Key West Shrimp House Inc

★★★☆☆
  • 512 Me Main St

    Madison, IN 47250

    Map & Directions
  • 812-265-2831

About Key West Shrimp House Inc

Food

Food
More choices in Madison:
Resultset_next

Captain D's

9088 Madison Blvd Madison, AL

Resultset_next

C D's Pub & Grill

107 Arlington Dr Ste B Madison, AL

2.75 4
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Key West Shrimp House Inc was?
Write a Review
.

I was visiting Madison for the weekend, and my boyfriend and I stopped for an early dinner at Key West Shrimp House. We split the Shrimp Panama and I was extremely disappointed. They were cooked, frozen shrimp that tasted a little fishy, and were seriously overcooked. The "special sauce" reminded me of Campbell's tomato soup with sugar. The double baked potato wasn't too bad, but it was obviously frozen, with that hard crust on top. According to my boyfriend, the salad bar and soup were OK. If we head back to Madison, it's a restaurant I would definately skip.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I was visiting Madison for the weekend, and my boyfriend and I stopped for an early dinner at Key West Shrimp House. We split the Shrimp Panama and I was extremely disappointed. They were cooked, frozen shrimp that tasted a little fishy, and were seriously overcooked. The "special sauce" reminded me of Campbell's tomato soup with sugar. The double baked potato wasn't too bad, but it was obviously frozen, with that hard crust on top. According to my boyfriend, the salad bar and soup were OK. If we head back to Madison, it's a restaurant I would definately skip.

.

I have had the pleasure for seven years now, to visit the Key West Shrimp House in Madison IN. The history of the building, the view of the mighty Ohio river, and the friendlieness of the wait staff are overwhelming. Great food, superb salad bar, and don't underestimate their famous garlic toast. I live three hours away, but every year I take some home to enjoy for several weeks.
A friendly, historic, and gourmet experience to be sure!
Bill Tandy, Kokomo, IN.

4
★★★★☆

I have had the pleasure for seven years now, to visit the Key West Shrimp House in Madison IN. The history of the building, the view of the mighty Ohio river, and the friendlieness of the wait staff are overwhelming. Great food, superb salad bar, and don't underestimate their famous garlic toast. I live three hours away, but every year I take some home to enjoy for several weeks.
A friendly, historic, and gourmet experience to be sure!
Bill Tandy, Kokomo, IN.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

It is rare that my wife and I treat ourselves to a fancy meal. On the occasion of our 2007 tax refund, we went to the KWSH and ordered lobster tails. What a disappointment! We could not decide if they were frozen, overcooked or both. They were dry and chewy. The soup, salad and drinks were fine. Alas, this was not the first time we had had such fare. Last year, I had a halibut steak that was also dry and chewy. If they are going to serve frozen seafood, they should say so in the menu. If it is the chef, they should can him! Will we eat there again. Perhaps. Eventually.

2
★★☆☆☆

It is rare that my wife and I treat ourselves to a fancy meal. On the occasion of our 2007 tax refund, we went to the KWSH and ordered lobster tails. What a disappointment! We could not decide if they were frozen, overcooked or both. They were dry and chewy. The soup, salad and drinks were fine. Alas, this was not the first time we had had such fare. Last year, I had a halibut steak that was also dry and chewy. If they are going to serve frozen seafood, they should say so in the menu. If it is the chef, they should can him! Will we eat there again. Perhaps. Eventually.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Order the Seafood Chowder, it is absolutely delicious! Key West Shrimp House has a very nice salad bar, it's always fresh and it's clean. Try the Mashed Potato Salad and Pickled Watermelon Rind. Remember to save room for the main course...Everything I have ever ordered here was great. The white fish....awesome!!!
Expect friendly, attentive service..the staff is great, as is the atmosphere. You may have to wait for a table but it's well worth it.
Take your birthday person here for a song, dessert, and they get their picture taken wearing the "hat"! It's fun!

4
★★★★☆

Order the Seafood Chowder, it is absolutely delicious! Key West Shrimp House has a very nice salad bar, it's always fresh and it's clean. Try the Mashed Potato Salad and Pickled Watermelon Rind. Remember to save room for the main course...Everything I have ever ordered here was great. The white fish....awesome!!!
Expect friendly, attentive service..the staff is great, as is the atmosphere. You may have to wait for a table but it's well worth it.
Take your birthday person here for a song, dessert, and they get their picture taken wearing the "hat"! It's fun!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Key West Shrimp House Inc, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review