New York Prime

★★★★☆
  • 3424 Peachtree Rd Ne

    Atlanta, GA 30326

    Cross street: Lenox Road NE

    Map & Directions
  • 404-846-0644

About New York Prime

Categories
Details
Hours
Serving Mon—Sat • 5pm — 11pm (Bar opens at 4pm) Sunday 5pm —10pm (Bar opens at 4pm)

Food

Food
More choices in Atlanta:
Resultset_next

Houston's_peachtree, Atlanta

2166 Peachtree Rd NW Atlanta, GA

Resultset_next

Kevin Rathbun Steak

154 Krog St NE 200 Atlanta, GA

4.087 23
Hi! Sign in to let us know how New York Prime was?
Write a Review
.

The best steak and sides in Atlanta! The cheesy mashed potatoes and corn make my mouth water just thinking of them ...

3
★★★★★

The best steak and sides in Atlanta! The cheesy mashed potatoes and corn make my mouth water just thinking of them ...

.

A true dining experience. Great bar and bartenders. Waiters were knowledgeable and friendly. The steak was perfect as were the sides and dessert.

3
★★★★★

A true dining experience. Great bar and bartenders. Waiters were knowledgeable and friendly. The steak was perfect as were the sides and dessert.

.

I visited the NY Prime Atlanta last night to celebrate my 13th year anniversary with my wife and the experience was totally awful. I should have known from the start when the valet ask me to park my own car . We were early around 6:30 so

3
★★★★★

I visited the NY Prime Atlanta last night to celebrate my 13th year anniversary with my wife and the experience was totally awful. I should have known from the start when the valet ask me to park my own car . We were early around 6:30 so

.

I am completely mystified why some ??high-end? steak houses have embraced the ??Pittsburgh Style? cooking method in which they take excellent cuts of meat and char them beyond recognition. We were guests in a rather large party and we shocked that all of the steaks, regardless of how they were ordered (rare, medium, etc.) were served coal black with charred bits falling off on the plate. The rare and medium rare steaks were blood red raw on the inside and none of them were any warmer than room temperature. If we had not been guests most/all of us would have sent these back immediately. We had to cut the blackened crust off the outside and the partially cooked portions inside. Every plate I saw cleared contained piles of inedible burnt or raw meat. What an incredible waste.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I am completely mystified why some ??high-end? steak houses have embraced the ??Pittsburgh Style? cooking method in which they take excellent cuts of meat and char them beyond recognition. We were guests in a rather large party and we shocked that all of the steaks, regardless of how they were ordered (rare, medium, etc.) were served coal black with charred bits falling off on the plate. The rare and medium rare steaks were blood red raw on the inside and none of them were any warmer than room temperature. If we had not been guests most/all of us would have sent these back immediately. We had to cut the blackened crust off the outside and the partially cooked portions inside. Every plate I saw cleared contained piles of inedible burnt or raw meat. What an incredible waste.

.

Good Food and Place! Thank you for the crew and for all the service.My friends and I will always come back !

5
★★★★★

Good Food and Place! Thank you for the crew and for all the service.My friends and I will always come back !

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I tried NY Prime for the first time and was so disappointed I had to write a review. I ordered my NY Strip rare, and the server told me it would have a cold red center. First of all, when you're paying almost $50 for a steak, it should be kept at room temperature long enough to not be cold in the center even when served rare. But that wasn't the problem.

The server didn't tell me that the steak would be charred. It came out closer to Medium, and I had to send the steak back. Even then, they didn't ask me if I would like light or no charring, so they brought out another steak that was a bit redder in the center but so charred on the outside I had to cut off the outside and top and eat only the center. My date ordered his ribeye at Medium Well and loved it, so I guess if you like very well done steaks this might be ok, but for true steak lovers, it's a mistake.

The servers were efficient but not at all personable. The sides, appetizers, and wine were great, but I went hoping for a great steak. I should have gone to Hal's or Rathbun's.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I tried NY Prime for the first time and was so disappointed I had to write a review. I ordered my NY Strip rare, and the server told me it would have a cold red center. First of all, when you're paying almost $50 for a steak, it should be kept at room temperature long enough to not be cold in the center even when served rare. But that wasn't the problem.

The server didn't tell me that the steak would be charred. It came out closer to Medium, and I had to send the steak back. Even then, they didn't ask me if I would like light or no charring, so they brought out another steak that was a bit redder in the center but so charred on the outside I had to cut off the outside and top and eat only the center. My date ordered his ribeye at Medium Well and loved it, so I guess if you like very well done steaks this might be ok, but for true steak lovers, it's a mistake.

The servers were efficient but not at all personable. The sides, appetizers, and wine were great, but I went hoping for a great steak. I should have gone to Hal's or Rathbun's.

Pros: Live Jazz

Cons: Steaks Over Cooked...Twice

.

My family and I went to NYP on a last-minute whim after an event. It was early evening, and we were the first customers there. The bar staff was incredibly friendly, and we carried on a conversation with them as we had a round of drinks.
When we were being seated, we asked for a table out of the center area, and they quickly made the change. Our server was a young woman who put up with a lot from my rather particular father-in-law, and she handled it with grace and humor. The atmosphere was friendly yet elegant, and the service impeccable.

The only negative of the night was the way they cook steaks--apparently, they intentionally char them. Perhaps some people enjoy eating a $40 steak that is burnt, but my family was not a fan. My husband sent his back, and the server handled it with aplomb, and quickly had a new steak for him, prepared without char (and a new side dish).

Overall, the service and willingness to please was tremendous, and I was very impressed.

2
★★★★★

My family and I went to NYP on a last-minute whim after an event. It was early evening, and we were the first customers there. The bar staff was incredibly friendly, and we carried on a conversation with them as we had a round of drinks.
When we were being seated, we asked for a table out of the center area, and they quickly made the change. Our server was a young woman who put up with a lot from my rather particular father-in-law, and she handled it with grace and humor. The atmosphere was friendly yet elegant, and the service impeccable.

The only negative of the night was the way they cook steaks--apparently, they intentionally char them. Perhaps some people enjoy eating a $40 steak that is burnt, but my family was not a fan. My husband sent his back, and the server handled it with aplomb, and quickly had a new steak for him, prepared without char (and a new side dish).

Overall, the service and willingness to please was tremendous, and I was very impressed.

Pros: great staff, amazing service

Cons: charring the steak is normal

.

This is the spot for fine dining with the best steak in town! A bit pricey but worth the money. Great service guaranteed.

5
★★★★★

This is the spot for fine dining with the best steak in town! A bit pricey but worth the money. Great service guaranteed.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I was first introduced to New York Prime by an associate while at a business dinner. I entertain a lot and the meaning of "customer service" means everything to me. I was absolutely amazed with the people, food and atmosphere at NYP! The timing of the staff is PERFECT and the conversation never drifts towards, "where's that waiter"?
The food is absolutely fantastic!! I have eaten steak and all types of food all over the country and I can say without a doubt this is the BEST of every world.
To top off the evening I asked for a tour on my very first visit and much to my surprise they gave it to me. I now visit this establishment whenever I can with clients or for just a simple evening with my wife. They staff learns you name and the owner is one of kind. Never will you have a guy that owns the joint at a 5 star establishment take your jacket!
Trust me when I say if you haven't eaten here then you haven't had a great meal yet.

2
★★★★★

I was first introduced to New York Prime by an associate while at a business dinner. I entertain a lot and the meaning of "customer service" means everything to me. I was absolutely amazed with the people, food and atmosphere at NYP! The timing of the staff is PERFECT and the conversation never drifts towards, "where's that waiter"?
The food is absolutely fantastic!! I have eaten steak and all types of food all over the country and I can say without a doubt this is the BEST of every world.
To top off the evening I asked for a tour on my very first visit and much to my surprise they gave it to me. I now visit this establishment whenever I can with clients or for just a simple evening with my wife. They staff learns you name and the owner is one of kind. Never will you have a guy that owns the joint at a 5 star establishment take your jacket!
Trust me when I say if you haven't eaten here then you haven't had a great meal yet.

Pros: Everything about this place is GREAT!

Cons: I don't get there often enough

.

Have eaten here many times. Always for a special occasion.

Service was as expected. They are not always the nicest but are on top of things.

Food was as expected. Get the Steak Fries. They are amazingly huge.

It was not overly crowded as it has been in the past. Not sure if that is a sign or just the economy.

2
★★★★☆

Have eaten here many times. Always for a special occasion.

Service was as expected. They are not always the nicest but are on top of things.

Food was as expected. Get the Steak Fries. They are amazingly huge.

It was not overly crowded as it has been in the past. Not sure if that is a sign or just the economy.

Pros: It feels like a New York Steakhouse

Cons: Did they raise prices

.

Don't let these snooty people make you think a restaurant that allows smoking somehow deserves 1 or 2 stars. I am a non smoker and I did not hesitate giving New York Prime 5 stars. Here's why;

My wife and I recently dined at New York Prime. I was a little shocked when I first walked in because my initial impression was that this was a high class, formal restaurant (based on the menu prices and the lambhorgini that was valet parked outside). The place was actually load and smokey like a bar. But that was fine with me. My wife best summed it up when she said it was like an 'old gentleman's club' that had a sophisticated Frat type atmosphere. We were greeted at the door by who we believe was one of the owners or managers who immediately took our coats. The place was packed and everyone including the guest were friendly.

The food was awesome. I had the bone in ribeye with baked potato and my wife had the garlic chicken. Both very juicy and filled with flavor. We must have had about 3 or 4 different servers and they all were not only knowledgeable about the menu and wines but also had a keen sense of humor and made us laugh. They made sure we were happy with our food. My wife got a wine she didn't like, and the bartender immediately brought her a different type that she loved (she ordered two glasses). I had two rum and cokes and the bartender made them exactly how I like them. This made the evening go way better then anticipated.

We had an amazing first time experience at New York Prime and I would highly recommend it to anyone.

2
★★★★★

Don't let these snooty people make you think a restaurant that allows smoking somehow deserves 1 or 2 stars. I am a non smoker and I did not hesitate giving New York Prime 5 stars. Here's why;

My wife and I recently dined at New York Prime. I was a little shocked when I first walked in because my initial impression was that this was a high class, formal restaurant (based on the menu prices and the lambhorgini that was valet parked outside). The place was actually load and smokey like a bar. But that was fine with me. My wife best summed it up when she said it was like an 'old gentleman's club' that had a sophisticated Frat type atmosphere. We were greeted at the door by who we believe was one of the owners or managers who immediately took our coats. The place was packed and everyone including the guest were friendly.

The food was awesome. I had the bone in ribeye with baked potato and my wife had the garlic chicken. Both very juicy and filled with flavor. We must have had about 3 or 4 different servers and they all were not only knowledgeable about the menu and wines but also had a keen sense of humor and made us laugh. They made sure we were happy with our food. My wife got a wine she didn't like, and the bartender immediately brought her a different type that she loved (she ordered two glasses). I had two rum and cokes and the bartender made them exactly how I like them. This made the evening go way better then anticipated.

We had an amazing first time experience at New York Prime and I would highly recommend it to anyone.

Pros: Great Food and Service

Cons: Prices are high, but expected for a buckhead steakhouse

.

I have been by this restaurant, dozens of times since it has been open. Last night, a business associate was staying next door at the Ritz Carlton Buckhead. My friend insisted I join him here for dinner. As to why he did not ask me where to dine in Buckhead for steak, is beyond me. He is from NYC. Buckhead has many excellent steakhouse fine dining destinations. I was hesitant, but gladly went along. The first thing I noticed, was the smell of strong cigar smoke. I'm not a smoker, and well you know the rest. The menu read nicely, but at these prices, it had better be darn good. I opted for one of those 3-4 lobsters, I usually order across the street, at a well-known NYC steakhouse. The presentation was terrible, Why did my server forget the drawn butter? And my friend's steak was overcooked. I just smiled, and thought about all the other really great steakhouses in Buckhead. Our waiters attitude, was that of someone serving a salesman at an auto convention. I dine out several times a week, and I will never come back here, even if my friend is from New York!

1
★★★☆☆

I have been by this restaurant, dozens of times since it has been open. Last night, a business associate was staying next door at the Ritz Carlton Buckhead. My friend insisted I join him here for dinner. As to why he did not ask me where to dine in Buckhead for steak, is beyond me. He is from NYC. Buckhead has many excellent steakhouse fine dining destinations. I was hesitant, but gladly went along. The first thing I noticed, was the smell of strong cigar smoke. I'm not a smoker, and well you know the rest. The menu read nicely, but at these prices, it had better be darn good. I opted for one of those 3-4 lobsters, I usually order across the street, at a well-known NYC steakhouse. The presentation was terrible, Why did my server forget the drawn butter? And my friend's steak was overcooked. I just smiled, and thought about all the other really great steakhouses in Buckhead. Our waiters attitude, was that of someone serving a salesman at an auto convention. I dine out several times a week, and I will never come back here, even if my friend is from New York!

Pros: It Was Near My Friend's Hotel!

Cons: Over-Hyped, Over-Priced Buckhead Steakhouse! Service?

.

I picked out New York Prime for our office dinner. There were 18 of us and we all agreed that it was one of the best meals we had ever eaten. They served us two large trays of appetizers that were delicious. It had oysters, lumb crab, crab claws and shrimp. Then along with our steaks and side dishes we were all stuffed. Everything was cooked to perfection. I will recommend this resturant to everyone. Not only was the food and atmosphere perfect but the custmer service was at the top of the chart. We had two waiters the entire time and we never wanted for anything. Charles was one of them and I sorry but the young ladies name I can't remember something like Kalen. We will be back. A great time had by all.

2
★★★★★

I picked out New York Prime for our office dinner. There were 18 of us and we all agreed that it was one of the best meals we had ever eaten. They served us two large trays of appetizers that were delicious. It had oysters, lumb crab, crab claws and shrimp. Then along with our steaks and side dishes we were all stuffed. Everything was cooked to perfection. I will recommend this resturant to everyone. Not only was the food and atmosphere perfect but the custmer service was at the top of the chart. We had two waiters the entire time and we never wanted for anything. Charles was one of them and I sorry but the young ladies name I can't remember something like Kalen. We will be back. A great time had by all.

Pros: Food and customers service

Cons: Smokey bar area

.

DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE unless you are a smoker or don't mind the smoke. This place was awful!!! My friends got sick and threw up because of the poor ventilation due to the cigar and cigarette smoke! The bar was right next to the dining area and you can see how smoky the place was, it was suffocating! It didn't matter where you sat, the smoke was overwhelming! NY Prime made a huge mistake by allowing smoking because it brought the classiness of this overpriced place way way down! The appetizers were excellent, but the lobster (3 pound minimum) was over priced! $70 for a lobster that the waiter had to clean for us on the cart because it wouldn't fit on the table with other dishes. The restrooms were nice, however, you'd have to make your way through the thick smoke just to get there! The wait staff was excellent. The food wasn't anything to brag about.

0
★☆☆☆☆

DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE unless you are a smoker or don't mind the smoke. This place was awful!!! My friends got sick and threw up because of the poor ventilation due to the cigar and cigarette smoke! The bar was right next to the dining area and you can see how smoky the place was, it was suffocating! It didn't matter where you sat, the smoke was overwhelming! NY Prime made a huge mistake by allowing smoking because it brought the classiness of this overpriced place way way down! The appetizers were excellent, but the lobster (3 pound minimum) was over priced! $70 for a lobster that the waiter had to clean for us on the cart because it wouldn't fit on the table with other dishes. The restrooms were nice, however, you'd have to make your way through the thick smoke just to get there! The wait staff was excellent. The food wasn't anything to brag about.

Pros: great appetizers

Cons: too expensive for "bar food"

.

Restaurant had a great atmosphere and overall the food was very good. The petit filet I ordered was not the best steak I've ever had but we both thought that the wine, salads and side items we ordered were exceptional. The caesar salad was amazing as well as the creamed corn. We had a fun night and most of the meal was great....but if you're going purely for the steaks, this is not the best I've eaten.

2
★★★★☆

Restaurant had a great atmosphere and overall the food was very good. The petit filet I ordered was not the best steak I've ever had but we both thought that the wine, salads and side items we ordered were exceptional. The caesar salad was amazing as well as the creamed corn. We had a fun night and most of the meal was great....but if you're going purely for the steaks, this is not the best I've eaten.

Pros: good atmosphere, good wine list

Cons: parking

.

New York Prime is definitely my favorite place to go for a serious dining experience. I've been there a number of times, and in addition to ordering the more traditional steaks, I've had their wonderful lobster (MAJOR portion) and their chopped steak. They also have a wonderful chopped salad, onion rings, and creamed spinach. Oh, I almost left out their jumbo lump crabmeat appetizer!

The bar is a very pleasant place for a pre dinner cocktail. They make an unusually good Kir Royale.

This is a first class steak house all the way from the food and wine selection to the excellent service.

2
★★★★☆

New York Prime is definitely my favorite place to go for a serious dining experience. I've been there a number of times, and in addition to ordering the more traditional steaks, I've had their wonderful lobster (MAJOR portion) and their chopped steak. They also have a wonderful chopped salad, onion rings, and creamed spinach. Oh, I almost left out their jumbo lump crabmeat appetizer!

The bar is a very pleasant place for a pre dinner cocktail. They make an unusually good Kir Royale.

This is a first class steak house all the way from the food and wine selection to the excellent service.

.

I went to New York Prime the first time with a group of 4. We had a great evening, but it had nothing to do with the food. The steak was Tender and cooked perfect, but it had no flavor. The oysters rockefeller were so over done with cheese and spinach that you were unable to taste the flavor of the oysters.The sides we very weird. The salad was put through a food processor before it was served so it looked like someone ate it and then put it back on our plate. The onion straws were greasy and cold the mashed potatoes had so much cheese in them, it was like eating baked cheese. The asparagus were as big as sausages and as touch as straw. Very over rated!

1
★★★☆☆

I went to New York Prime the first time with a group of 4. We had a great evening, but it had nothing to do with the food. The steak was Tender and cooked perfect, but it had no flavor. The oysters rockefeller were so over done with cheese and spinach that you were unable to taste the flavor of the oysters.The sides we very weird. The salad was put through a food processor before it was served so it looked like someone ate it and then put it back on our plate. The onion straws were greasy and cold the mashed potatoes had so much cheese in them, it was like eating baked cheese. The asparagus were as big as sausages and as touch as straw. Very over rated!

Pros: good drinks, good wine

Cons: food, flavor, quality

.

We enjoyed New York Prime for my father's 60th b-day. The service and food was UNBELIEVEABLE!! Between the 4 of us in the party, we had 3 bone in Rib eyes and 1 Petite strip. No one was disappointed, and all agreed it was the BEST steaks we had ever had, period. The bone-in is exceptional!! We have all been to almost every fine steakhouse in Atlanta, and all agreed this by far is the best. The service is terrific as well. They anticipated our every need, from the water glasses never allowed to go below the halfway mark, to our napkins being folded the moment anyone left the table. It was a terrific night and we can't wait to go back! The ambience is not quiet, so it is not a great romantic place. If you want the PERFECT steak, this is the place!!

2
★★★★★

We enjoyed New York Prime for my father's 60th b-day. The service and food was UNBELIEVEABLE!! Between the 4 of us in the party, we had 3 bone in Rib eyes and 1 Petite strip. No one was disappointed, and all agreed it was the BEST steaks we had ever had, period. The bone-in is exceptional!! We have all been to almost every fine steakhouse in Atlanta, and all agreed this by far is the best. The service is terrific as well. They anticipated our every need, from the water glasses never allowed to go below the halfway mark, to our napkins being folded the moment anyone left the table. It was a terrific night and we can't wait to go back! The ambience is not quiet, so it is not a great romantic place. If you want the PERFECT steak, this is the place!!

Pros: Valet parking, Excellent food, great service

Cons: crowded, loud

.

I will preface this review that with the fact that this was a business dinner, so it was on the company dime. It kind of got off on the wrong foot, as we had asked if they had a private room to accommodate a meeting we were scheduling. The host said they did, and it was the Ritz Room. Upon arrival we learned that the entire dining room was called the Ritz Room. They tried to seat us in a quiet corner to accommodate our meeting, but it was still too loud in there to really hear much of anything. On a better note, the food that we dined on was very good. I had the bone rib-eye, which was absolutely FANTASTIC. Id never really had a prime rib-eye before, but this was one of the best pure steaks Ive ever had. Our waiter and overall service was notably excellent.

2
★★★★☆

I will preface this review that with the fact that this was a business dinner, so it was on the company dime. It kind of got off on the wrong foot, as we had asked if they had a private room to accommodate a meeting we were scheduling. The host said they did, and it was the Ritz Room. Upon arrival we learned that the entire dining room was called the Ritz Room. They tried to seat us in a quiet corner to accommodate our meeting, but it was still too loud in there to really hear much of anything. On a better note, the food that we dined on was very good. I had the bone rib-eye, which was absolutely FANTASTIC. Id never really had a prime rib-eye before, but this was one of the best pure steaks Ive ever had. Our waiter and overall service was notably excellent.

Pros: Bone Rib-Eye!, Excellent service

Cons: Hard to find, No private room, Loud (not romantic)

.

The succulent filet is to die for! Service staff anticipates your every need. Portions are generous enough to share. The banana cream pie is the perfect finish.

2
★★★★☆

The succulent filet is to die for! Service staff anticipates your every need. Portions are generous enough to share. The banana cream pie is the perfect finish.

Pros: valet parking, secluded, great people watching

.

Although I don't live in Atlanta, I get to the city as often as I can. I have been unable to forgo this restaurant (EACH TRIP) to give another steak place a try. This place is by far the best steak I have ever had anywhere. Their service is impeccable, and they do it so well without making you uncomfortable. I strongly recommend the appetizers, too. Portion sizes are generous, and everything is brought to your table at the PEFECT temperature.

2
★★★★★

Although I don't live in Atlanta, I get to the city as often as I can. I have been unable to forgo this restaurant (EACH TRIP) to give another steak place a try. This place is by far the best steak I have ever had anywhere. Their service is impeccable, and they do it so well without making you uncomfortable. I strongly recommend the appetizers, too. Portion sizes are generous, and everything is brought to your table at the PEFECT temperature.

Pros: FOOD, Service, Atmosphere

.

I have tried Bones, Chops, Ruth etc. If it is food you are looking for, than this is the place. When it comes to steaks the quality of meat is exceptional. The best in Atlanta. New York Prime does not have the best ambience if you are looking for that sort of thing. I personally could care less. It is about the food and when it comes to Steaks this is THE PLACE. Service is very polite, attentive but hands-off. Service will not interfere with the enjoyment of exceptional food. Enjoy. Keep up the good work.

2
★★★★★

I have tried Bones, Chops, Ruth etc. If it is food you are looking for, than this is the place. When it comes to steaks the quality of meat is exceptional. The best in Atlanta. New York Prime does not have the best ambience if you are looking for that sort of thing. I personally could care less. It is about the food and when it comes to Steaks this is THE PLACE. Service is very polite, attentive but hands-off. Service will not interfere with the enjoyment of exceptional food. Enjoy. Keep up the good work.

Pros: Steaks, Sides, Service

Cons: , can be difficult to , find for some

.

Despite the ravings of the Atlanta magazine food critic, she is way off target. First - no ambiance. You walk right in, not to the reception area, but to the bar. The matre d' is on the OTHER side of it. Ugly place. Second - food, ick. My friends, celebrating their birthdays, ordered the $60 porterhouse for two medium. It came totally raw (this from a bunch of "experts"?)> Upon sending it back a second and third time, it came out charred and horribly overcooked. Sure they credited the check, after complaints, but it RUINED the evening.

1
★★☆☆☆

Despite the ravings of the Atlanta magazine food critic, she is way off target. First - no ambiance. You walk right in, not to the reception area, but to the bar. The matre d' is on the OTHER side of it. Ugly place. Second - food, ick. My friends, celebrating their birthdays, ordered the $60 porterhouse for two medium. It came totally raw (this from a bunch of "experts"?)> Upon sending it back a second and third time, it came out charred and horribly overcooked. Sure they credited the check, after complaints, but it RUINED the evening.

Editorial from

Dramatic dark woods craft a perfect space for guy dining, with high-energy and lots of ambient noise---but the huge steaks are the main attraction (for the ladies, too). The best way to order them is to focus on the color and temperature…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used New York Prime, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review