Amazing Cakes By Millie

★★★☆☆
  • 4102 Madison Ave

    Indianapolis, IN 46227

    Map & Directions
  • 317-782-0660

About Amazing Cakes By Millie

Categories
Hours
Mon-Fri 10am-5:30pm, Sat 10am-4pm

Food

Food
More choices in Indianapolis:
Resultset_next

Working Man's Friend

234 N Belmont Ave Indianapolis, IN

Resultset_next

Propylaeum Club

1410 N Delaware St Ste 2 Indianapolis, IN

3.3333 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Amazing Cakes By Millie was?
Write a Review
.

When we went to pick out the cake, Millie was wonderful and sweet. We were only home for a couple days to get all the planning done since we live out of state. We picked the cake, all the details, and thought we were done. Then the month of our wedding she tried to tack on additional charges that we had not discussed when we had put the deposit down. I had to argue for her to waive that charge.

Then the Monday before our wedding she called to ask us what our cake looked like. What was the shape, the design, when we were bringing the ribbon to decorate it. I immediately was disappointed and frustrated that the WEEK of our wedding she could not recall the details of our order. How did she charge us then?! Additionally, there had been NO discussion that we had to bring anything to her other than the fresh flower topper. She immediately said it was MY fault and that I had not told her what we wanted the cake to look like b/c she is very thorough in her notes and she KNOWS she would have written it down. My fiance was with me when we picked the cake out, so I think she must be getting senial. She then threw out that she "didn't need this kind of questioning" and that she would give me my money back and I could go elsewhere. Which obviously the week of my wedding that is not an option.

I would NEVER do business with this lady, very unprofessional, rude, and tries to nickel and dime you throughout the process. She is a wedding bully.

And to end it all, she then tried to change the confirmed delivery time on the day of the wedding to 30 minutes before the ceremony. CRAZY!

0
★☆☆☆☆

When we went to pick out the cake, Millie was wonderful and sweet. We were only home for a couple days to get all the planning done since we live out of state. We picked the cake, all the details, and thought we were done. Then the month of our wedding she tried to tack on additional charges that we had not discussed when we had put the deposit down. I had to argue for her to waive that charge.

Then the Monday before our wedding she called to ask us what our cake looked like. What was the shape, the design, when we were bringing the ribbon to decorate it. I immediately was disappointed and frustrated that the WEEK of our wedding she could not recall the details of our order. How did she charge us then?! Additionally, there had been NO discussion that we had to bring anything to her other than the fresh flower topper. She immediately said it was MY fault and that I had not told her what we wanted the cake to look like b/c she is very thorough in her notes and she KNOWS she would have written it down. My fiance was with me when we picked the cake out, so I think she must be getting senial. She then threw out that she "didn't need this kind of questioning" and that she would give me my money back and I could go elsewhere. Which obviously the week of my wedding that is not an option.

I would NEVER do business with this lady, very unprofessional, rude, and tries to nickel and dime you throughout the process. She is a wedding bully.

And to end it all, she then tried to change the confirmed delivery time on the day of the wedding to 30 minutes before the ceremony. CRAZY!

Cons: Bully, Customer Service,

.

If you want a professionally decorated cake that also tastes great than don't overlook this mom and pop shop. Millie and family make the best cakes in town. The cherry chip cake is made with real cherries! Prices are reasonable and if you are shopping for a wedding cake the down to earth staff won't intimidate (unlike some of the upscale, pricey wedding cake bakeries).

5
★★★★★

If you want a professionally decorated cake that also tastes great than don't overlook this mom and pop shop. Millie and family make the best cakes in town. The cherry chip cake is made with real cherries! Prices are reasonable and if you are shopping for a wedding cake the down to earth staff won't intimidate (unlike some of the upscale, pricey wedding cake bakeries).

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

A Amazing Cakes by Millie is a very nice bakery with a personal touch. Prices are very reasonable and personalization is nice. Quick turn around on orders. Easy to get to and find. Overall recommend trying this place out! We like the atmosphere. It's very clean and the sights and smells are wonderful.

4
★★★★☆

A Amazing Cakes by Millie is a very nice bakery with a personal touch. Prices are very reasonable and personalization is nice. Quick turn around on orders. Easy to get to and find. Overall recommend trying this place out! We like the atmosphere. It's very clean and the sights and smells are wonderful.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Amazing Cakes By Millie, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review