Antonio's New York Pizzeria

★★★★☆
  • 4210 Waialae Ave #109

    Honolulu, HI 96816

    Map & Directions
  • 808-737-3333

Food

Food
More choices in Honolulu:
Resultset_next

Assaggio Hawaii Kai

7192 Kalanianaole Hwy Honolulu, HI

Resultset_next

Auntie Pasto's

1099 S Beretania St Honolulu, HI

4.2857 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Antonio's New York Pizzeria was?
Write a Review
.

A+++

3
★★★★★

A+++

.

I called all enthusiastic, and polite, and all I got from the girl that answered the phone was BS and attitude...no ideas how to make my date in a few days better...just no we dont have what you want....blah blah blah....Im going to California Pizza Kitchen...screw Antonios. It was HST 4.55PM on the 17 of July!!!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I called all enthusiastic, and polite, and all I got from the girl that answered the phone was BS and attitude...no ideas how to make my date in a few days better...just no we dont have what you want....blah blah blah....Im going to California Pizza Kitchen...screw Antonios. It was HST 4.55PM on the 17 of July!!!

Cons: First contact was crap!!

.

ok, so while i was hapai, i craved pizza... not delivery kine, but pizza joint kine. one evening, as we left kahala mall, we passed antonio's and i said, "ooooh, pizza...let's try it!" never mind the fact that we must've passed this joint a million times... we went. it's kind of dimly lit with a tiny tv and an old video game machine near the parmesan cheese and red chili flakes station. we ordered a caesar salad, sausage and ham calzone, and a small cheese pizza for me... (couldn't stand pepperoni while i was pregnant.) the salad was average, but the calzone was meaty and cheesy and the pizza was good. only regret - after eating, i used their bathroom. they had one of those old school cushioned toilet seats... gross! a bathroom says so much about a place.

3
★★★☆☆

ok, so while i was hapai, i craved pizza... not delivery kine, but pizza joint kine. one evening, as we left kahala mall, we passed antonio's and i said, "ooooh, pizza...let's try it!" never mind the fact that we must've passed this joint a million times... we went. it's kind of dimly lit with a tiny tv and an old video game machine near the parmesan cheese and red chili flakes station. we ordered a caesar salad, sausage and ham calzone, and a small cheese pizza for me... (couldn't stand pepperoni while i was pregnant.) the salad was average, but the calzone was meaty and cheesy and the pizza was good. only regret - after eating, i used their bathroom. they had one of those old school cushioned toilet seats... gross! a bathroom says so much about a place.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

If you are looking for authentic East Coast pizza and real Philly chessesteaks, this is THE only place on the island! Clean, friendly and the freshest and best tasting.

5
★★★★★

If you are looking for authentic East Coast pizza and real Philly chessesteaks, this is THE only place on the island! Clean, friendly and the freshest and best tasting.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I'm from the Northeast, my gf is from NYC, and we can vouch that Antonio's is without a doubt the best pizza in the state of Hawaii. Nothing comes close, and most island pies are straight up inedible. Antonio's is excellent pizza, more in the CT style than NY, but still leagues above anything you can get out here. Highly recommended!!

2
★★★★★

I'm from the Northeast, my gf is from NYC, and we can vouch that Antonio's is without a doubt the best pizza in the state of Hawaii. Nothing comes close, and most island pies are straight up inedible. Antonio's is excellent pizza, more in the CT style than NY, but still leagues above anything you can get out here. Highly recommended!!

.

Antonio's is a great place to get some ono pizza. Granted the location is inconvenient to get to, but the food and the service makes it all worth it. The workers talk to you
New York Style, and the pizza is to die for. The cheesecake is the best i have also eaten as well. You can get a variety of pizza choices as well. Sized and topped to your delight. And the kicker is that the pizza is very inexpensive. Great food at a great price. I live in Mililani and i will drive to Kahala to get my fix. Totally worth trying.

2
★★★★★

Antonio's is a great place to get some ono pizza. Granted the location is inconvenient to get to, but the food and the service makes it all worth it. The workers talk to you
New York Style, and the pizza is to die for. The cheesecake is the best i have also eaten as well. You can get a variety of pizza choices as well. Sized and topped to your delight. And the kicker is that the pizza is very inexpensive. Great food at a great price. I live in Mililani and i will drive to Kahala to get my fix. Totally worth trying.

Pros: Taste, Value, Service

Cons: Difficult Location

.

I have never had such great pizza! I went there by referral and was NOT disappointed. The pizza is absolutely fabulous and bursting with flavor. Everytime I go there it is hard to decide whether I want a philly cheesesteak or a pizza. The restaurant itself is not much to look at it but who cares?! You are going there for the great food at a great price! I'll be going back again soon!

2
★★★★★

I have never had such great pizza! I went there by referral and was NOT disappointed. The pizza is absolutely fabulous and bursting with flavor. Everytime I go there it is hard to decide whether I want a philly cheesesteak or a pizza. The restaurant itself is not much to look at it but who cares?! You are going there for the great food at a great price! I'll be going back again soon!

Pros: Delicious food, Great value, Amazing sandwiches

Editorial from

Locals flock for traditional New York style pizza at the restaurant that also serves cheesecakes at affordable prices.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Antonio's New York Pizzeria, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review