Insider Pages Reviews for Margie's Candies

5 Stars: Chocolate Lovers go Mmmmmm...... (by dwogn)

dwogn — Thu, 23 Apr 2009 00:00:00 GMT

The place has simply the Best Chocolate Ice cream in town, its called the Brownie Ala Mode. I ordered it with Chocolate Ice cream and Pecans, it comes in this huge bowl shaped like a shell, with 3 scoops of yummy chocolate ice cream, a chocolate brownie, whipped cream, sprinkled with pecans and they give you a jar of warm molten chocolate fudge. Have a spoon of this a you will close your eyes and go Mmmmmmmm.... Heaven!

5 Stars: ice cream (by Sylvia C.)

Sylvia C. — Fri, 10 Apr 2009 12:27:00 GMT

The best place ever! I love this place. It has the best ice cream hands down. Everyone should try this place. Great prices and its a nice and cute place to go to.

2 Stars: chocolates tasted like soap (by shorty68)

shorty68 — Tue, 30 Dec 2008 00:00:00 GMT

We ordered two candies which were loose. One was a coffee cream. The other was a cherry cluster. Both my husband and I agreed that both candies tasted like soap. We are wondering if someone sprayed soap on the candies or mixed soap with the chocolate.

Hopefully this is only an isolated problem.

2 Stars: Just plain mean. (by likejen)

likejen — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 00:00:00 GMT

Like other reviewers, I had driven by this place for years and was very excited to visit. I didn't last 30 seconds before what looked like the owner and another staff member harrassed and made fun of me for 'just looking around'. When I decided to leave, they laughed and sarcastically told me to hurry back real soon. I honestly was not in the store for an entire minute. It was a disturbing and uncomfortable experience to say the least.

5 Stars: YUMMY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (by Steve L.)

Steve L. — Thu, 29 May 2008 21:31:00 GMT

Old Fashion Ice Cream Parlor in the heart of the City. The Sunday's are to die for. You could not ask for a better Ice cream Sunday & they have tons of cool pictures of people that worked there in the past or owned it. it is quite cool

4 Stars: Margie's Candies (by Dena L.)

Dena L. — Thu, 24 Apr 2008 22:05:00 GMT

I'm an ice cream fanatic, and I love this place. Though they could use more flavor choices, one can't go wrong with a yummy hot fudge sundae from Margies. Their hot fudge is warm and gooey. Fun place to hang out.

4 Stars: Great desserts, Small place (by Carmen I Q.)

Carmen I Q. — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 14:46:00 GMT

I absolutely love this ice cream parlor!! It's been around since the 1920's and still holds most of it's original furniture/decor. The ice cream is divine, and so is the service. However, it gets REALLY crowded in the tiny parlor, especially on weekends. BUT they're open till 12am, sometimes 1am. You have to try their Turtle Banana Split with coconut ice cream!

5 Stars: very clean, no odors like the other place, great customer service! (by chiguy1)

chiguy1 — Wed, 20 Feb 2008 00:00:00 GMT

Hey Everyone, I just want to let everyone know that A second Margie's icecream store is opened on Montrose Ave right off the brown line, (Around 1800 W. Montrose) They have the same menu, But alot less candies in their display! This place is so much cleaner and no foul odor's as in the one on Western Ave, The wait staff is very friendly and helpful (except for the redish brown hair lady -talked my head off and didn't give me time to read the menu) That was on my 4th vist there on a slow sunday, But all other vists were EXCELLENT! Weekend's are A great time and not A long wait, With A nice mix of people and A very nice neighborhood! So my advice is if you still want Margie's icecream in a nice enviroment, Go to the one on Montrose! It's worth the little extra drive

5 Stars: A Chicago gem (by funkdragon23)

funkdragon23 — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 00:00:00 GMT

I took a leisurely stroll northward on scenic Milwaukee Avenue one sultry summer night this August with a female companion. After a great dinner at Earwax Cafe, we craved a cool dessert. Ten minutes later, we were in line at Margie's. Plenty of bustle about the place: local families with kids in tow intermingled with obvious visitors to this ice cream mecca on the outskirts of Bucktown. It was a gorgeous evening so we didn't mind the wait, which turned out to be quite short--five minutes tops--on a hot and busy Saturday night, no less. We were ushered into what must be the tiniest restaurant in existence, for sure, but were relieved to be seated at a comfy, roomy booth, surrounded by a collection of tchachkes to rival all tchachkes. Definitely a portal into a more innocent time. The service was curt, the menu was gargantuan. We both ordered sundaes. They. Were. MAGNIFICENT! Mounds of freshly-made ice cream topped with incredible caramel and chocolate sauces, nuts, and garnished with a wafer cookie and one of Margie's signature candies. But the real treat was the gravy-boat of homemade hot fudge provided, the most decadent chocolate I may have ever tasted. Drizzled over our ice cream treats, we were in heaven. When we'd finally devoured our awesome creations, we wanted more, but prudence ruled, and we went home very, very happy. So if you don't mind a little wait, utilitarian service, and some seriously retro surroundings, you'll be rewarded with the most remarkable ice cream you've ever tasted. Guaranteed.

5 Stars: Love This Place (by Joseph C.)

Joseph C. — Tue, 29 Nov 2005 09:35:00 GMT

This is the best place for those who have a sweet tooth. They have every kind of ice cream dessert imaginable. It is very homey and you can buy different trinkets to take home with you. It is definately a Chicago favorite.

5 Stars: I love this place!! (by Puja C.)

Puja C. — Thu, 10 Nov 2005 14:12:00 GMT

They have the best ice cream I have ever had! I love their different dessert creations and all the history that surrounds the store. It is a cozy place and it can satisfy anyone's sweet tooth.

PROS:
CONS: Parking can be tough.

5 Stars: Perfect for Ice Cream Lovers (by Kimberly S.)

Kimberly S. — Sun, 11 Sep 2005 15:27:00 GMT

Margie's is a rare old-fashioned ice cream parlor. It's a small crowded space, so on nice evenings be prepared to wait if you want a seat (you can just order to go, but the place is part of the charm). Many sundae options, the toppings are homemade and delicious. Generous portions.

PROS: Atmosphere
CONS: Crowds

5 Stars: authentic ice parlor (by L A N G T.)

L A N G T. — Mon, 16 May 2005 11:14:00 GMT

this place is great for the sweet tooths. its homemade ice cream served in a clam shell bowls makes this place unforgettable. it's great for dates-portions are huge. it's side includes their homemade hot fudge and wafer cookies. go there for your birthday, and you'll get a gift from margie's. to those smarties: bring in your report card with an "a" on it and you'll get a free cone on them!

PROS: closes late-Sun-Thu 9am-12am Fri-Sat 9am-1am
CONS: always a wait especially at night, not good for large groups