Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

★★★★☆
  • 4983 N Franklin Rd

    Indianapolis, IN 46226

    Map & Directions
  • 317-545-7650

Shopping

Shopping
More choices in Indianapolis:
Resultset_next

Osterman Jewelers

6020 E 82nd St Indianapolis, IN

Resultset_next

Hofmeister Personal Jewelers

3809 E 82nd St Indianapolis, IN

3.5 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Lost Dutchman Rare Coins was?
Write a Review
.

I came to the shop for the first time last week to get rid of a few silver half dollars and a couple broken gold bracelets. I will not be going to a "Cash 4 Gold" place again. Not only did their payout beat the competitors, but the staff was so informative and very kind. Highly recommended if you are in the Indy Metro area!

5
★★★★★

I came to the shop for the first time last week to get rid of a few silver half dollars and a couple broken gold bracelets. I will not be going to a "Cash 4 Gold" place again. Not only did their payout beat the competitors, but the staff was so informative and very kind. Highly recommended if you are in the Indy Metro area!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I've done business in the passed and came away feeling good about my transactions. But as of late, they, (IMO) are gouging people. The use of the "Blue Sheet" for coins is fine, but they never show you these prices and I have a copy of this same sheet and can verify they are giving 20% to 30% even 50% less than the sheet... Sellers beware! It seems they rip off people on higher end coins by "Guessing" what they may be worth. Sell them yourself on line or find another shop who are fair in their pricing.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I've done business in the passed and came away feeling good about my transactions. But as of late, they, (IMO) are gouging people. The use of the "Blue Sheet" for coins is fine, but they never show you these prices and I have a copy of this same sheet and can verify they are giving 20% to 30% even 50% less than the sheet... Sellers beware! It seems they rip off people on higher end coins by "Guessing" what they may be worth. Sell them yourself on line or find another shop who are fair in their pricing.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Business Response:

Gene, I am sorry that you were less then happy with the prices you were quoted. We try very hard to pay the best prices we can for items while still maintaining a small profit. The percentages of sheet paid are determined by things like how many we have in stock and if we have a customer for an item. If I already have 5 of what you are selling with no customers for them we may offer %50-%70 of sheet simply because I already have more then I need. I hope we can continue to do business in the future. Matt
.

Maybe if your selling, he's the best... We drove 2 hours to get there and he told us he couldn't help us as he was 'busy' buying a guys stuff. Didn't matter as there was only two displays of coins and an unorganized accessory area. VERY disappointed wasted 4 total hours of drivetime.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Maybe if your selling, he's the best... We drove 2 hours to get there and he told us he couldn't help us as he was 'busy' buying a guys stuff. Didn't matter as there was only two displays of coins and an unorganized accessory area. VERY disappointed wasted 4 total hours of drivetime.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Business Response:

Kevin, I remember the day you are speaking of. I do apologize for the waste of your drive time. However you came in 20 minutes after closing. We close at 3 on Saturdays. The gentleman who you saw was the last customer who had been waiting since before 3 for his turn. In response to your review we have completely reorganized our accessory area and coin cases. Matt
.

Out of all of the places in Indianapolis Lost Dutchman is the place to go! They paid me more then I expected for my fathers coin collection. They are friendly, professional, and family owned! They are also BBB members. Everyone I saw also selling at Lost Dutchman seemed to be pleased with what they were being paid for their items.

Great Place!!

4
★★★★☆

Out of all of the places in Indianapolis Lost Dutchman is the place to go! They paid me more then I expected for my fathers coin collection. They are friendly, professional, and family owned! They are also BBB members. Everyone I saw also selling at Lost Dutchman seemed to be pleased with what they were being paid for their items.

Great Place!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

I purchased from this seller on ebay and immediately sent a money order for the full amount. I got no response. this has gone on for many months, maybe even since before January. There is correspondence back from my inquiries but they got paid.They won't send the merchandise nor will they return my money.
MLH, Westfield, New Jersey
PS this was an under $50.00 purchase.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I purchased from this seller on ebay and immediately sent a money order for the full amount. I got no response. this has gone on for many months, maybe even since before January. There is correspondence back from my inquiries but they got paid.They won't send the merchandise nor will they return my money.
MLH, Westfield, New Jersey
PS this was an under $50.00 purchase.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

I love this coin shop! They always have great stuff to dig through and are very fair and nice people! I have sold them a few items and was very happy with the prices I was paid! Basically... don't bother going anywhere else... these people are the best!!

5
★★★★★

I love this coin shop! They always have great stuff to dig through and are very fair and nice people! I have sold them a few items and was very happy with the prices I was paid! Basically... don't bother going anywhere else... these people are the best!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

The guys at Lost Dutchman is the best!!! I have been to most of the other shops in town and I will never go back after finding this place! They always treat me very fairly and greet me with a smile! All of the other shops in town seemed to be "bothered" when you want to come in and just look... but these guys encourage it and are more then willing to let me browse. I have also sold them several coins and was very pleased with the price they paid! Very fair and honest people there...

Jimmy

2
★★★★★

The guys at Lost Dutchman is the best!!! I have been to most of the other shops in town and I will never go back after finding this place! They always treat me very fairly and greet me with a smile! All of the other shops in town seemed to be "bothered" when you want to come in and just look... but these guys encourage it and are more then willing to let me browse. I have also sold them several coins and was very pleased with the price they paid! Very fair and honest people there...

Jimmy

Pros: honest, friendly, fair

Cons: there arent more shops like this

.

the lost dutchman is a good place to go if you are interested in coins. they have a lot of coins for sale in the store and their prices arent bad. they are also a good place to go if you need any jewelry appraised. The staff here is very helpful and seem to welcome questions. I thought the store was clean and well organized.

4
★★★★☆

the lost dutchman is a good place to go if you are interested in coins. they have a lot of coins for sale in the store and their prices arent bad. they are also a good place to go if you need any jewelry appraised. The staff here is very helpful and seem to welcome questions. I thought the store was clean and well organized.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

Lost Dutchman is primarily a coin shop, but they also buy jewelry, currency, and have appraisal services.
The times I have visited the store it has always been clean, well-organized, and generally inviting.
The staff is friendly, extremely knowledgeable (they're not afraid to say I don't know when they don't know - which isn't often), and treats you with respect regardless of whether you're buying a few cheap coins to complete a collection or purchasing a lot of valuable items.
I was particularly impressed by their selection of rare proof sets.
Prices have always been consistently lower than average (both locally and online), so they do well in that all-important aspect as well.

4
★★★★☆

Lost Dutchman is primarily a coin shop, but they also buy jewelry, currency, and have appraisal services.
The times I have visited the store it has always been clean, well-organized, and generally inviting.
The staff is friendly, extremely knowledgeable (they're not afraid to say I don't know when they don't know - which isn't often), and treats you with respect regardless of whether you're buying a few cheap coins to complete a collection or purchasing a lot of valuable items.
I was particularly impressed by their selection of rare proof sets.
Prices have always been consistently lower than average (both locally and online), so they do well in that all-important aspect as well.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

Matt is great! He is honest, fair, and great to deal with!

2
★★★★★

Matt is great! He is honest, fair, and great to deal with!

Pros: Inexpensive, Fair, Honest

Cons: none, none, none

Message from Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

It would be our pleasure to be YOUR local coin dealer.

More about Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

We pay top prices in the city for: Gold Silver Collectible Coins Currency Vintage & Collectible Watches Military Collectibles

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Lost Dutchman Rare Coins, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review