Johnny's New York Style Pizza

★★★★☆
  • 1810 Cheshire Bridge Rd NE

    Atlanta, GA 30324

    Map & Directions
  • 404-874-8304

About Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Categories
  • Pizza Restaurants
  • Restaurants
  • Catering Companies
Details
  • Carry Out
Hours
M-Sa 11am-11pm, Su 4pm-10pm
Special Offer
Order takeout today!
Emails
  • nichols71@gmail.com
Keywords
  • pizza
  • pizza restaurant
  • restaurant
  • delivery
  • take out
  • catering
  • pizza delivery
  • food delivery
  • pizza near me
  • pizzeria
  • restaurant near me
  • pizza place
  • carry out
  • caterer
Payment Options
  • American Express
  • Cash
  • Discover
  • MasterCard
  • Visa
Languages
  • EN

Food

Food
More choices in Atlanta:
Resultset_next

Shorty's

2884-B N Druid Hills Rd Atlanta, GA

Resultset_next

Mellow Mushroom

1679 Lavista Rd NE Atlanta, GA

3.5556 9
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Johnny's New York Style Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Johnny's on Cheshire Bridge has been a fixture on this street for over 30 years, and it still serves the best pizza in town! I've eaten at many other Johnny's pizzas, but this one has the best pizza. My family loves to eat there. The kids even eat the crust that they usually leave from other restaurants. The crust is hand tossed. You can actually watch your pizza being cooked in front of you, so you know it's fresh. The wait staff makes you feel like you're family. I'd recommend this place to anyone, and I usually do!

2
★★★★★

Johnny's on Cheshire Bridge has been a fixture on this street for over 30 years, and it still serves the best pizza in town! I've eaten at many other Johnny's pizzas, but this one has the best pizza. My family loves to eat there. The kids even eat the crust that they usually leave from other restaurants. The crust is hand tossed. You can actually watch your pizza being cooked in front of you, so you know it's fresh. The wait staff makes you feel like you're family. I'd recommend this place to anyone, and I usually do!

Pros: Relaxed atmosphere/ fun staff/ fantastic pizza

Cons: Small restaurant

.

I like that this is kind of a dive-y place to grab a slice, but truly the pizza is sub-par, like almost everywhere in Atlanta. Droopy dough with tastless canned sauce and just OK cheese. Seems to do a brisk business...I guess because there arent a lot of options in the area.

1
★★☆☆☆

I like that this is kind of a dive-y place to grab a slice, but truly the pizza is sub-par, like almost everywhere in Atlanta. Droopy dough with tastless canned sauce and just OK cheese. Seems to do a brisk business...I guess because there arent a lot of options in the area.

.

The pizza was good and hot. I enjoy ordering a sub sandwich- turkey, cheese, light lettuce, bell pepper on dry wheat. Everything is always fresh how I like them.

5
★★★★★

The pizza was good and hot. I enjoy ordering a sub sandwich- turkey, cheese, light lettuce, bell pepper on dry wheat. Everything is always fresh how I like them.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

we live around the corner from this place and waited patiently for them to open. then we waited patiently for them to get their beer and wine license... for 2 months. when they could finally serve beer i couldnt get any of my favorites because they aparently dont serve budweiser products. why? i gleamed from a server that the owners/managers/whoever aparently had some personal spat with the rep and now they are boycotting them altogether. really? we all have to suffer because you cant be grown up to do business?
on top of this, they aparently deliver now, but to our apartment complex around the corner? no why? i dont know. the person on the phone just said it had something to do with security. whatever that means.
if it weren for these things, me and my family might still eat there. the pizza is decent and the service, when available has been good. its really a shame that this place seems to be under the operation of nimrods because it could have had potential. however, i think its probably a sinking ship and i'll just keep eating at felini's on howell mill until a better place opens where this johnny's used to be.

0
★☆☆☆☆

we live around the corner from this place and waited patiently for them to open. then we waited patiently for them to get their beer and wine license... for 2 months. when they could finally serve beer i couldnt get any of my favorites because they aparently dont serve budweiser products. why? i gleamed from a server that the owners/managers/whoever aparently had some personal spat with the rep and now they are boycotting them altogether. really? we all have to suffer because you cant be grown up to do business?
on top of this, they aparently deliver now, but to our apartment complex around the corner? no why? i dont know. the person on the phone just said it had something to do with security. whatever that means.
if it weren for these things, me and my family might still eat there. the pizza is decent and the service, when available has been good. its really a shame that this place seems to be under the operation of nimrods because it could have had potential. however, i think its probably a sinking ship and i'll just keep eating at felini's on howell mill until a better place opens where this johnny's used to be.

Pros: decent pizza for johnn'ys

Cons: incompetent ownership

.

Soggy pizza that is essentially a slab of bread with a pound of cheese piled in the middle. The large cheese pizza I picked up was coated on the bottom with the charred remnants of the previous fifteen pizza's. I was starving so I had to eat one slice. The remainder went into the trash.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Soggy pizza that is essentially a slab of bread with a pound of cheese piled in the middle. The large cheese pizza I picked up was coated on the bottom with the charred remnants of the previous fifteen pizza's. I was starving so I had to eat one slice. The remainder went into the trash.

Pros: Vey hip looking employees

Cons: Horrible pizza

.

This Johnny's may be small, but that gives it terrific character. For me this will always be the best Johnny's Pizza in Atlanta. There are a few Johnny's around today but none are better or more Atlanta than this location. I know the sign may say New York pizza, but this is Atlanta pizza and it is unsurpassed.

2
★★★★☆

This Johnny's may be small, but that gives it terrific character. For me this will always be the best Johnny's Pizza in Atlanta. There are a few Johnny's around today but none are better or more Atlanta than this location. I know the sign may say New York pizza, but this is Atlanta pizza and it is unsurpassed.

.

Ordered a pizza from Johnny's today while doing a yard sale. Drove over to pick it up and it was ready just as stated. The pizza was great as usual and a few people who hadn't had Johnny's before were all impressed. Definitely good stuff here.

5
★★★★★

Ordered a pizza from Johnny's today while doing a yard sale. Drove over to pick it up and it was ready just as stated. The pizza was great as usual and a few people who hadn't had Johnny's before were all impressed. Definitely good stuff here.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

A true hole in the wall, but good pizza. Dress up to much, and you might feel like a bill collector in the middle of a dead beat convenation. Dine in or take out. Eat it up!

2
★★★★☆

A true hole in the wall, but good pizza. Dress up to much, and you might feel like a bill collector in the middle of a dead beat convenation. Dine in or take out. Eat it up!

.

I'm originally from Chicago so when I moved to ATL I was on the prowl for some good pizza. So far this Johnny's has been the best! While the place may look like a hole in the wall...the pizza is awesome. I recommend trying one with feta and banana peppers! The prices are awesome! I've also tried the subs which are tasty, and they are huge for the price you pay. I've tried other Johnny's pizzas, but for some reason this one remains the best! If you are looking for some really good pizza, check this place out!

2
★★★★★

I'm originally from Chicago so when I moved to ATL I was on the prowl for some good pizza. So far this Johnny's has been the best! While the place may look like a hole in the wall...the pizza is awesome. I recommend trying one with feta and banana peppers! The prices are awesome! I've also tried the subs which are tasty, and they are huge for the price you pay. I've tried other Johnny's pizzas, but for some reason this one remains the best! If you are looking for some really good pizza, check this place out!

Pros: Awesome food, awesome prices

Cons: looks a little scary from the outside, but don't worry....its all good!

Message from Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Looking for a pizza near you? Our pizza restaurant always makes all of our pizza from scratch with the freshest ingredients. We also provide other delicious Italian food such as pasta and calzones. And if you can't stay at our restaurant to enjoy your delicious pizza, you can always order for take-out or even delivery. So, give us a call today to enjoy your delicious pizza or order online!

Yext PowerListings

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Johnny's New York Style Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review