Mr Benny's Steak & Lobster

★★★★★
  • 19200 Everett Ln

    Mokena, IL 60448

    Map & Directions
  • 708-478-5800

About Mr Benny's Steak & Lobster

Hours
Tue - Sun, 5pm - close

Food

Food
More choices in Mokena:
Resultset_next

Toby's Dining & Spirits

13248 S 76TH Ave Palos Heights, IL

Resultset_next

Outback Orland Park

15608 Harlem Avenue Orland Park, IL

4.5556 9
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Mr Benny's Steak & Lobster was?
Write a Review
.

Went to Mr Benny's for our Anniversary thought it would be a very nice experience. However the atmoshpere was a jeans place comparable to (MC DONALDS/DENNYS), even the hostess was wearing jeans.\r
The building and atmosphere other than

3
★★★★★

Went to Mr Benny's for our Anniversary thought it would be a very nice experience. However the atmoshpere was a jeans place comparable to (MC DONALDS/DENNYS), even the hostess was wearing jeans.\r
The building and atmosphere other than

.

Oct, 24,2010
We thought it odd that on a Sunday at dinner time there were just a few cars and patrons at Mr. Benny's. We had been here many times before so expected it to be as good as in the past. NOT!
The meal was terrible and very expensive. After sending a steak back for the third time the owner offered to cook it himself "the way it should be. Trust me." Wow was it bad! The steak had a phony smoke flavor and was ice cold in the middle. It seemed to have been precooked. The other entree was a "specialty of the house" baby back ribs that was really awful. We were charged for the dinner and were not pleased at all.
So much for Mr. Benny's. It was good in the past but forget about
it now and head to Texas Roadhouse down the street and be happy. A one star rating is too generous.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Oct, 24,2010
We thought it odd that on a Sunday at dinner time there were just a few cars and patrons at Mr. Benny's. We had been here many times before so expected it to be as good as in the past. NOT!
The meal was terrible and very expensive. After sending a steak back for the third time the owner offered to cook it himself "the way it should be. Trust me." Wow was it bad! The steak had a phony smoke flavor and was ice cold in the middle. It seemed to have been precooked. The other entree was a "specialty of the house" baby back ribs that was really awful. We were charged for the dinner and were not pleased at all.
So much for Mr. Benny's. It was good in the past but forget about
it now and head to Texas Roadhouse down the street and be happy. A one star rating is too generous.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We went to Mr. Benny's this evening for our 40th wedding anniversary. The filet mignon was the best I have ever had. The service was fantastic and our waitress, Roxanne, was excellent. She even served us ice cream with whipped topping for our anniversary.

5
★★★★★

We went to Mr. Benny's this evening for our 40th wedding anniversary. The filet mignon was the best I have ever had. The service was fantastic and our waitress, Roxanne, was excellent. She even served us ice cream with whipped topping for our anniversary.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

excellent meal steak and lobster were outstanding, have eaten at many 5 star establishment and Mr. Benny's is among the finest.Wonderful professional service from all wait staff, big thank you to Vicki for the 1st class service, her meal recommendations were right on, and Nick at the bar certainly can mix an excellent cocktail. Mr Benny greets his patrons to see if all is well and if there is any you need. His personal touch makes you feel like family when you're there. I would highly recommend this resturant to those who appreciate a fine meal in a very cozy, comfortable atmosphere where the service is outsatnding.

5
★★★★★

excellent meal steak and lobster were outstanding, have eaten at many 5 star establishment and Mr. Benny's is among the finest.Wonderful professional service from all wait staff, big thank you to Vicki for the 1st class service, her meal recommendations were right on, and Nick at the bar certainly can mix an excellent cocktail. Mr Benny greets his patrons to see if all is well and if there is any you need. His personal touch makes you feel like family when you're there. I would highly recommend this resturant to those who appreciate a fine meal in a very cozy, comfortable atmosphere where the service is outsatnding.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have been coming here for ages. The food and service are outstanding. This is a place where they strive to "Know Your Name." Known for their steak, but excel in seafood and other specials. I have never been a meat person, but have been known to get the filet with melted blue cheese on top. I highly recommend the Meditteranean Salmon, the perch, the Chicken Marsala, the Zuppe de Pesche, and especially the Linguini with Clam Sauce. The latter is my favorite and in my opinion, better than any I have had downtown!
Also, keep in mind that while average entrees cost from $15 to $30, they come with a relish tray, hot bread, and soup or salad.

2
★★★★★

I have been coming here for ages. The food and service are outstanding. This is a place where they strive to "Know Your Name." Known for their steak, but excel in seafood and other specials. I have never been a meat person, but have been known to get the filet with melted blue cheese on top. I highly recommend the Meditteranean Salmon, the perch, the Chicken Marsala, the Zuppe de Pesche, and especially the Linguini with Clam Sauce. The latter is my favorite and in my opinion, better than any I have had downtown!
Also, keep in mind that while average entrees cost from $15 to $30, they come with a relish tray, hot bread, and soup or salad.

Pros: Great Food, close to I-57, and great salad and relish tray

Cons: Far from downtown

.

While it goes without saying that the atmosphere and the food are top notch, what needs to be singled out is the service provided by Jane. While we certainly recommend this restaurant to all, we must encourage you to ask for Jane.
To all, especially Jane, we thank you for a wonderful meal.

5
★★★★★

While it goes without saying that the atmosphere and the food are top notch, what needs to be singled out is the service provided by Jane. While we certainly recommend this restaurant to all, we must encourage you to ask for Jane.
To all, especially Jane, we thank you for a wonderful meal.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

r. Bennys has great atmosphere and service. You can expect to get a handshake from Mr. Benny himself at the bar or at some point during dinner. Stick with the foods that you would expect a Steak and Lobster place to be good at; Steak and Lobster. Anything else, especially the pasta, is really not good at all. Your best bet actually is the Alaskan King crab legs, which are near impossible to mess up. But then again, crab legs are crab legs and those bought at the store and cooked at home will taste exactly the same; Mr. Bennys Crab legs are about $50. Also, another word of caution for the deserts; they all sound good but taste store bought.

To summarize:

:

1. Order only Crab legs or Fillet Minion (you will be disappointed by anything else on the menu)
2. Enjoy the great service and a hand shake from Mr. Benny himself
3. Enjoy the warm roles

:

1. Order any pasta dishes (especially not the Chicken Tuscany)
2. Forget your wallet (Mr. Bennys is overly expensive)
3. Order Desert (they all sound good but taste store bought)

2
★★★★☆

r. Bennys has great atmosphere and service. You can expect to get a handshake from Mr. Benny himself at the bar or at some point during dinner. Stick with the foods that you would expect a Steak and Lobster place to be good at; Steak and Lobster. Anything else, especially the pasta, is really not good at all. Your best bet actually is the Alaskan King crab legs, which are near impossible to mess up. But then again, crab legs are crab legs and those bought at the store and cooked at home will taste exactly the same; Mr. Bennys Crab legs are about $50. Also, another word of caution for the deserts; they all sound good but taste store bought.

To summarize:

:

1. Order only Crab legs or Fillet Minion (you will be disappointed by anything else on the menu)
2. Enjoy the great service and a hand shake from Mr. Benny himself
3. Enjoy the warm roles

:

1. Order any pasta dishes (especially not the Chicken Tuscany)
2. Forget your wallet (Mr. Bennys is overly expensive)
3. Order Desert (they all sound good but taste store bought)

Pros: Service, Ambiance, Crab Legs

Cons: Expensive, boring menu, pasta dishes

.

I have traveled and eaten at 5 star restaurants all over the world. Mr. Benny' captures everything a 5 star restaurant should be. 1st class service, impeccable cleanliness, food prepared to order, a wonderful relaxed atmosphere, the Owner- Mr. Benny is on site and greets patrons, in fact treats them like family. Cost,Some people have said its a tad pricey, I believe its well/fair priced for the wonderful dinning experience you'll have. Keep NYC give me MR. Benny's

PROS: Excellent aged beef, wonderful lobster, Great wait staff Ask for Vicki
CONS: NONE

5
★★★★★

I have traveled and eaten at 5 star restaurants all over the world. Mr. Benny' captures everything a 5 star restaurant should be. 1st class service, impeccable cleanliness, food prepared to order, a wonderful relaxed atmosphere, the Owner- Mr. Benny is on site and greets patrons, in fact treats them like family. Cost,Some people have said its a tad pricey, I believe its well/fair priced for the wonderful dinning experience you'll have. Keep NYC give me MR. Benny's

PROS: Excellent aged beef, wonderful lobster, Great wait staff Ask for Vicki
CONS: NONE

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Mr. Benny's is an excellent restaurant. The food is very high quality, specializing in steaks and seafood. They offer party facilities as well and I have been to a rehearsal dinner here that was very nice. Mr. Benny himself is usually present to greet customers and comes around to see if you are happy with everything. While it is expensive you do get the best food and service, well worth it for any special occasion.

5
★★★★★

Mr. Benny's is an excellent restaurant. The food is very high quality, specializing in steaks and seafood. They offer party facilities as well and I have been to a rehearsal dinner here that was very nice. Mr. Benny himself is usually present to greet customers and comes around to see if you are happy with everything. While it is expensive you do get the best food and service, well worth it for any special occasion.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Mr Benny's Steak & Lobster, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review