Amici Italian Restaurant

★★★★★
  • 1915 A1a S Ste B

    St Augustine, FL 32080

    Map & Directions
  • 904-461-0102

About Amici Italian Restaurant

Hours
Mon. - Wed., Sun. 11am - 9:30pm;Thu. - Sat. 11am - 10:30pm

Food

Food
More choices in St Augustine:
Resultset_next

Benito's Pizza & Pastabilities

180 Vilano Rd St Augustine, FL

Resultset_next

CiCi's Pizza

115 Jenkins St 101 St. Augustine, FL

4.5 2
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Amici Italian Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

We passed Amici?s and decided to give them a try. I wouldn?t say that it is fine dining, but a little bit better then casual. However, they do have a room for banquets.
We tried the fried Calamari appetizer which had a good taste and was not all rubbery. I don?t like tomatoes so I am not a big fan of tomato sauces, but I really liked the red sauce that came with the Calamari.
My husband had the Capellini Di Mare. He absolutely loved it. He was too stuffed to eat the whole thing, but he didn?t want to ruin it by bringing home left overs and reheating it in the microwave so he went ahead and ate the whole thing. I had the Al Forno which was cooked perfectly. However, it was too much for me to finish. I received the broccoli soup as a side item. I could tell that it was made there and not from a package or can. As another side I received the zucchini with their red sauce. It doesn?t sound very good and again even though I don?t care for tomato sauces this was excellent. Since I couldn?t finish the steak I took it with me and asked for some of their red sauce to eat with it. The steak was cooked rare enough that when I re-cook it with the red sauce it will still be great with the blue cheese they add on it and I don?t even like left overs.
They obviously take pride in their dishes and make everything from scratch. It was also better then any chain I have ever been to. I wouldn?t say this is a family restaurant, but a nice place for adults to get together and have a great meal. This is a nice restaurant, but not really the type of place you would go to if you are looking for a very upscale place that does extra request like bringing you flowers. They also don?t have valet parking. However, if you are looking for a nicer place with great food and attentive service then this is the place for you. Even though it is pricier then a lot of places at about $20- $25 an entree I would still pay the extra money to eat here again.

2
★★★★★

We passed Amici?s and decided to give them a try. I wouldn?t say that it is fine dining, but a little bit better then casual. However, they do have a room for banquets.
We tried the fried Calamari appetizer which had a good taste and was not all rubbery. I don?t like tomatoes so I am not a big fan of tomato sauces, but I really liked the red sauce that came with the Calamari.
My husband had the Capellini Di Mare. He absolutely loved it. He was too stuffed to eat the whole thing, but he didn?t want to ruin it by bringing home left overs and reheating it in the microwave so he went ahead and ate the whole thing. I had the Al Forno which was cooked perfectly. However, it was too much for me to finish. I received the broccoli soup as a side item. I could tell that it was made there and not from a package or can. As another side I received the zucchini with their red sauce. It doesn?t sound very good and again even though I don?t care for tomato sauces this was excellent. Since I couldn?t finish the steak I took it with me and asked for some of their red sauce to eat with it. The steak was cooked rare enough that when I re-cook it with the red sauce it will still be great with the blue cheese they add on it and I don?t even like left overs.
They obviously take pride in their dishes and make everything from scratch. It was also better then any chain I have ever been to. I wouldn?t say this is a family restaurant, but a nice place for adults to get together and have a great meal. This is a nice restaurant, but not really the type of place you would go to if you are looking for a very upscale place that does extra request like bringing you flowers. They also don?t have valet parking. However, if you are looking for a nicer place with great food and attentive service then this is the place for you. Even though it is pricier then a lot of places at about $20- $25 an entree I would still pay the extra money to eat here again.

Pros: Great food, attentive service, not a place for kids.

Cons: The entrance was at the back door; not the fanciest place, but nice.

.

We stopped at this little restaurant on a whim, and were pleasntly surprised by the quality of the food, the great prices and the pleasant atmosphere. Dimly lit, with comfy chairs and friendly staff, this restaurant is inviting, to say the least. The food was excellent, and the cappucino was unusually good. We will definitely eat here again.
-This restaurant is smoker-friendly; they have a little covered porch outside to allow the smokers to smoke and eat in privacy, without offending the non-smokers.

4
★★★★☆

We stopped at this little restaurant on a whim, and were pleasntly surprised by the quality of the food, the great prices and the pleasant atmosphere. Dimly lit, with comfy chairs and friendly staff, this restaurant is inviting, to say the least. The food was excellent, and the cappucino was unusually good. We will definitely eat here again.
-This restaurant is smoker-friendly; they have a little covered porch outside to allow the smokers to smoke and eat in privacy, without offending the non-smokers.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Amici Italian Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review