. I must say Sam's has set a very high standard for me as far as seafood restaurants in this area are concerned. The food was great. Everything was fresh and perfectly seasoned. If your looking for a good ole fish fry the seafood combo is for you. Plenty for two? Thats an understatement. In fact the portions for everything we tried were huge. The restaurant is small and cozy with plenty of parking. Even on a Saturday night when the place was packed there was only a 25 minute wait for a table. The service was excellent to say the least. Sounds too good to be true? I'm not finished yet. I was also very impressed by the reasonable prices. Considering the size of the portions, the quality and taste as well as the great service, Sam's is definitely a keeper for me. See you next week Sam!

2
★★★★★

This was my first trip to a real seafood restaurant (red lobster doesn't count) since re-locating to the Jacksonville area. Don't get me wrong, I love seafood and had all my favorite restaurants mapped out in my head when I lived up north. However, I've been a little hesitant to try any since I been here. I must say Sam's has set a very high standard for me as far as seafood restaurants in this area are concerned. The food was great. Everything was fresh and perfectly seasoned. If your looking for a good ole fish fry the seafood combo is for you. Plenty for two? Thats an understatement. In fact the portions for everything we tried were huge. The restaurant is small and cozy with plenty of parking. Even on a Saturday night when the place was packed there was only a 25 minute wait for a table. The service was excellent to say the least. Sounds too good to be true? I'm not finished yet. I was also very impressed by the reasonable prices. Considering the size of the portions, the quality and taste as well as the great service, Sam's is definitely a keeper for me. See you next week Sam!

Pros: Food, Prices, Service, Parking

Cons: Wish I didn't get full so fast

.

This is a wonderful little seafood restaurant located on Highway 17 in Orange Park. It can be very busy, so plan on a small wait before being seated. After being seated, the server is always prompt and polite. We love to get the Plenty for Two platter, although it is really plenty for three. The food is great. My kids love this restaurant, as does the rest of my family!

2
★★★★★

This is a wonderful little seafood restaurant located on Highway 17 in Orange Park. It can be very busy, so plan on a small wait before being seated. After being seated, the server is always prompt and polite. We love to get the Plenty for Two platter, although it is really plenty for three. The food is great. My kids love this restaurant, as does the rest of my family!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sam's St Johns Seafood Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review