Sabatino's

Message from Sabatino's

This Portage Park institution has become a destination for families and couples craving Northern Italian fare.
  • Banquet Facilities Available
  • Traditional Italian Dining
  • Private Parties

This traditional Italian restaurant features an authentic menu with options such as fresh Florida broiled red snapper, broiled English dover sole, broiled African lobster tail, lobster al diavolo and shrimp for seafood. In addition are various meat and chicken dishes such as Sabatino's prime N.Y. strip, filet mignon, baby back ribs, pepper steak, pork, chicken toscana, chicken parmigiana and chicken Sabatino. Sabatino's was also acclaimed as "The Best Northern Italian Cuisine in the city" --by Citysearch '04.

Editorial and merchant content by Citysearch

Marker Sabatino's

(773) 877-3971

4441 W Irving Park Rd Chicago, IL 60641
Write a Review

Editorial Description by Citysearch
The Scene
This windowless trattoria could be the setting for a gangster movie. To the right of the entrance, locals sit in vinyl chairs or booths in a dark piano bar while a suited-up maitre d' ushers diners to one of three unique dining rooms. The first resembles an outdoor garden with statuettes and white lights; the second and most intimate has private alcoves for couples; and the last offers several large round tables for group dining. The old-school soundtrack marries Sinatra and strolling violinists who serenade lovers upon request.

The Food
Reasonably priced, classic Italian cuisine covers just about every meat and seafood dish out there. Start with buttery baked clams or artichoke bottoms topped with chunks of lobster swimming in a mornay sauce. Landlubbers won't go wrong with meaty, cheesy lasagna or a juicy New York strip that comes in two sizes--large and extra large--for mammoth appetites.
Rated 10.0 out of 10 by Citysearch.

32 Reviews of Sabatino's in Chicago

Have experience with this business? Write a review


pasta  3 Star Rating - Satisfactory

By pauline a. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 3,202

The pasts here is very good. my friend took me here for my birthday and the place is very nice. the service is also great. i think people should try it.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)

Good Italian Food  4 Star Rating - Very good

By Tony D. | insider Insider | Rank: 12,816

We had a family banquet here and the food and service were excellent.

The pasta dishes were delicious. I love my pasta al dente and they prepared it to perfection. The sauce was very flavorful and the prices were reasonable.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)

Sabatino's Restaurant  3 Star Rating - Satisfactory

By Orlando M. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 3,599

I don't know if it was the night that I went in but I was not too impressed with Sabatino's. My friends love them.I think one day I'll try them again with my wife just to sharpen my judgement.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes / No (you must log in or sign up to vote)
Latest reviews by Citysearch: (read all 29 reviews on Citysearch)

Very romantic .. best Itallian food! 5 Star Rating - World class

By Munchkin79

This is one of the best Itallian restaurants... my husband and I have been going here for years now and the best feature is their romantic booths!! This is the place we celebrate our special ocassions!
I've only tried the vegeitarian part of the menu and the bow tie pasta with cream sauce and the fettucine with mushroom cream sauce are the best. Good drinks and huge portions... we always walk out with lunch for the next day! Bit pricy but its well worth it!!

The tiramasu and the baked alaska is a very good dessert choice.

Make reservation for the booth... its prefect for couples!! I would definately recommend this to families and couples.... dont be fooled by the outside... You have to walk inside and try this place!!

Pros: Romantic, good food, free and valet parking...
Cons: gets really crowded .. make reservations
Posted 12/02/08

Recently Disappointed 2 Star Rating - Wouldn't recommend

By AprilMae

Sabatino's had always been one of my family's favorite resturants. I grew up in the neighborhood and looked forward to going for special occaisons. We loved the attentive service, the large portions and the tasty food. Chicken Parm and Chateaubriand were are favorites. We recommend Sabatino's to all of our family and friends.

Recently we visted and had a bad experience. We were very disappointed. One of the steaks was overcooked and we asked for a replacement. One of the owners came to the table and argued that the steak was cooked correctly. He was extremely rude. Never-the-less, the steak was replaced but came back still overcooked and tough. We were most shocked by the owner's behavior since this was a man who had greeted us warmly in the past and knew us from the neighborhood.

That night, my sister became extremely ill. She was rushed to the emergency room and told she had food psnng. The doctor said that based on the timing of the symptoms, the food psnng must have come from the meal at Sabaino's. A few days later my sister called Sabatino's and told them she had gotten food psnng. She mostly wanted to make them aware. They were very rude and insisted that it was not because of thier food. They also told my sister, "she could not prove it was thier food that got her sick."

In addition to the horrific service, the once charming decor has begun to look dated and worn. We hope that Sabatino's makes the necessary improvements to return it to the nice family resturant it once was. At this point, we are not interested in returning.

Pros: traditional italian food
Cons: RUDE service
Posted 06/25/08

Mangia! Mangia! 5 Star Rating - World class

By biscotti11

My husband and I have been visiting Sabatino's from the South Side for nearly 30 years and have never (I repeat NEVER) been disappointed in their fine food and service. It is one of the truly precious Italian (real ITALIAN) restaurants left in Chicagoland. It is affordable and friendly. If someone is unhappy with the food....say something!! I'm sure that it will be remedied immediately. The owners aim to please.....like I said, I've been going there for nearly 30 years. Oh, did I say that I, too, am a chef?

Posted 01/09/08

Restaurant should be kept a secret!!!!!!! 1 Star Rating - Unsatisfactory

By mercypes

Hostess was less than charming - when we told her we didn't have reservations she made a face. We were seated quickly and server took our drink orders. Place began to crowd up after 630 to the point every 5mins bus boys and waitresses kept excusing themselves to get through to other parties. The area we were located in was definitely not a romantic spot - it was too noisy you can practicately hear everyone's conversations. Soup, Salad, Entrees were served every 30 mins. When entrees finally arrived my friends chicken had an eye lash on it she disregarded it. My entree the norweign salmon had a black short hair on the sauce. Plate was replaced but after having my entire party finish their food. In total we were there 2hrs and 15 mins. I can suggest that servers should try to lift trays higher to prevent their hairs from being dropped on food because they carry entree trays so close to their necks.. I will NOT go back to Sabtino's this place is better off kept a secret.

Posted 07/30/07

Neighborhood legend still a big draw 5 Star Rating - World class

By foodindustrynewsguy

We enjoy Sabatino's. Along Irving Park Road, It is a classy place in a middle-class neighborhood: valet parking but parking is always easy on Irving, but Irving being a main street that cuts through the north side, you can easily take the El here or grab the bus in front.

Very nice Italian fare and lowered lights makes this a PERFECT place for a group of friends to quietly chat and enjoy dinner together. If you leave it still hungry, you're not trying: it's Italain, for gosh sakes: indulge!

Dress well: this isn't McDonald's. Wines are varied, so try a recommendation with assurance that they'll do a good job for you. You go here to eat well but also to impress. you may try to plan a movie or show after your visit, but Sabatino's IS the show for the evening, so spend, eat and smile.

This is 1950's class that refuses to go away, thank god! For those times when you want to impress someone, Sabatino's is one of our fav places, and has been for nearly three decades!

Mark Braun
Food Industry News

Pros: Classy, busy but still intimate. good service and excellent Italian menu
Cons: Reservations needed! Dress well
Posted 05/03/07