Carey Hilliard's Restaurant

★★★☆☆
  • 8410 Waters Ave

    Savannah, GA 31406

    Map & Directions
  • 912-355-2468

About Carey Hilliard's Restaurant

Hours
Sunday 12:00AM - 1:00AM 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Monday 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Tuesday 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Wednesday 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Thursday 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Friday 11:00AM - 11:45PM ,Saturday 12:00AM - 1:00AM 11:00AM - 11:45PM

Food

Food
More choices in Savannah:
Resultset_next

Love's Seafood Restaurant

6817 Basin Rd Savannah, GA

Resultset_next

Carey Hilliard's Restaurant

514 Us Highway 80 W Savannah, GA

3.25 4
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Carey Hilliard's Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

Don't waste your time or money
"Could have gotten better food at Capt. Dee's . Over Priced , poor quality , poor service, Small portions, . The only thing good was the Crab stew"

The location I tried was the Pooler , GA location may be different at others , But this one gives them all a black eye ,My family and I were on vacation in Savannah and wanted some good local seafood , but this was a true let down. Sure not fresh or local but tasted like spoiled frozen imported shrimp and scallops

0
★☆☆☆☆

Don't waste your time or money
"Could have gotten better food at Capt. Dee's . Over Priced , poor quality , poor service, Small portions, . The only thing good was the Crab stew"

The location I tried was the Pooler , GA location may be different at others , But this one gives them all a black eye ,My family and I were on vacation in Savannah and wanted some good local seafood , but this was a true let down. Sure not fresh or local but tasted like spoiled frozen imported shrimp and scallops

Pros: None

Cons: All foods

.

Bad News first--Avoid the BBQ at all costs! I have been going to CH for over 20 years, and at best their BBQ is average, nothing to brag about--in the last several years, at all the locations, I have found the BBQ to be stringy, tough, tasteless, pale and unappetizing. If it's included on club sandwich, it's bearable, but that's about it. Be careful with their shrimp, which often taste as if they've been swimming in a chlorine pool before cooking. Also, take a small first taste of their coleslaw because it has too often "gone around the bend", and I, as well as many others I know, have gotten sick from it. They also have a problem with overcooking their oysters. The flounder is OK, nice and crispy, but not much taste. The grouper fingers are thin, tasteless and not worth the trouble. The salad is ho-hum, unless you add the chicken fingers. Watch both their hotwings and fried chicken too, as they both have a tendency to be bloody and undercooked, especially the thighs--sorry to be gross, but the fact is, this has happened a lot.
GOOD NEWS--Their Brunswick stew over the years has remained tasty, thick and satisfying--forget the BBQ and just get a big bowl, along with their excellent, crispy, divine onion rings, which are freshly battered for each order and a real treat. Their chicken fingers are also golden, crispy and a delight for dinner or for kids, and their burger, though pretty simple, is good. My son enjoys their hamburger steak with onions, which is a filling and tasty dinner, and my husband says the turkey club is excellent, as well as the BBQ club. For the price, the steak is also a good deal, with onion rings or a bowl of the crab stew. For the most part, the hushpuppies are also good--sometimes we substitute them for fries or potato--crispy on the outside, tender on the inside.
A word on their tea--if you like supersweet tea, then you'll be happy here, otherwise, ask for half-sweet, half-unsweet.
The service is, in general, quite good, and I've found the wait staff usually attentive to your needs.

3
★★★☆☆

Bad News first--Avoid the BBQ at all costs! I have been going to CH for over 20 years, and at best their BBQ is average, nothing to brag about--in the last several years, at all the locations, I have found the BBQ to be stringy, tough, tasteless, pale and unappetizing. If it's included on club sandwich, it's bearable, but that's about it. Be careful with their shrimp, which often taste as if they've been swimming in a chlorine pool before cooking. Also, take a small first taste of their coleslaw because it has too often "gone around the bend", and I, as well as many others I know, have gotten sick from it. They also have a problem with overcooking their oysters. The flounder is OK, nice and crispy, but not much taste. The grouper fingers are thin, tasteless and not worth the trouble. The salad is ho-hum, unless you add the chicken fingers. Watch both their hotwings and fried chicken too, as they both have a tendency to be bloody and undercooked, especially the thighs--sorry to be gross, but the fact is, this has happened a lot.
GOOD NEWS--Their Brunswick stew over the years has remained tasty, thick and satisfying--forget the BBQ and just get a big bowl, along with their excellent, crispy, divine onion rings, which are freshly battered for each order and a real treat. Their chicken fingers are also golden, crispy and a delight for dinner or for kids, and their burger, though pretty simple, is good. My son enjoys their hamburger steak with onions, which is a filling and tasty dinner, and my husband says the turkey club is excellent, as well as the BBQ club. For the price, the steak is also a good deal, with onion rings or a bowl of the crab stew. For the most part, the hushpuppies are also good--sometimes we substitute them for fries or potato--crispy on the outside, tender on the inside.
A word on their tea--if you like supersweet tea, then you'll be happy here, otherwise, ask for half-sweet, half-unsweet.
The service is, in general, quite good, and I've found the wait staff usually attentive to your needs.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I love this place for their fried sea food and their BBQ sandwiches. I have not had a bad experience here. Their food has a special taste to it. I would certainly recommend.

4
★★★★☆

I love this place for their fried sea food and their BBQ sandwiches. I have not had a bad experience here. Their food has a special taste to it. I would certainly recommend.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Nothing comes close to the great food they have at this restaurant! My family and I love the down home southern taste of the food here. The kids love the menu!

5
★★★★★

Nothing comes close to the great food they have at this restaurant! My family and I love the down home southern taste of the food here. The kids love the menu!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Carey Hilliard's Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review