Michael R Mc Carty's Rstrnt

★★★★☆
  • 50 Cocoanut Row

    Palm Beach, FL 33480

    Map & Directions
  • 561-659-1899

About Michael R Mc Carty's Rstrnt

Hours
Mon. - Sun. 11:30am - 1am

Food

Food
More choices in Palm Beach:
Resultset_next

Ocean Grill at the Breakers

1cSouth County Road Palm Beach, FL

Resultset_next

Ruth's Chris Steak House

661 U.S. Highway 1 North Palm Beach, FL

3.5 2
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Michael R Mc Carty's Rstrnt was?
Write a Review
.

One on my favez in the area.
My mother and i go there every couple weeks for brunch.
We are the ultimate brunchers!
I usually take the Bagel with smoked Salomon, and my mother takes the Eggs Benedict.
The service is always great, the place is spotless and the location is nice and very classy.

5
★★★★★

One on my favez in the area.
My mother and i go there every couple weeks for brunch.
We are the ultimate brunchers!
I usually take the Bagel with smoked Salomon, and my mother takes the Eggs Benedict.
The service is always great, the place is spotless and the location is nice and very classy.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Upon arrival at McCarty's, our party of 8 had to wait even though the restaurant was half empty. After being seated, our waiter, Alex, came and asked about drinks. One person ordered, another asked about a wine list (which should have been presented when Alex arrived at the table, or even as we were seated) and our waiter left to fill the 1 drink order and bring back the wine list, but never finished taking the drink orders from anyone else. He didn't return again for another 15 minutes to finish just taking drink orders. At this point, we had all figured out what we wanted for appetizers and dinner and we felt with our service starting off so poorly, we had better order everything now. For some reason, Alex seemed to have an attitude, perhaps he was just in a bad mood, perhaps he was supposed to leave and because a party of 8 came in, he had to stay...who knows, but he shouldn't have been taking it out on us. He was short and discourteous, even though we recognized that and everyone went out of their way to be light-hearted and make him more at ease. He definitely had an attitude for the entire evening and it was so obvious to everyone. We almost asked for a different waiter, which at the end of our evening, when Alex cleared the table and never came back to ask about coffee or dessert, we finally did ask for someone to come and just bring us our check. We had decided we didn't want to deal with his lack of service any longer. We went elsewhere for after dinner drinks and dessert.

This restaurant is far from inexpensive and for it's location on Palm Beach and the prices on the menu, I expected more on the service side. When you go to a restaurant on the Island of Palm Beach, you expect exceptional service. Perhaps this was a fluke, but I can't say that I will recommend this restaurant, nor give them a 2nd chance. One of the couples at our table has had a previous bad experience at this restaurant and that alone is good enough for me to not want to give them a 2nd chance.

Go ahead and try it for yourself. Again, perhaps Alex was just having a bad night. Request someone else for your waiter. I hope you have a better experience.

2
★★☆☆☆

Upon arrival at McCarty's, our party of 8 had to wait even though the restaurant was half empty. After being seated, our waiter, Alex, came and asked about drinks. One person ordered, another asked about a wine list (which should have been presented when Alex arrived at the table, or even as we were seated) and our waiter left to fill the 1 drink order and bring back the wine list, but never finished taking the drink orders from anyone else. He didn't return again for another 15 minutes to finish just taking drink orders. At this point, we had all figured out what we wanted for appetizers and dinner and we felt with our service starting off so poorly, we had better order everything now. For some reason, Alex seemed to have an attitude, perhaps he was just in a bad mood, perhaps he was supposed to leave and because a party of 8 came in, he had to stay...who knows, but he shouldn't have been taking it out on us. He was short and discourteous, even though we recognized that and everyone went out of their way to be light-hearted and make him more at ease. He definitely had an attitude for the entire evening and it was so obvious to everyone. We almost asked for a different waiter, which at the end of our evening, when Alex cleared the table and never came back to ask about coffee or dessert, we finally did ask for someone to come and just bring us our check. We had decided we didn't want to deal with his lack of service any longer. We went elsewhere for after dinner drinks and dessert.

This restaurant is far from inexpensive and for it's location on Palm Beach and the prices on the menu, I expected more on the service side. When you go to a restaurant on the Island of Palm Beach, you expect exceptional service. Perhaps this was a fluke, but I can't say that I will recommend this restaurant, nor give them a 2nd chance. One of the couples at our table has had a previous bad experience at this restaurant and that alone is good enough for me to not want to give them a 2nd chance.

Go ahead and try it for yourself. Again, perhaps Alex was just having a bad night. Request someone else for your waiter. I hope you have a better experience.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Michael R Mc Carty's Rstrnt, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review